The Core Analytical Challenges
The feasibility analysis for a fueling station is among the most demanding in commercial real estate, and three challenges dominate it.
The bifurcated profit-and-loss. The model separates fuel and store because their economics diverge. Gross retail fuel margins have averaged roughly 35 to 40 cents per gallon over the past five years, but after card fees, distribution and store operating costs, net margin typically falls to about 10 to 15 cents per gallon (NACS). Inside merchandise and foodservice carry far higher margins than fuel. Modeling these streams independently, then reconciling them, is what produces a credible net operating income rather than a blended figure that obscures where the business actually earns.
Fuel volume and capture. Site selection and traffic are the dominant variables. Traffic count, intersection configuration, ingress and egress, visibility, and proximity to highway ramps determine volume potential. We project volume two ways and reconcile them: from state DOT traffic counts, a capture rate and gallons per fill (in our experience, well-positioned sites capture roughly 1.5 to 3.0 percent of average daily traffic), and from the actual gallons of comparable stations in the trade area. For travel centers, the analysis shifts to truck-classification and freight-corridor data, because for a diesel-led site the quality of traffic, a logistics stop point, matters more than raw count.
Credit card processing. Interchange is the largest controllable expense after labor. Card fees reached a record $21.3 billion industry-wide in 2025; NACS put them at about 8.4 cents per gallon in 2023, a large share of the net fuel margin. A pro forma that does not model interchange explicitly overstates fuel profitability.
Environmental risk is material to feasibility. Tank compliance, contamination and remediation affect both development cost and long-term operating expense; EPA's 2022 study of leaking tank cleanups found median costs per site ranging from about $27,000 in Virginia to about $266,000 for active remediation in Kansas. Our studies carry environmental compliance and a capital-events reserve in the expense structure; the environmental due diligence itself is a separate scope the borrower and lender obtain.