Gas Station Feasibility Study

    Independent feasibility analysis for gas stations, convenience stores, truck stops and fueling-station developments financed with SBA 7(a), SBA 504 and USDA B&I loans, built around the two businesses operating under one roof.

    By Robert Mitchell, MAI, SRA, AI-GRS, Founder & Principal Appraiser · Last reviewed October 20, 2026

    Request a Consultation

    What a gas station feasibility study decides

    Whether the site can sell enough fuel and inside merchandise, at realistic margins, to carry its debt. SBA does not require a feasibility study on every gas station loan; under 13 CFR 120.160(b) it may require one, and lenders routinely do for ground-up construction, start-ups and changes of ownership. What SBA does require on a gas station file is a going-concern appraisal, a Phase I environmental site assessment, and, where the station operates under a fuel supply or dealer agreement, a brand listed on the SBA Franchise Directory.

    What Is a Gas Station Feasibility Study?

    A gas station feasibility study is the independent market and financial analysis lenders rely on for this special-purpose property type. It answers whether a proposed or acquired site can achieve the fuel volume, inside-sales revenue, and overall profitability needed to service its debt under the conservative assumptions an SBA credit demands. It is not a valuation, and it is not a business plan. It is an independent assessment of whether the project works.

    The defining feature of the analysis is that a fueling station is two businesses, not one. The income approach bifurcates fuel operations from convenience-store operations, because they behave nothing alike. Fuel is a high-volume, thin-margin traffic driver whose economics are dominated by volume and operating cost. The convenience store, and increasingly its foodservice program, is where profitability actually accumulates. A study that underwrites the site on fuel alone is underwriting the wrong business. Where a project also requires an opinion of value, that is the separate role of an appraisal, and for a going concern that appraisal carries specific requirements set out below. If your project requires a property valuation, explore our gas station appraisal services. Long-term fuel demand and the capital events over a 25-year loan are covered in gas station feasibility and EV exposure across a 25-year term.

    The 2026 Convenience and Fuel Retail Context

    Gas station feasibility has to be read against a structural shift in where the money is made. U.S. convenience industry sales reached $817.5 billion in 2025. Fuel accounted for $476.3 billion, down 5.4 percent as average prices fell, while in-store sales reached $341.2 billion, up 1.7 percent and growing for the twenty-third consecutive year (NACS, April 2026).

    The profit split is what reframes a feasibility study. Fuel was 65 percent of sales dollars but only 38.8 percent of gross profit dollars. Inside the store, foodservice was 28.5 percent of in-store sales and 38.9 percent of in-store gross profit, up from 11.9 percent of in-store sales in 2005, and prepared food has grown to 73.9 percent of foodservice sales from 66.4 percent in 2021.

    The store base is large and fragmented. NACS counted 151,975 convenience stores at the end of 2025, of which 122,620 sell fuel, an eight-year high. Convenience stores sell an estimated 80 percent of the fuel purchased in the United States, and 63 percent of stores are owned by companies operating ten or fewer stores. Volume benchmarks vary by source and sample: NACS publishes figures from about 2,500 gallons a day for the average fueling location to about 4,000 gallons a day for the average convenience store, which is why our studies benchmark a site against comparable stations in its own trade area rather than a national average.

    The Foodservice Profit Engine

    Because foodservice now generates the largest share of in-store gross profit, it deserves separate analytical treatment in any modern fueling-station study, and it is where new builds and repositionings increasingly win or lose. Foodservice is 38.9 percent of in-store gross profit on 28.5 percent of in-store sales, and prepared food is 73.9 percent of foodservice sales. The trajectory is clear: the store is becoming a quick-service restaurant that happens to sell fuel.

    This carries direct feasibility consequences. A foodservice-forward format costs more to build and equip and is the most operationally demanding part of the business, dependent on labor, supply chain, cold storage and food-safety execution. Our studies model foodservice on a ramp to stabilization rather than at a mature chain's numbers, because assuming day-one performance that takes an experienced operator years to reach is the most common way a fuel-and-store pro forma overstates profitability.

    SBA and USDA Requirements for Gas Stations

    Gas stations are owner-operated going-concern businesses, which makes them SBA-eligible, and SBA treats them as special-purpose property. The rules below decide how the file is financed and what the study must support.

    RequirementSBA 7(a)SBA 504USDA B&I
    Feasibility studyLender's choice; SBA may require one (13 CFR 120.160(b))Lender's and CDC's choiceRequired for guaranteed loans over $1,000,000 to a new business (7 CFR 5001.306)
    EquityAt least 10% for start-ups and changes of ownership15% for a special-purpose property (typically 50% bank / 35% CDC / 15% borrower); 20% if the business has also operated two years or less (50/30/20) (13 CFR 120.910)Balance sheet equity of 10% to 25% depending on the borrower (7 CFR 5001.105(d))
    CoverageAt least 1.15x; 1.25x on historical earnings for most acquisitions under SOP 50 10 8.1Tested on the bank loan and debenture togetherEBITDA less replacement capital expenditures over principal and interest (7 CFR 5001.3)
    AppraisalGoing-concern appraisal for special-purpose propertySameAppraisal under 7 CFR 5001.203
    EnvironmentalPhase I required on gas station loansSameEnvironmental review under 7 CFR Part 1970
    BrandFuel supply, dealer and jobber agreements are franchises; brand must be on the SBA Franchise DirectorySameLender review

    The going-concern appraisal

    For special-purpose property, SBA requires a going-concern appraisal by a state Certified General appraiser who has completed at least four going-concern appraisals of equivalent special-use property in the past 36 months, stated in the appraisal's qualifications. The appraisal allocates separate values to land, building, equipment and intangible assets. The feasibility study is the forward-looking companion: the appraisal states what the going concern is worth, and the study tests whether the projected operation supports the loan.

    Changes of ownership under SOP 50 10 8.1

    SOP 50 10 8.1 governs SBA loans numbered on or after October 1, 2026. It tests most acquisitions at 1.25x coverage on the business's historical earnings rather than projections, and it expands the independent business valuation and quality-of-earnings requirements for changes of ownership. Your lender will confirm which apply to your file; our studies verify the seller's historical fuel gallons and inside sales against tax returns, fuel supplier statements and point-of-sale data so the historical test can be documented.

    Environmental, brand and eligibility rules specific to fuel

    • Environmental: SBA requires at least a Phase I environmental site assessment on every gas station loan, documented compliance with tank and equipment testing, and a Phase II where the environmental professional recommends one (SOP 50 10 8, Appendix 7). Phase I work follows ASTM E1527-21 under EPA's All Appropriate Inquiries rule.
    • Brand: SBA treats agreements covered by the Petroleum Marketing Practices Act, including fuel supply, dealer and jobber agreements, as franchises, so the brand must appear on the SBA Franchise Directory before the loan can proceed (SOP 50 10 8, Section A, Chapter 1, Paragraph G).
    • Lottery: a business earning more than one-third of its prior-year gross revenue from legal gambling is ineligible; commissions from state lottery ticket sales count toward that third (13 CFR 120.110(g)).
    • Size: SBA size standards are $36.5 million in average annual receipts for gasoline stations with convenience stores (NAICS 457110), $33.5 million for other gasoline stations (457120) and 100 employees for fuel dealers (457210) (13 CFR 121.201). Receipts include fuel sales, so high-volume sites should check the test early.

    USDA B&I for rural fuel and travel centers

    Rural fueling and travel-center projects can be financed through USDA's Business and Industry program in areas outside any city or town of more than 50,000 people and outside the urbanized area contiguous to such a city, a test that excludes many highway-interchange sites on the edge of metro areas (7 CFR 5001.3). For loans obligated in FY2026, B&I guarantees are 85 percent under $5 million and 80 percent from $5 million to $25 million, with a 3.0 percent upfront fee and a 0.55 percent annual fee. For a rural travel center, diesel rather than gasoline is usually the volume driver, and demand turns on freight-corridor and truck-traffic data rather than passenger counts.

    How gas station SBA loans have actually performed

    Gas stations are often described as high-risk SBA credits. SBA's own public loan-level data does not support that. Published tabulations of SBA's 7(a) and 504 FOIA data put lifetime dollar losses on gas station 7(a) loans at about 3.5 percent of dollars approved, and loans approved in fiscal 2010 to 2019 charged off at about 3.4 percent by count, against about 6.4 percent for all 7(a) loans. Figures near 15 percent that circulate for gas stations measure something different: the share of loans that have already resolved (paid off or charged off) that charged off, and on that basis the 7(a) program as a whole runs at about 16 percent.

    What drives a gas station loss is specific and testable: fuel volume asserted rather than supported, a seller's historical numbers accepted without verification, foodservice assumed at a mature chain's level, environmental exposure left unpriced, and a supply agreement on terms the operator has not secured. Lenders commonly underwrite fuel credits above SBA's floors and stress-test earnings; our studies show coverage at the base case and at downside cases so the lender can apply its own policy.

    Going-Concern Value vs. Real Estate Value

    The split between fuel and store reappears at the level of value. The going-concern value of a station combines the real estate (land, building and fueling improvements), the equipment, and the business intangibles, including goodwill, the fuel supply agreement, branding and the assembled workforce. SBA's appraisal rule requires the appraiser to allocate value across these components, and SBA 504 finances fixed assets rather than goodwill, so the financeable real estate and equipment can be well below the going-concern value. A study that understands how value is allocated keeps the loan request aligned with what the collateral and the cash flow actually support.

    Net lease pricing shows how the market values the real estate on its own: The Boulder Group's Q3 2026 tenant profiles put 7-Eleven at 4.80 to 5.15 percent for 15-year leases and 5.90 to 6.20 percent for 5-year leases, against a 6.92 percent average for single-tenant net lease property overall. Owner-operated stations without a corporate lease trade on the business's earnings and carry materially higher capitalization rates.

    Feasibility Study vs. Appraisal vs. Business Plan

    These three documents answer different questions and are not substitutes for one another.

    A feasibility study answers whether the project should be done, and under what conditions. It is independent and forward-looking, and it produces the volume, revenue, and coverage analysis the lender relies on.

    A business plan answers how the operator will run the business. It is prepared from the borrower's perspective and advocates for the project.

    An appraisal answers what the going concern is worth. It is an opinion of value prepared under USPAP, with the allocation across land, building, equipment and intangibles described above.

    A lender financing a start-up, a ground-up build, or a change of ownership generally needs all three, because each answers a question the others do not. A feasibility study that contains no opinion of value is a consulting assignment, not an appraisal; where our engagement includes a going-concern value, that value is developed and reported as a USPAP appraisal by a state-certified general appraiser.

    The Core Analytical Challenges

    The feasibility analysis for a fueling station is among the most demanding in commercial real estate, and three challenges dominate it.

    The bifurcated profit-and-loss. The model separates fuel and store because their economics diverge. Gross retail fuel margins have averaged roughly 35 to 40 cents per gallon over the past five years, but after card fees, distribution and store operating costs, net margin typically falls to about 10 to 15 cents per gallon (NACS). Inside merchandise and foodservice carry far higher margins than fuel. Modeling these streams independently, then reconciling them, is what produces a credible net operating income rather than a blended figure that obscures where the business actually earns.

    Fuel volume and capture. Site selection and traffic are the dominant variables. Traffic count, intersection configuration, ingress and egress, visibility, and proximity to highway ramps determine volume potential. We project volume two ways and reconcile them: from state DOT traffic counts, a capture rate and gallons per fill (in our experience, well-positioned sites capture roughly 1.5 to 3.0 percent of average daily traffic), and from the actual gallons of comparable stations in the trade area. For travel centers, the analysis shifts to truck-classification and freight-corridor data, because for a diesel-led site the quality of traffic, a logistics stop point, matters more than raw count.

    Credit card processing. Interchange is the largest controllable expense after labor. Card fees reached a record $21.3 billion industry-wide in 2025; NACS put them at about 8.4 cents per gallon in 2023, a large share of the net fuel margin. A pro forma that does not model interchange explicitly overstates fuel profitability.

    Environmental risk is material to feasibility. Tank compliance, contamination and remediation affect both development cost and long-term operating expense; EPA's 2022 study of leaking tank cleanups found median costs per site ranging from about $27,000 in Virginia to about $266,000 for active remediation in Kansas. Our studies carry environmental compliance and a capital-events reserve in the expense structure; the environmental due diligence itself is a separate scope the borrower and lender obtain.

    Trade-Area and Demand Methodology

    Fuel volume is the output of a demand analysis, and the quality of that analysis is what separates a defensible projection from a hopeful one. Our studies define the trade area by drive-time radii around the site, typically a sequence of short intervals that capture both the immediate catchment and the broader market, and then layer the variables that determine capture within it: resident and daytime population, employment and commuting patterns, the configuration and accessibility of the site, and competitive density.

    Capture is then estimated against this evidence rather than applied as a flat assumption. A site with strong access on a high-count corridor with limited competition supports a higher capture rate than a constrained site facing several established competitors, and the projection reflects that difference. For a neighborhood site, resident and daytime population dominate; for a highway or interstate site, pass-by traffic and ramp proximity dominate; for a travel center, freight-corridor position and truck stop points dominate. Matching the methodology to the site type is what makes the volume forecast credible to a reviewer.

    Development Cost Structure

    A feasibility study tests projected performance against what the project costs to build. The most reliable public benchmarks are franchisor disclosures. Circle K's 2026 Franchise Disclosure Document puts a new store and fuel site at $3.1 million to $9.4 million before land, with a car wash as an option and a minimum site of 50,000 square feet. Holiday's 2025 disclosure puts a new store and fuel site at $3.4 million to $7.7 million including land. Store size, fuel positions, foodservice and the market drive the spread. Underground storage is a major line: EPA's cost analysis for its 2015 tank rule put a double-walled tank with piping at about $88,700 installed, in 2006 dollars, and current costs are higher. Casey's reported in June 2026 that an acquired store costs about $1 million less, on average, than a new build.

    The study uses current contractor bids and these benchmarks to test whether the development budget is realistic and whether the resulting basis is supportable by the projected cash flow and the going-concern value. Retail motor fuel outlets can qualify as 15-year property eligible for bonus depreciation, which affects after-tax returns; confirm the treatment with your tax advisor.

    Fuel Supply Strategy: Branded vs. Unbranded

    The fuel supply agreement is a core input to the margin projection and to the financing. A branded agreement brings brand recognition, marketing support and image standards, against volume commitments, pricing terms and assignment obligations. An unbranded position offers pricing flexibility without brand support. Both affect value, and for SBA a branded agreement also means the brand must be on the SBA Franchise Directory. Our studies evaluate the agreement's term, volume commitments, pricing structure and image requirements as a primary variable, because a projection that assumes supply terms the operator has not secured is one a reviewer cannot rely on.

    The EV Transition and Long-Term Fuel Demand

    A responsible study addresses long-term fuel demand without overstating it. The Energy Information Administration forecast U.S. gasoline consumption to decline about 1 percent in 2026 as fuel economy gains outpace miles driven. Electric vehicles were about 6.4 percent of new-vehicle sales in the third quarter of 2026 (Cox Automotive), down from a record 10.6 percent a year earlier after the federal vehicle credits ended, and the federal charging-equipment credit under Section 30C ended for property placed in service after June 30, 2026.

    The longer view is uncertain, and credibility means presenting the range. Boston Consulting Group's 2019 analysis found that, if electric and autonomous vehicles took off rapidly, up to 80 percent of the fuel-retail network as then constituted could become unprofitable within about fifteen years; its 2024 analysis of an electric-dominance scenario, with electric vehicles reaching about 55 percent of the vehicle stock by 2035, put up to one quarter of sites at risk. The U.S. is far from that scenario today. The consistent implication is that inside sales and foodservice are the hedge against fuel decline, which is why a forward-looking study weights them.

    Change of Ownership and Repositioning

    A large share of fueling-station financing is for acquisition rather than construction, and these transactions carry their own analytical demands. SBA 7(a) is the usual change-of-ownership vehicle, and under SOP 50 10 8.1 the acquisition is tested on the business's historical earnings. The central diligence task is verifying the seller's historical fuel volume and inside-sales performance, because the purchase price and the financing rest directly on figures that must be substantiated rather than accepted.

    Repositioning an underperforming independent is a common value-creation strategy: converting to a major fuel brand and adding a foodservice program can lift both volume and margin, at a capital cost the study must price from contractor bids. The market supplies steady opportunity for this, because 63 percent of U.S. convenience stores belong to companies with ten or fewer stores, and owners without succession plans keep bringing sites to market. A feasibility study for an acquisition tests whether the repositioning thesis is supportable, accounting for the conversion capital, the time to realize the uplift, and the environmental and operational risks of taking over an existing site.

    Our Methodology and Data Sources

    Every conclusion is traceable to a source. We draw on the NACS State of the Industry data for fuel and inside-sales benchmarks, the U.S. Energy Information Administration for fuel-demand and EV outlook, OPIS for fuel pricing and margin, state DOT continuous-count stations and FHWA freight data for traffic, and CoStar, The Boulder Group, and Marcus and Millichap for real estate and capital-markets benchmarks. Where data providers diverge, we disclose the divergence. Studies are prepared to the requirements of SBA SOP 50 10 8.1 and, for rural projects, 7 CFR Part 5001.

    What Our Feasibility Study Covers

    Trade-area and demand analysis with drive-time and capture-rate methodology (passenger and, for travel centers, truck-classification and freight-corridor analysis)
    Traffic-count analysis and fuel-volume projections
    Competitive fuel-station inventory and market-share analysis
    Convenience-store and foodservice revenue and margin modeling, on a realistic ramp
    Fuel-supply agreement evaluation, branded and unbranded
    Development cost and budget review against current benchmarks
    Operating-expense rationalization (fuel cost of goods, labor, credit-card interchange, environmental compliance)
    Financial pro forma with a bifurcated fuel and store profit-and-loss, DSCR, break-even, and sensitivity analysis
    Going-concern value reconciliation across real estate, equipment, and intangibles
    Environmental and regulatory risk assessment, qualitatively and as a cost input
    EV charging integration feasibility, where applicable

    Who Needs This Study?

    SBA lenders and CDCs underwriting gas station and convenience store loans

    Developers planning new gas station and c-store construction

    Investors and buyers acquiring or repositioning existing fuel-retail operations, including change-of-ownership transactions

    Branded fuel dealers evaluating new locations

    USDA Business and Industry borrowers and lenders for rural fuel and travel-center projects

    Our Process

    1

    Engagement & Scoping

    We define the project scope, identify key assumptions, and establish the analytical framework tailored to your property type and financing program.

    2

    Market Research & Data Collection

    Our team collects primary and secondary market data including demographics, competitive supply, demand drivers, and industry benchmarks.

    3

    Financial Analysis & Modeling

    We build detailed financial pro formas with revenue projections, operating expense rationalization, DSCR analysis, and sensitivity testing.

    4

    Report Delivery & Review

    You receive a comprehensive, lender-ready feasibility report with clear conclusions, supporting data, and a review call to discuss findings.

    Why Choose UnionMetric

    Institutional Quality

    Our reports meet the standards of major SBA lenders, USDA Rural Development, and institutional investors.

    Independent & Third-Party

    We maintain strict independence from borrowers, developers, and operators to ensure unbiased conclusions.

    Nationwide Coverage

    We serve projects across all 50 states with expertise spanning every major CRE asset class.

    Fees and turnaround

    Every engagement is quoted at a fixed fee before work starts, based on the program, whether the site is existing or ground-up, the store format and whether a going-concern appraisal is engaged alongside the study. The fee does not depend on the conclusion or on whether the loan closes. Typical price ranges by program are set out in our feasibility study cost guide.

    What we need to start: the site address and site plan, the development budget or purchase contract, the fuel supply agreement or brand proposal, the financing program and lender, and for an existing station two to three years of tax returns, fuel supplier gallon statements and point-of-sale reports.

    Request a Consultation

    Contact our team to discuss your project and receive a customized proposal with scope, timeline, and fee estimate.

    (214) 855-0355
    hello@unionmetricfeasibility.com

    How we verify this page

    Program rules on this page are checked against 13 CFR Parts 120 and 121, SBA SOP 50 10 and 7 CFR Part 5001, and every industry figure names its source and date. Last verified October 20, 2026.

    DateChange
    October 20, 2026Page revised: SBA 504 equity and CDC structure corrected; going-concern appraisal, Phase I, franchise, lottery and size rules added; SBA loss data, NACS figures and build-cost benchmarks re-sourced; unsupported figures removed.

    Related Blog Posts

    View All
    Gas Stations

    Zoning for Gas Stations: A Complete Guide for Developers, Lenders, and Investors

    Zoning is the single largest risk factor in new gas station development. Setback requirements ranging from 30 to 1,500 feet across jurisdictions, increasing drive-through restrictions, and growing community opposition make early zoning verification essential before any capital is committed.

    March 23, 2026
    50 min read
    Gas Stations

    Gas Stations and Convenience Stores 2026: Foodservice Fuels the Future

    The U.S. had 151,975 convenience stores as of December 31, 2025, a decrease of 280 stores and the second consecutive year of net decline. The most dramatic structural shift is in foodservice: prepared food and dispensed beverages now account for 28.5% of in-store sales (NACS State of the Industry data, April 2026).

    March 15, 2026
    35 min read
    Industry Guides

    Rationalizing the Development Budget: How a Feasibility Study Tests Project Cost Across Seven Asset Classes

    A development budget is not a number the sponsor hands the lender. It is a hypothesis about cost that a feasibility study must test against three independent standards: completeness, benchmark evidence and the value of what gets built. This is how that test is run, line by line, for the seven asset classes that dominate SBA, USDA and community-bank construction lending in 2026.

    October 21, 2026
    59 min read
    USDA / Regulatory

    How USDA Deducts Going-Concern Value From Collateral: Hotels, Gas Stations and Car Washes

    Under 7 CFR 5001.203, any business or going-concern value in an appraisal comes off the reconciled market value before the lender's discount is applied. For hotels, fuel stations and car washes, that single sentence can remove between 5 and 40 per cent of the appraised figure and leave a B&I loan short of collateral before underwriting has properly begun. This is how the deduction works, how appraisers isolate the number, what the federal audit record shows, and how a lender sizes and closes the gap.

    October 7, 2026
    33 min read
    Gas Stations

    Gas Station Feasibility and EV Exposure Across a 25-Year Term

    An SBA real estate loan on a fuel site runs 25 years. No credible forecast of United States gasoline demand runs that long, and the agency that publishes the best known one says plainly that it is not making predictions. A feasibility study cannot resolve that by guessing at adoption curves. What it can do is separate what is measured from what is modelled, price the capital events that are actually schedulable, and hand the lender an honest band instead of a false number.

    September 8, 2026
    28 min read

    Frequently Asked Questions