Gas station feasibility is fundamentally a story about two businesses operating under one roof: a fuel distribution operation with razor-thin 1% to 2% net margins and a convenience retail operation generating 30% to 40% gross margins that produces the actual profit.
Gas station feasibility is fundamentally a story about two businesses operating under one roof: a fuel distribution operation with razor-thin 1% to 2% net margins, a cost structure that differs significantly from car wash pro forma economics and truck stop operating expenses and a convenience retail operation generating 30% to 40% gross margins that produces the actual profit. Lenders evaluate gas station pro formas primarily through the Debt Service Coverage Ratio, which must account for the thin-margin nature of fuel retail. NACS 2024 data confirms that fuel contributed $501.9 billion in revenue but only approximately 30% of gross profit, while in-store sales of $335.5 billion (a 22nd consecutive record) generated approximately 70% of gross profit. Lenders must see these operations bifurcated in the pro forma. Understanding zoning requirements for gas stations is a prerequisite to development. This guide provides the line-item benchmarks that SBA underwriters and commercial appraisers expect to find in a credible gas station operating expense rationalization.
Fuel Economics: Margins Measured in Pennies
Fuel cost of goods sold runs 90% to 92% of fuel revenue, leaving gross margins of 10 to 15 cents per gallon before operating expenses. After credit card processing fees, which alone consume approximately 8 cents per gallon at current prices, net fuel profit drops to 3 to 7 cents per gallon. At the EIA's 2025 national average of $3.10 per gallon for regular gasoline (down from $3.31 in 2024, with approximately $3.00 forecast for 2026), credit card fees at 2.5% equal approximately 7.5 to 8.3 cents per gallon.
Diesel prices average $3.65 to $3.70 per gallon in 2025, down from $3.76 in 2024, with 2026 forecasts at $3.46 to $3.50. Diesel crack spreads are actually widening, from $0.52 per gallon in 2024 to a projected $0.84 per gallon in 2026, which should modestly improve wholesale-to-retail margins. A typical gas station sells approximately 1.4 million gallons annually, generating roughly $4.8 million in fuel revenue.
Credit Card Processing: The Silent Profit Killer
Credit card processing is often the largest single operating expense after COGS and labor. With approximately 75% of gas station transactions paid by card, processing fees of 1.7% to 3.0% on fuel sales translate to enormous dollar figures. A station doing $4.8 million in fuel sales at 2.5% processing pays approximately $120,000 per year in card fees. Casey's General Stores reported $63.8 million in credit card fees in a single quarter.
Visa's interchange rate for fuel is 1.15% plus $0.25 per transaction, capped at $1.10, but the total merchant discount rate including acquirer and processor markups ranges from 1.7% to 3.0% or more. This line item is frequently underestimated in pro formas, and it is a critical error that lenders will catch. A feasibility study that models credit card fees at 1.5% of fuel sales is immediately suspect; the realistic range is 2.0% to 3.0%, and lenders will adjust the pro forma upward if this line item appears understated.
Convenience Store Margins by Category
Overall c-store gross margins run 29% to 35% depending on product mix, with Casey's reporting inside gross margins of 40% to 41% in FY2024. The category breakdown reveals why foodservice investment is accelerating. Fountain beverages carry 85% to 90% gross margins, the highest of any category. Prepared food/foodservice achieves 35% to 40% gross margin, now representing 28.7% of in-store sales and 39.6% of in-store gross profit dollars. Candy runs 45% to 50%. Packaged beverages achieve 25% to 43% depending on category. Other tobacco products deliver 20% or more margin and have eclipsed beer as the third-largest gross profit contributor. Cigarettes carry only 11% to 15% margin on approximately 24% of in-store sales, the only top-10 category with negative growth in 2024. Beer/wine margins run 22% to 25%.
The average in-store market basket is $8.98 per transaction against COGS of $5.84, with facility expense and labor adding $1.88 per transaction, resulting in an inside operating profit of negative $0.11 per transaction before fuel margin contribution. This underscores why fuel and c-store operations must be evaluated together in every feasibility study.
Labor, Utilities, and Overhead
Labor costs register at just 3% to 5% of total revenue (because fuel revenue dominates the denominator) but represent 15% to 20% of inside sales, which is the operationally meaningful benchmark. Casey's reports total store expenses at 22.3% to 22.5% of net inside sales. A typical station employs 6 to 15 workers (mix of full-time and part-time), with 24-hour operations requiring 8 to 12 FTEs.
Utility costs run $1,500 to $3,000 per month ($18,000 to $36,000 per year), with electricity averaging $1,900 per month for a typical 3,460-square-foot store at the commercial rate of 12.66 cents per kWh. Shrinkage/theft averages approximately $2,000 per store per month ($24,000 per year), with overall retail shrink rates at 1.5% to 1.6% of sales. External theft accounts for 36% to 37% of shrink and internal/employee theft for 29%.
Environmental Compliance and Insurance
Underground storage tank compliance costs $5,000 to $15,000 per year in routine testing, monitoring, and inspections, with UST pollution liability insurance running $500 to $10,000 or more per tank annually depending on tank age. EPA requires $1 million per occurrence/$1 million aggregate financial responsibility for petroleum marketers under 40 CFR Part 280. Remediation costs, if contamination occurs, average $130,000 to $1 million or more when groundwater is involved. Property taxes range from $5,000 to $25,000 or more per year depending on jurisdiction, with high-value California and Texas properties reaching $40,000 or more.
Environmental liability is a dealbreaker issue in gas station feasibility. Lenders require Phase I Environmental Site Assessments for every acquisition, and any indication of prior contamination triggers Phase II testing at $10,000 to $50,000. Pro formas must include environmental insurance as a line item, not bury it in a general insurance category. The cost difference between a station with newer double-wall tanks and one with aging single-wall tanks can be $15,000 to $30,000 per year in insurance premiums alone.
Franchise and Brand Fee Structures
Branded stations operate under varying fee models. BP/AMPM charges a $30,000 to $70,000 initial franchise fee plus 3% to 12% ongoing royalty and 5% advertising fee. Chevron/ExtraMile requires $15,000 initial plus 4% royalty and 2% ad fee. Circle K charges $25,000 initial plus 3% to 5.5% royalty. 7-Eleven's model is unique: $50,000 to $750,000 initial fee with 50% of gross profit as the ongoing charge. Many major oil brands (Shell, BP) use licensing/branding agreements rather than traditional franchises, sometimes structured as commission-based arrangements at 2 to 3 cents per gallon.
The choice of branding model has substantial impact on the pro forma. A branded station paying 5% royalty plus 2% advertising on $335,000 in monthly inside sales faces $23,450 per month in franchise obligations, while an unbranded station retains that margin entirely. However, branded stations typically achieve 10% to 20% higher fuel volume due to brand recognition and loyalty programs. The feasibility study must model both scenarios to demonstrate which structure optimizes DSCR.
Net Margins and How Lenders Evaluate the Deal
Overall gas station net profit margins are 1% to 5% of total revenue, with the industry average across IRS data showing approximately 1.4%. Sole proprietors typically achieve 3% to 5%, while multi-store chains can reach 10% through scale efficiencies. When c-store operations are separated from fuel, the c-store alone generates approximately 10% or more net margins.
Lenders require 10-year financial projections with monthly/annual cash flow, a minimum DSCR of 1.20x to 1.25x, and expense assumptions benchmarked against comparable stations' actual P&L statements. Valuation typically uses a Gross Profit Multiplier rather than cap rate, since OpEx volatility distorts NOI-based approaches. EBITDA multiples for small/medium stations run 3.45x to 4.49x. Feasibility studies cost $6,500 to $10,000 for standard gas stations.
Common Pro Forma Mistakes That Get Gas Station Feasibility Studies Rejected
The most frequent errors include failing to bifurcate fuel and c-store operations in the P&L, underestimating credit card processing fees (the single most common dollar-value error), using national average fuel margins instead of local competitive pricing data, projecting fuel volume growth without traffic count support, omitting environmental compliance costs or burying them in general categories, modeling lottery income at unrealistic levels, and ignoring the impact of EV adoption on long-term fuel volume projections. Accepted data sources for gas station feasibility include RMA ratios, NACS State of the Industry, EIA energy price forecasts, ESRI demographics, and state-specific fuel tax data.
For lenders and investors evaluating projects in this sector, UnionMetric provides independent gas station feasibility study services that meet SBA and USDA requirements.
Sources
The income approach for gas stations requires careful bifurcation of fuel and convenience store revenue streams. Forecasting gallons and cents per gallon over a 25-year term, including the tank replacement schedule, is covered in gas station feasibility and EV exposure across a 25-year term.
- NACS, 2024 State of the Industry Report via CSP Daily News, April 2025
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, Short-Term Energy Outlook November 2025
- Casey's General Stores, SEC Filings Q1 FY2026 and Q3 FY2024
- MMCG Invest, The Economic Landscape of a Typical Gas Station Business 2023
- MMCG Invest, U.S. Fuel Prices Change Forecast 2026: Impact on Gas Stations Margins and Profitability
- Toast POS, How Much Do Gas Stations Make Average Revenue Data 2025
- Arrowfish Consulting, A Complete Gas Station Valuation Guide 2026
- ARMR.net, Environmental Insurance for AST/UST Risks
- NRF, Shrink Accounted for Over $112 Billion in Industry Losses in 2022
Looking for a lender-grade gas stations feasibility study?
Related feasibility study engagements
Truck Stop and Convenience Retail, Lincoln County, Nebraska
USDA B&I feasibility study supporting a gas station project in Lincoln County.
Convenience Store with Fuel Station, Ada County, Idaho
SBA 504 feasibility study supporting a gas station project in Ada County.
Robert Mitchell, MAI, SRA, AI-GRS
Certified commercial real estate appraiser with extensive experience in gas stations property valuations across the United States.
View team credentials →