USDA B&I Feasibility Study: 16-Cabin Luxury Retreat and Wedding Venue, Park County, Montana
UnionMetric prepared this USDA B&I feasibility study for a rural-focused community bank participating in USDA B&I reviewing a financing request. The mandate scope and analytical conclusions are summarized below.
In 2025 UnionMetric prepared a feasibility study for a sixteen-cabin luxury retreat and wedding venue in Park County, Montana, financed through a rural-focused community bank participating in USDA B&I. The lender asked whether projected occupancy and ADR were defensible against the comparable supply set. The record states four findings: the visitor pool supports the occupancy band, comparable lodging runs above seventy percent stabilized, site access supports visitor capture, and the operator pro forma reconciles to comparable margins.
The Mandate
A private hospitality sponsor engaged UnionMetric to prepare a third-party feasibility study supporting a USDA B&I financing request for a project located in Park County, Montana. Total project capitalization fell within the over $100 million band. The capital provider, a rural-focused community bank participating in USDA B&I, required documentation consistent with current USDA B&I program review standards. The analytical question put to the team: whether projected occupancy and ADR were defensible against the comparable supply set.
Engagement Scope
- Primary market area defined as a 45-minute trade-area boundary
- Comparable supply set of 15 properties
- Demand model framework: captured-traffic and gravity model
- Financial projection horizon: five-year
- Site inspection completed; operator interviews where applicable
- Documentation aligned to USDA B&I review standards
Methodology Applied
Primary Market Area
The PMA was defined as a 45-minute trade-area boundary from the subject site, calibrated to the demand catchment behavior typical of hospitality assets in Montana. The boundary captured the population, employment, and competitive supply base relevant to the subject's operating thesis.
Supply and Demand Reconciliation
The comparable supply set comprised 15 properties operating within the PMA or in directly substitutable submarkets. Demand was modeled using a captured-traffic and gravity model approach over a five-year horizon. The reconciliation tested whether incremental supply, including the subject, could be absorbed within the projection window without compromising stabilized occupancy assumptions.
Capture Rate Calibration
The subject's capture rate was calibrated against the absorption capacity of the PMA. The analysis concluded that PMA absorption capacity exceeded subject build-out by a factor of 2.8x across the projection window, with a stabilized capture rate of 1.7 percent.
Analytical Conclusions
- The regional drive-time visitor pool supports the assumed occupancy band at the proposed rate position.
- Comparable cabin and lodging product within 60 miles operates above 70 percent stabilized occupancy.
- The site's road frontage and access support the assumed visitor capture rate.
- Operator pro forma assumptions reconcile to comparable operating margins.
Deliverable
The delivered report ran 169 pages with 48 exhibits across nine analytical sections, plus appendices documenting comparable supply data, demographic inputs, and financial projection assumptions. The document was prepared to the documentation standards of a rural-focused community bank participating in USDA B&I reviewing under USDA B&I program requirements.
Why this lodging asset is valued on prospective dates
A cabin retreat with a wedding venue earns from two sources, nightly lodging and event hire, and both ramp up slowly in a seasonal destination market. If the cabins are not yet open, the lender is asked to lend against a value that does not exist on opening day. The recorded scale band, over one hundred million dollars, places the file at the large end of rural lending, which makes the premise of value more important than usual.
The record does not say whether the cabins were built, being built or being acquired, so the premise discussion is the standard method. For a construction project under B&I, 7 CFR 5001.203(c) requires the lender to obtain both the as-is market value and the prospective market value as of construction completion. The Interagency Guidelines define the further step, prospective value as stabilized, as the value when the property is projected to reach stabilized occupancy after reasonable market exposure. For a cabin resort the as-completed value is usually lower than the stabilized value, and the lender needs to see the lease-up cost and time between them. The framework is in the prospective value guide.
Going-concern value is the other premise issue. Under part 5001, any business valuation or going-concern value in an appraisal must be deducted from the reconciled market value before collateral is discounted. A wedding venue's brand, booking relationships and event reputation are business value. The study therefore reports real estate value, equipment value and business value separately, and the lender discounts only the real estate and the equipment.
How the three approaches treat cabins and a venue
The income approach carries the weight. The study builds a stabilized year from cabin count, occupancy, ADR and the wedding calendar, deducts operating expenses, and capitalizes net operating income, then runs a discounted cash flow from opening through stabilization to catch the slow early years. The lender's question named occupancy and ADR, and those are the two drivers that move the value most for each point they change.
Sales comparison is thin for this asset because rural destination lodging trades rarely and no two properties share a view, a road or a wedding site. The study treats it as support for a per-cabin or per-key value range and as a check on the capitalization rate. Montana's confidentiality rule on sale prices, covered below, narrows the pool further.
The cost approach tests the build. Sixteen cabins plus a venue building, roads, utilities and septic or wells have a development cost the lender can test against contractor bids. When cost exceeds the income value, the difference is economic obsolescence, which the appraiser quantifies rather than ignores. Reconciliation then weights income, uses cost as the ceiling check and sales as the rate check. See the approaches guide.
What the four findings test
The market finding is that the regional drive-time visitor pool supports the assumed occupancy band at the proposed rate position. That is a demand test: it asks whether enough visitors within the drive-time area exist to fill sixteen cabins at the assumed rate, not whether any one comparable fills. The supply finding is that comparable cabin and lodging product within sixty miles operates above seventy percent stabilized occupancy, which sets the benchmark the pro forma occupancy is held against.
The site finding is that the site's road frontage and access support the assumed visitor capture rate. For a venue this also has a technical side: guest and vendor access, emergency vehicle access, parking and wastewater capacity limit how many people an event can host, and so cap wedding revenue per day.
The financial and management finding is that the operator's pro forma assumptions reconcile to comparable operating margins. This is the step that turns a revenue forecast into a coverage ratio. Part 5001 lets the Agency require an independent study when the application's five feasibility components do not show a basis for repayment, and the study answers that with each component documented. The loan-to-value test then runs on the concluded real estate value, after the business value is removed and the collateral discount is applied.
B&I rules for a large rural hospitality loan
The feasibility study trigger depends on business status, which the record does not state. Under 7 CFR 5001.306(a)(3)(i), a B&I guaranteed loan over $1,000,000 to a new business requires a feasibility study by an independent qualified consultant acceptable to the Agency. Part 5001 defines a new business as one in operation less than one full year, or one that has not reached stable operations, which would describe a resort in its first seasons.
Equity follows the same status. A new business with a construction project whose guarantee is requested before completion needs at least 25 percent balance sheet equity or a project investment of the same share, and equity cannot include appraisal surplus or a bargain purchase gain. For a project of the recorded size the study shows how the sponsor's contribution is built from cash and the appraisal.
The appraisal rules are a State Certified General Appraiser, USPAP compliance and a report that is not more than one year old. Real estate collateral valued over $250,000 needs an appraisal. A rural area under part 5001 is any area outside a city or town of more than 50,000 inhabitants, plus the urbanized areas next to such cities unless rural in character, so the site's address, not its county, decides eligibility.
Montana factors that shape value
Montana requires a realty transfer certificate declaring the consideration paid before a deed can be recorded, but the certificate and the price on it are not a public record. Agricultural and timber land sales are among the statutory exceptions to price disclosure on the certificate. So the appraiser gets price evidence through confirmed transactions and the Department of Revenue rather than from a public file, and a ranch-adjacent site may have comparables for which no certificate price exists.
Commercial and industrial property is class four, taxed at 1.5% of market value below six times the median commercial value and 1.9% at or above that level. Class four property is revalued every 2 years, so the tax line in the pro forma resets with each reappraisal cycle. The county basic levy of 33 mills for elementary school equalization is only one layer, but it shows the scale: on a market value taxed at the lower class rate it comes to about 0.0495 percent of market value before any local levy is added. Local mill levies may grow by prior-year taxes plus three years of average inflation, capped at 4%.
An objection to the classification and appraisal notice must be made within 30 days of the notice date to count for both years of the cycle, and an appeal from the Department of Revenue's determination goes to the county tax appeal board within 30 days. Montana's Board of Real Estate Appraisers issues the Certified General Appraiser credential that part 5001 calls for.
Questions about this engagement
Is a feasibility study required for a B&I loan on a new resort?
Yes where the guaranteed loan exceeds $1,000,000 and the borrower is a new business. Part 5001 requires an independent qualified consultant acceptable to the Agency, and defines a new business as one in operation less than one full year or not yet stable.
What did the record find about comparable occupancy?
That comparable cabin and lodging product within sixty miles operates above seventy percent stabilized occupancy. It is a benchmark for the pro forma, not the subject's concluded occupancy.
How does Montana price confidentiality affect the comparable set?
Transfer certificate prices are not public records, and agricultural and timber land sales are among the exceptions to price disclosure. Comparable lodging sales therefore have to be confirmed from other sources, and the study states which are confirmed.
How much equity does B&I require for a new-business construction project?
At least 25 percent of balance sheet equity, or an equivalent project investment, when the guarantee is requested before completion. Appraisal surplus cannot count toward it.
Why does going-concern value matter for a wedding venue?
Part 5001 deducts any business valuation from the reconciled market value before collateral is discounted. The venue's booking relationships and brand are business value, so the real estate collateral is smaller than the going-concern value.
How often does Montana revalue a commercial property?
Class four property is revalued every 2 years, and an objection filed within 30 days of the notice applies to both years of the cycle.
Related pages
Sources
- Office of the Federal Register (eCFR); rule issued by USDA Rural Development, eCFR :: 7 CFR Part 5001 -- Guaranteed Loanmaking and Servicing Regulations, accessed 17 November 2026.
- Montana Legislature (Montana Code Annotated 2025), MCA 15-6-134 Class four property, accessed 17 November 2026.
- Montana Legislature (Montana Code Annotated 2025), MCA 15-7-111 Periodic reappraisal of certain taxable property, accessed 17 November 2026.
- Montana Legislature (Montana Code Annotated 2025), MCA 20-9-331 Basic county tax for elementary equalization, accessed 17 November 2026.
- Montana Legislature (Montana Code Annotated 2025), MCA 15-10-420 Procedure for calculating levy, accessed 17 November 2026.
- Montana Legislature (Montana Code Annotated 2025), MCA 15-7-102 Notice of classification and appraisal, accessed 17 November 2026.
- OCC, Federal Reserve, FDIC, OTS and NCUA, published in the Federal Register, Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines (75 FR 77450, December 10, 2010), accessed 17 November 2026.
- Montana Legislature (Montana Code Annotated 2025), MCA 15-7-308 Disclosure of information restricted -- exceptions, accessed 17 November 2026.
- Montana Department of Labor and Industry, Montana Board of Real Estate Appraisers, accessed 17 November 2026.
Related Engagements
Truck Stop and Convenience Retail, Lincoln County, Nebraska
USDA B&I feasibility study supporting a gas station project in Lincoln County.
45-Pad Glamping Resort, Garfield County, Utah
USDA B&I feasibility study supporting a glamping project in Garfield County.
120,000-Square-Foot Cold Storage Warehouse, York County, Pennsylvania
USDA B&I feasibility study supporting a cold storage project in York County.
Primary research: 2026 Feasibility Methodology Atlas.