Gas Stations

    Rationalizing Operating Expenses for Truck Stop Pro Formas: What Lenders Need to See

    March 23, 2026
    50 min read

    Truck stop feasibility differs fundamentally from gas station analysis because of the sheer number of revenue streams, the 24/7 operational requirement, and the massive physical footprint.

    Truck stop feasibility differs fundamentally from gas station analysis because of the sheer number of revenue streams, the 24/7 operational requirement, and the massive physical footprint. While gas station pro forma analysis bifurcates fuel and c-store operations, and car wash pro forma models center on membership economics, the 24/7 operational requirement, and the massive physical footprint. A full-service travel center requires 10 to 25 or more acres versus 0.5 to 2 acres for a gas station, employs 50 to 100 or more workers versus 6 to 15, and generates revenue from 8 to 12 distinct business lines versus 2 to 3. Development costs run $6 to $20 million or more excluding land. The truck parking shortage, with only 1 space for every 10 to 11 trucks on U.S. roads, is creating sustained demand for new capacity, backed by $275 to $300 million in federal grants through IIJA funding. This guide provides the operating expense benchmarks that lenders require for truck stop feasibility studies.

    Revenue Mix: Fuel Dominates Revenue but Not Profit

    Fuel (diesel plus gasoline) represents 65% to 80% of total revenue at a typical travel center, but contributes only 30% to 40% of gross profit. The inverse relationship between revenue share and profit share is the single most important concept in truck stop feasibility. TravelCenters of America's last public financial disclosure (Q4 2022) provides the clearest revenue breakdown for a major operator: non-fuel revenue of $517.8 million per quarter split across store/retail services ($191M, 36.9%), truck service ($196M, 37.8%), restaurant ($83M, 16.0%), and DEF ($48M, 9.2%). Non-fuel gross margin was $314.7 million, or 61% of non-fuel revenue, versus fuel gross margin of $167.9 million on vastly higher fuel sales, demonstrating that non-fuel operations generated nearly twice the gross profit of fuel.

    Diesel Margins and Fleet Card Dynamics

    Diesel margins at truck stops typically run $0.15 to $0.30 per gallon for retail sales to independent drivers, with TA reporting an average of approximately $0.30 per gallon in Q4 2022 during favorable market conditions. The combined diesel/gasoline margin averaged $0.172 per gallon in less favorable periods. Fleet/bulk sales carry slightly lower per-gallon margins but dramatically higher volume. Diesel represents 60% to 80% of total fuel sales at travel centers, with chain locations moving approximately 800,000 gallons of diesel per month versus 300,000 for independents. The average diesel fill is 100 to 200 or more gallons per truck ($400 to $700 or more per transaction), compared to approximately 12 gallons for a gasoline fill.

    Fleet card processing is a critical distinction from gas station feasibility. Major fleet cards (Comdata, EFS, T-Check) charge interchange rates that differ from consumer credit cards, and fleet card negotiations can materially affect the bottom line. A feasibility study that models all fuel transactions at consumer credit card rates will overstate processing costs for a truck stop where 40% to 60% of diesel volume flows through fleet accounts.

    Truck Service, Tire Operations, and DEF

    Truck service and tire operations are major profit centers. TA's truck service network generated $196 million in quarterly revenue across approximately 300 locations, equating to roughly $653,000 per location per year. Love's operates Speedco/Love's Truck Care across 650 or more locations. Margins exceed 50% on labor, with parts marked up from wholesale. Average trucking fleet tire expense runs $0.46 per mile or approximately $3,687 per truck per year.

    DEF (Diesel Exhaust Fluid) dispensing offers attractive margins. Pump DEF retails at $2.69 to $3.80 per gallon against bulk wholesale costs of $0.60 to $1.50 per gallon, producing 50% to 100% or more markup. Trucks consume DEF at 2% to 5% of diesel consumption (typically 3%), with average purchases of approximately 10 gallons per truck. TA generated $47.8 million in quarterly DEF revenue across approximately 300 locations, or approximately $160,000 per location per year. Infrastructure costs for DEF dispensing run $50,000 to $150,000 installed, including temperature-controlled underground storage (DEF freezes at 11 degrees Fahrenheit). Ninety-five percent of Pilot/Flying J locations now offer DEF at the pump.

    Restaurant, Shower, and Scale Revenue

    Restaurant operations generate approximately $1.1 million per location per year at TA locations. Restaurant food cost is controllable with 60% or more gross markup on ingredients, though restaurant-specific labor runs 30% or more of restaurant sales. QSR franchise tenants (Subway, Wendy's, Arby's) pay 4% to 8% royalties to their franchisors but generate 5% to 15% profit margins for the truck stop operator. Full-service 24/7 diners serve as significant traffic drivers; a good truck stop restaurant can draw truckers to a location more than any other amenity.

    Shower facilities charge $12 to $18 per use at major chains, though most showers are provided free as loyalty rewards for fuel purchases of 50 or more gallons. Shower revenue is primarily a customer acquisition and retention tool rather than a standalone profit center. Large travel centers maintain 8 to 20 shower stalls. Pilot Flying J invested $100 million upgrading shower and bathroom facilities. CAT Scale operates 2,200 or more locations across the U.S. and Canada, charging truckers $12 to $15 per weigh. CAT Scale owns and installs the equipment; the truck stop receives a revenue share of each weigh fee.

    Labor and Staffing for 24/7 Operations

    Labor costs at truck stops run 10% to 20% of total gross revenue, higher than gas stations due to the 24/7/365 operational requirement and the need to staff multiple departments simultaneously. A typical full-service travel center employs 50 to 100 people across fuel desk/cashiers (3 shifts), store clerks (3 shifts), restaurant staff (3 shifts or franchised), maintenance/custodial crew, security personnel, mechanics/technicians, and 1 to 2 managers on duty at all times. Employee turnover frequently exceeds 100% annually in truck stop retail.

    Buc-ee's represents the extreme end of the staffing spectrum, creating approximately 200 full-time jobs per location with wages of $16 to $32 per hour and six managerial positions at $100,000 or more per year. Buc-ee's total workforce exceeds 10,000 employees across approximately 63 locations. The Buc-ee's model demonstrates that premium labor investment can produce outsized revenue: estimated revenue of $50 to $100 million per store annually, with approximately two-thirds from non-fuel inside sales and an estimated gross profit margin of approximately 40%.

    Utilities, Lot Maintenance, and Insurance at Scale

    Utility costs for truck stops are dramatically higher than gas stations. A mid-size travel center should budget $8,500 to $26,000 per month ($100,000 to $300,000 or more per year) across electricity ($5,000 to $12,000 per month for 24/7 lighting, HVAC, refrigeration, and fuel pumps), water/sewer ($2,000 to $8,000 per month for showers, restrooms, and restaurant), natural gas ($1,000 to $4,000 per month for cooking and water heating), and waste disposal ($500 to $2,000 per month).

    Lot maintenance is a major recurring expense that pro formas frequently underestimate. Heavy truck traffic destroys pavement faster than passenger vehicles, requiring more frequent repaving cycles. Initial paving for a 100-space truck parking lot (approximately 100,000 sq ft) costs $300,000 to $700,000 at $3 to $7 per square foot, with resurfacing needed every 5 to 10 years. Annual lot maintenance budgets should run $25,000 to $100,000 or more depending on size and climate, covering sweeping, pothole repair, re-striping, snow removal, and high-intensity 24/7 lighting.

    Insurance packages for truck stops are significantly more complex and expensive than gas stations: $50,000 to $150,000 per year for small-to-mid operations and $150,000 to $400,000 or more per year for large full-service travel centers. Required coverages include general liability, property insurance, UST pollution liability ($1 million per occurrence minimum per EPA 40 CFR Part 280), workers' compensation, business interruption, product liability for food service, and environmental/spill liability. UST insurance alone costs $500 to $10,000 or more per tank annually, and truck stops operate 6 to 12 or more tanks versus 2 to 4 at a standard gas station.

    EBITDA Margins and Major Operator Benchmarks

    Truck stop EBITDA margins typically run 5% to 10% of total revenue, though this figure is depressed by the high fuel pass-through that inflates the revenue denominator. TA reported adjusted EBITDAR margins (excluding rent) of 16.8% to 19.4%. Pilot Travel Centers, now 100% owned by Berkshire Hathaway, generated approximately $486 million in pre-tax earnings on $36.1 billion in revenue during the first nine months of 2024, equating to a 1.3% pre-tax margin on total revenue. This reflects Pilot's massive fuel pass-through volume of approximately 12 billion gallons annually serving 1.2 million guests per day across approximately 900 locations. Berkshire paid $13 billion for full ownership, implying roughly 25x earnings.

    The Truck Parking Shortage as Demand Thesis

    The truck parking crisis is the primary demand driver for new travel center development. FHWA's Jason's Law survey found 98% of 11,700 drivers reporting problems finding safe parking, with truck stop operators confirming facilities at more than 100% capacity overnight. Only 1 parking space exists for every 10 to 11 trucks on U.S. roads, and public spaces increased just 6% while private spaces grew only 11% between 2014 and 2019. The most problematic hours are 4 PM to 5 AM, Monday through Thursday, October through February. The industry loses an estimated $4.4 billion annually due to parking inefficiencies.

    Federal investment is accelerating: USDOT allocated $275 to $300 million in truck parking grants through IIJA/INFRA programs in 2024 to 2025. ATA freight tonnage is projected to reach approximately 14 billion tons by 2035, up from 11.3 billion in 2024, further tightening parking demand. Paid/reserved parking is a growing revenue stream: TA's Reserve-It and Pilot's reserved parking programs charge $5 to $20 or more per night.

    Common Pro Forma Mistakes That Get Truck Stop Feasibility Studies Rejected

    The most common feasibility study errors in truck stop analysis differ meaningfully from gas station mistakes. Over-relying on fixed traffic capture rates instead of modeling by trip purpose, distance, and competitor positioning leads to inflated revenue projections. Failing to model fleet card sales separately from retail, since fleet sales are high volume but lower margin, distorts the fuel margin analysis. Underestimating credit card processing fees (2% to 3% of fuel sales is enormous when fuel is 70% or more of revenue) and understaffing for true 24/7 coverage across all departments are recurring errors. Using gas station comparables for a truck stop is the most fundamental mistake; the cost structure, scale, and revenue profile are entirely different. A gas station feasibility study costs $6,500 to $10,000, while a truck stop study runs $10,000 to $15,000.

    For lenders and investors evaluating projects in this sector, UnionMetric provides independent gas station and truck stop feasibility services that meet SBA and USDA requirements.

    Sources

    1. MMCG Invest, The U.S. Truck Stop Economy: An Ultimate Guide to Full-Service Travel Plazas, January 2025
    2. TravelCenters of America, SEC Filings Q4 2022 and Q2 2021
    3. Berkshire Hathaway, SEC Filing Q3 2024 10-Q (Pilot Travel Centers)
    4. FHWA, Jason's Law Truck Parking Survey 2019
    5. NACS/NATSO, Convenience and Fuel Retailing Industry Data 2024
    6. CSP Daily News, Foodservice Drives Sales at U.S. Convenience Stores in 2024
    7. ATRI, Operational Costs of Trucking 2024
    8. Palmer Lake Fiscal Impact Analysis, Buc-ee's Travel Center
    9. ARMR.net, Environmental Insurance for AST/UST Risks 2024

    Looking for a lender-grade gas stations feasibility study?

    MR

    Michael Rodriguez, MAI, CCIM

    Certified commercial real estate appraiser with extensive experience in gas stations property valuations across the United States.

    View team credentials →
    Get Started Today

    Need to Know if Your Project Works?

    Tell us about your project and we'll send a clear proposal: scope, timeline, and fee.