Which program finances the project, and what each requires
The program financing the project decides what the study must contain, who may prepare it and how the loan is sized. Generic studies most often go wrong here.
| Program | What the file needs | Governing rule |
|---|
| Bank construction loan | Feasibility or market study at the lender's discretion | Lender credit policy |
| Fannie Mae / Freddie Mac | Stabilized property, or a lease-up or forward-commitment execution sized on as-stabilized value | Fannie Mae Multifamily Selling and Servicing Guide; Freddie Mac Multifamily Seller/Servicer Guide |
| HUD 221(d)(4) | Independent market study and appraisal | HUD MAP Guide, Chapter 7; Mortgagee Letter 2026-01 |
| USDA Section 538 | Separate market study showing market and financial feasibility | 7 CFR Part 3565; Handbook HB-1-3565 |
| USDA Section 515 | Professional market study for 12 or more units | 7 CFR Part 3560; Handbook HB-1-3560 |
| LIHTC | Comprehensive market study by a disinterested party approved by the allocating agency | Internal Revenue Code §42(m)(1)(A)(iii); state Qualified Allocation Plan |
| SBA 7(a) / 504 | Not available for apartments held for rent; available for owner-occupied mixed-use buildings | 13 CFR 120.110(c) and 120.131; SBA SOP 50 10 |
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac
The agencies finance stabilized properties. Fannie Mae's Guide requires at least 85 percent physical and 70 percent economic occupancy at commitment and for the prior three months, and its Small Mortgage Loans (up to $9 million) require 90 percent physical occupancy for the 90 days before commitment. Freddie Mac requires at least 90 percent of units occupied for the three consecutive months before closing. Both agencies' term sheets show 80 percent maximum loan-to-value and 1.25x minimum coverage for standard executions, though at current rates coverage usually sets the loan below that ceiling.
Newly built projects reach the agencies through lease-up and forward-commitment executions. Freddie Mac's Optigo Lease-Up loan expects stabilization within 12 months of closing and is sized on the as-stabilized value, and Freddie Mac requires the appraiser to develop both an as-is and an as-stabilized value whenever a property has not reached stabilized operations. Our studies supply the absorption, rent and vacancy evidence behind that stabilized value. FHFA set 2026 multifamily purchase caps at $88 billion for each enterprise, with at least half reserved for mission-driven affordable housing.
HUD 221(d)(4)
HUD's construction-to-permanent loan is sized at the lowest of several tests. Under Mortgagee Letter 2026-01, market-rate projects are sized at up to 87 percent of cost and 1.15x coverage, and qualifying Middle Income projects (at least half the units restricted to households at or below 120 percent of area median income under a recorded use restriction of at least ten years) at up to 90 percent and 1.11x, each with a 7 percent vacancy factor. Statutory per-unit limits also apply: HUD indexed them for 2026 (91 FR 24597), Section 211 of the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act (P.L. 119-101, July 11, 2026) raised the statutory base amounts, and HUD's high-cost percentage is currently 270 percent, with 315 percent available project by project (Mortgagee Letter 2026-05). Confirm with your MAP lender how HUD is applying the new statutory amounts to your application.
HUD requires the market study and the appraisal to be complete, independent reports meeting Chapter 7 of the MAP Guide, including an opinion of market feasibility, absorption to sustaining occupancy, capture rates and achievable rents.
USDA Section 538 and Section 515
Section 538 guarantees, usually layered with low-income housing tax credits, are USDA's active path for new rural rental housing. USDA guarantees up to 90 percent of the loan; loans may reach 90 percent of the lesser of cost or value for for-profit owners and 97 percent for nonprofits; tenants must earn no more than 115 percent of area median income at move-in; projects need at least five units in an eligible rural area; and stabilization means 90 percent occupancy for 90 days (7 CFR Part 3565). USDA will not guarantee a loan where existing Agency-guaranteed properties in the market are more than 15 percent vacant because of market conditions (7 CFR 3565.213). Handbook HB-1-3565 requires a separate market study covering employment, population, tenure, incomes, permits, a rental survey with vacancies, rent overburden, a demand projection and tax credit units.
Two September 2026 Federal Register notices changed the terms. 91 FR 60930 raised the Option 3 loan-to-cost limit to 80 percent and opened a pilot (October 9, 2026 to September 25, 2028) that lowers minimum coverage to 1.11x for the first 200 Section 538 loans closed. 91 FR 61820 set guarantee fees at 65 basis points upfront and 35 annually, or 60 and 25 for workforce housing (80 to 115 percent of area median income), preservation of existing USDA properties, and new construction in Qualified Opportunity Zones.
Section 515 direct loans can still legally fund new construction, but the program received $50 million for FY2026 and works mainly as a preservation tool. Its market rules are stricter: USDA rejects a 515 application where existing assisted housing in the area has not reached projected occupancy or is 5 percent or more vacant, unless the state sets a different standard (7 CFR 3560.57(d)). USDA's Business and Industry program does not finance rental housing.
LIHTC and affordable housing
Tax credit projects need a market study by a disinterested party approved by the allocating agency (Internal Revenue Code §42(m)(1)(A)(iii)), and state rules set the content and the acceptable capture rates, which vary widely from state to state. We model restricted rents alongside market rents by income tier, because the affordability cushion that protects deeply restricted units can disappear for higher-tier units once market rents soften toward their caps. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (P.L. 119-21) made two permanent changes that improve feasibility: a 12 percent increase in 9 percent credit allocations beginning in 2026, and a reduction of the 50 percent bond-financing test for 4 percent credits to 25 percent for buildings placed in service after 2025 with bonds issued after that date.
SBA: owner-occupied mixed-use only
SBA 7(a) and 504 loans cannot finance apartments held for rent: businesses primarily engaged in owning real estate and leasing it are ineligible (13 CFR 120.110(c)). They can finance an owner-occupied mixed-use building with apartments above the business. The owner may rent the residential space to third parties under the same occupancy rules as commercial tenants (13 CFR 120.131): occupy at least 51 percent of an existing building and lease up to 49 percent, or for new construction occupy at least 60 percent, lease up to 20 percent permanently, and plan to occupy the remaining space within three years and all of it within ten. Where the business requires a resident owner or manager, that residential space may be financed but may not exceed 49 percent of the property. SBA's SOP 50 10 8.1 governs SBA loans from October 1, 2026.