SBA 7(a) Gas Station Acquisition Case Study: Lavy's Marathon, Gettysburg, Ohio, and the $409,000 of Verified EBITDA a $2.6 Million Price Requires

    A model feasibility study and going-concern valuation of a listed rural Marathon station and convenience store under SOP 50 10 8.1 Appendix 15. The case is built on the valuation problem every fuel acquisition now raises: how the going concern splits between land and building, the tanks, canopy and dispensers, and the business, and how 2026 fuel margins should be normalised. Under the 1 October 2026 rules that split sets the blended amortisation, and the blended amortisation sets the loan.

    By Robert Mitchell, MAI, SRA, AI-GRS, UnionMetric Feasibility | 6 October 2026

    Study at a Glance

    ItemFinding
    SubjectLavy's Marathon (Lavy's Corner Mart), 103 W Main St (US Route 36), Gettysburg, Darke County, Ohio 45328
    ParcelsFour: A05431025020310600, A05431025020312800, A05431025020313001 and a fourth to be confirmed with the Auditor
    Improvements2,961 SF convenience store built about 2000, fuel canopy, regular, midgrade, premium and diesel, pay at the pump, eatery
    Site3.36 acres; 73 feet of frontage on US 36
    Listed price$2,600,000 for the business and four parcels ($878.08 per SF of building)
    Disclosed operationsNone: the listing pages do not publish gallons, inside sales or cash flow
    Benchmark profile750,000 gallons (560,000 gasoline, 190,000 diesel); $1,400,000 inside sales
    Going-concern value on the benchmark profile$1,850,000
    AllocationReal property $850,000; fuel and store equipment $170,000; intangible business value $830,000
    Supportable SBA loan at $1.85 million$1,515,000 at 1.25x historical coverage; equity 28.7%
    EBITDA the $2.6 million price requires$409,352, 1.81 times the benchmark
    Quality of EarningsNot triggered at either price: the business purchase price is $1.0 million at value and $1.75 million at the asking price
    DeterminationSupportable at $1.85 million on a benchmark profile; the $2.6 million price requires $409,000 of verified adjusted EBITDA

    Determination

    The listing discloses no gallons, no inside sales and no cash flow, so this study does not pretend to know what the station earns. It builds a benchmark profile from the site, the market and national operating data, values the station on that profile, and then asks the question a lender needs answered first: what would the seller's tax returns have to show for the asking price to work?

    On the benchmark profile of 750,000 gallons and $1.4 million of inside sales, the going concern is worth $1,850,000. At that price the acquisition is feasible. A project cost of $2,124,109, including inventory, reports, working capital and the guaranty fee, supports a $1,515,000 SBA 7(a) loan that passes the 1.25x historical coverage test on modelled adjusted EBITDA of $225,816, with the real property share amortised over 25 years and the business share over 10. The buyer contributes $609,109, or 28.7 per cent.

    At the $2,600,000 asking price, the same structure needs historical adjusted EBITDA of $409,352 to clear 1.25 times, which is 1.81 times the benchmark. At normalised margins that means about 972,000 gallons and $1.81 million of inside sales, both about 30 per cent above the benchmark, from a village of 544 people on a road the listing puts at a little over 5,000 vehicles a day. If the seller's returns show that, the price works. If they show the benchmark, the price exceeds the value by $750,000 and a 90 per cent loan would cover its debt service 0.69 times.

    The valuation and the feasibility test meet in the allocation. Only $850,000 of the $1.85 million value is real property. The other 54 per cent must amortise over ten years under Appendix 15, which lifts the blended debt constant to 11.9 per cent and is the reason a station worth $1.85 million supports only $1.5 million of debt.

    Scope, Basis and Data Verification

    This is a model study. UnionMetric was not engaged on this property, did not inspect it, and has no relationship with the seller, the listing broker or any buyer. The subject is a real station listed for sale in 2026; one brokerage page for the listing returned an error on 6 October 2026 while two portals still showed it, so its status is confirmed with the listing agent before any use beyond illustration. The subject was chosen because it shows the allocation problem in its clearest form: a real-estate-heavy rural deal of four parcels and 3.36 acres, a long-tenured owner-operator business dating to 1982, almost no fuel competition within three miles, and a price that only the business component can explain. Because the listing discloses no operating data, every operating figure here is a benchmark built from market evidence, not the station's own results. The value indications illustrate method. They are not an appraisal, they are not an opinion of market value for any intended user, and they must not be relied on in any transaction involving the property.

    StatusItems
    Primary-verifiedNACS margin series and net-margin waterfall; EIA weekly retail gasoline and diesel prices and the Short-Term Energy Outlook; Murphy USA and Getty Realty SEC filings; the SOP 50 10 page listing Version 8.1 with Technical Updates effective 1 October 2026 and the two SBA information notices; ACS place data for Gettysburg via Census Reporter
    Primary (extract)The listing's price, parcels, acreage, building size and zoning as shown on the portal
    SecondaryEvery Appendix 15 provision (SBA publishes the SOP as a Word document; provisions are taken from lender, accounting and law firm summaries); competitor locations and distances; the store's amenities and hours; c-store cap rates and transaction coverage; 2025 industry results reported from NACS State of the Industry data
    Not obtainedGallons, inside sales and cash flow; Darke County parcel cards, assessments and tax bills; an ODOT traffic count; tank count, capacity and installation dates from the Ohio Bureau of Underground Storage Tank Regulations; ring demographics; closed sales; replacement cost quotes
    ModelledThe whole operating profile, margins, expenses, the historical years, the capitalisation rate, market rent, component values and depreciation, the allocation and the interest rate

    The Valuation Problem This Case Is Built On

    At $878 per SF of building, the asking price is plainly a going-concern price. A 2,961 SF rural store on 3.36 acres will not appraise anywhere near $2.6 million as real estate. Whatever the land, building, canopy and tanks are worth, the rest of the price has to be supported as equipment and intangible business value from historical earnings. Three questions follow, and each is answered by a different report.

    The going-concern appraisal must allocate the value between land, building, equipment and intangible assets. On a fuel property that allocation has a classification question inside it: are the canopy and the underground storage tanks real property fixtures or equipment?

    The lender's coverage test must clear 1.25 times on historical earnings. Under Appendix 15, as published summaries report it, the 25-year term once available when real estate was 51 per cent or more of a project is gone; the loan term is now a weighted blend of the real estate portion and the business portion, and the business portion may not amortise over more than ten years. The allocation therefore sets the debt constant.

    The fuel margin in the trailing year must be judged against a longer history, because 2026 is not a normal year for fuel retailing.

    Method. On a change-of-ownership fuel file the appraiser, the business valuator and the lender each answer the allocation question separately, and they rarely agree. The study's job is to show one allocation, the evidence for it, and what each alternative does to collateral, amortisation and coverage, so that the three reports can be reconciled before closing rather than after.

    Project Business Plan

    The Project is the acquisition and continued operation of Lavy's Marathon, a branded Marathon fuel station and convenience store with an eatery at 103 W Main Street (US Route 36) in the village of Gettysburg, Darke County, Ohio, operating since 1982. The property comprises four parcels totalling 3.36 acres with 73 feet of frontage on US 36, a one-storey 2,961 SF store built about 2000, a fuel canopy, and dispensers selling regular, midgrade and premium gasoline and diesel with pay at the pump. The store offers convenience merchandise, an eatery, an ATM, air, restrooms and a tanning station, and opens from 5:30 am to 10:00 pm on weekdays and from 7:00 am to 10:00 pm at weekends with a staff of roughly ten to nineteen. The buyer acquires the fee simple real estate and the operating business, with the real estate held by an eligible passive company and the station operated by the borrowing operating company, and continues the Marathon supply relationship subject to the supplier's consent. The station is positioned as the only fuel and convenience stop within about 3.5 miles on the US 36 corridor between Greenville and Piqua, serving village residents, Adams Township farm households and through traffic.

    Marketing & Sales Strategy

    The strategy is continuity first. The station's name, staff and hours carry over so that regular customers notice no change on the day of closing. The first investment goes into the eatery and the prepared-food offer, because inside sales produce most of a convenience store's gross profit and the nearest competing food service is in Versailles and Bradford. Fuel pricing tracks the Shell in Bradford rather than the Versailles cluster, holding volume without starting a price war. Business-to-business outreach targets farm operations for diesel and bulk accounts, the township and school district, and contractors working the corridor. The built-in acquisition channel is the pump: a daily price that keeps local drivers from detouring to Versailles brings them inside, where the margin is made.

    Amenities

    • Marathon-branded fuel: regular, midgrade, premium and diesel
    • Pay at the pump
    • 2,961 SF convenience store with an eatery
    • ATM, air and restrooms
    • Tanning station
    • 3.36 acres across four parcels with 73 feet of frontage on US Route 36
    • Open from 5:30 am on weekdays and 7:00 am at weekends, until 10:00 pm daily

    Subject Property: Site, Improvements, Zoning and Tax

    ItemFindingStatus
    Address and tax district103 W Main St, Gettysburg, OH 45328; Adams Township, Gettysburg Corporation (A05)Listing; Darke County Auditor search page
    Price$2,600,000; $878.08 per SF of buildingListing, October 2026
    ParcelsFour; three IDs complete, the fourth shown with 16 characters and checked against the Auditor's recordListing
    Site3.36 acres; building 2,961 SF; one storey; single tenancy; FAR 0.02Listing
    Zoning"Commercial"; the Village of Gettysburg district is confirmed at engagementListing
    AgeAbout 26 years (built about 2000)MLS display
    Traffic"Over 5,000 vehicles passing daily in 2024"Seller claim; ODOT count at engagement
    Fuel positions and tanksNot statedBUSTR registry and site visit at engagement
    Assessment and taxesNot obtained; Ohio assesses at 35% of appraised valueDarke County Auditor parcel cards at engagement

    The tank record matters more than any other item on this list. A tank system installed with a store built about 2000 is near the end of a typical 30-year warranty, and replacement is a six-figure capital item that falls on the buyer. The Ohio Bureau of Underground Storage Tank Regulations registry lists tank count, capacity, material and installation year for each facility, and it is read before the allocation is finalised. The study models three double-wall tanks of about 30,000 gallons in total, installed about 2000.

    Method. On a fuel property, the most valuable diligence document is often not the appraisal but the tank registry. Tank age sets the depreciation of the most expensive equipment on the site, the timing of the next capital call, and the scope of the environmental review. A going-concern value that does not state the tank installation year has not valued the tanks.

    Real estate taxes are modelled at $18,000 a year pending the parcel cards, and the lender's environmental review for a station with tanks of this age normally goes beyond a Phase I environmental site assessment to tank tightness testing and, where indicated, soil sampling.

    Market Area and Demand

    Gettysburg is a village of about 544 people (ACS 2024 five-year estimate, plus or minus 158; 463 at the 2020 Census) with about 180 households, a median household income of $63,125 and per capita income of $22,473. Darke County, the Greenville micropolitan area, has a median household income of $64,486, against $71,389 for Ohio and $80,734 for the United States. The margins of error at this scale show how thin place-level data is; the five-mile ring, not the village, is the trade area, and it takes in farm households across Adams Township and the edge of Bradford. Ring populations and incomes are built from block-group ACS tables at engagement.

    Demand comes from three sources: village and township households, through traffic on US 36 between Greenville and Piqua, and farm operations that buy diesel. The capture arithmetic sets the limits. At 5,000 vehicles a day, with 2 to 3 per cent stopping for about 10 gallons, through traffic supplies about 365,000 to 550,000 gallons a year. The benchmark profile of 750,000 gallons therefore assumes 200,000 to 385,000 gallons of local and farm demand, a large share of it diesel in one of Ohio's leading agricultural counties. That assumption is the first thing the seller's fuel invoices confirm or reject.

    A price-sensitive rural customer base points the store toward beer, tobacco, lottery and prepared food. Nationally, the industry earned 61.2 per cent of its gross profit inside the store on 35 per cent of sales in 2025, and foodservice was 28.5 per cent of inside sales and about 38.9 per cent of inside gross profit.

    Competitive Supply: Competitor Census

    The subject has almost no fuel competition within three miles. Distances for the Bradford stations other than the Shell are estimates and are measured at engagement; posted prices on a single dated day are captured in a field survey.

    Competitor Number 1

    Shell, Bradford

    This Shell station, open 24 hours with V-Power premium, is located at 9990 US Route 36, Bradford, OH, about 3.46 miles from the subject.

    Competitor Number 2

    Bradford convenience store

    This convenience store station is located at 120 N Miami Ave, Bradford, OH, about four miles from the subject. Its brand is not confirmed.

    Competitor Number 3

    Hocker's Service

    This independent service station is located at 806 S Miami Ave, Bradford, OH, about four miles from the subject.

    Competitor Number 4

    Casey's, Versailles

    This Casey's store with prepared food sells diesel, unleaded 88, E85, regular and premium. It is located at 706 E Main St, Versailles, OH, beyond three miles.

    Competitor Number 5

    Versailles Marathon / BP

    This station with regular, midgrade, premium and diesel and a convenience store is shown under different brands by different directories. It is located at 7 N 2nd St, Versailles, OH, beyond three miles.

    Competitor Number 6

    Valero and ARCO, Versailles

    These two stations are located at 1375 and 1327 E Main St, Versailles, OH, beyond three miles.

    Real estate taxes and acreage for each competitor come from the Darke and Miami County Auditors at engagement. For a lender, being the only station in a three-mile ring is real protection on volume. It also means a thin, spread-out trade area: the station's volume depends on regular local customers and farm accounts more than on a busy road.

    Fuel Margins in 2026: What Normalisation Means Here

    YearNational gasoline gross marginShare of the retail price
    202129.9 cents per gallon10.2%
    202242.9 cents10.8%
    202339.4 cents11.2%
    202439.7 cents11.9%
    202539.7 cents12.7% of a $3.12 average
    Five-year average38.3 cents

    The 2025 margin was only 1.4 cents, or 3.7 per cent, above the five-year average, and the five-year average is itself lifted by 2022. Against the pre-2020 norm of about 22 to 24 cents, current margins are 65 to 80 per cent higher, which is where the story of elevated fuel margins comes from.

    2026 runs the other way. EIA's weekly U.S. regular gasoline price rose from $4.006 on 10 August to $4.319 on 14 September, $4.478 on 21 September and $4.465 on 28 September; the Midwest price was $4.091, $4.386 and $4.291 in the latest three weeks. Retail diesel set a nominal record of $6.29 on 14 September and broke it the next week at $6.529. The Short-Term Energy Outlook puts the 2026 gasoline average at $3.84 and 2027 at $3.35, after $3.31 in 2024 and $3.10 in 2025. Rising wholesale prices compress retail margins, and NACS was reported in September 2026 as saying margins had narrowed by about 15 cents during the climb. Murphy USA's retail fuel margin was 25.4 cents in Q1 2026 and 35.1 cents in Q2.

    NACS's net-margin waterfall shows how little of the gross margin a retailer keeps: from a 35-cent gross margin, about 8.4 cents goes to card fees, 6 cents to distribution, 6 cents to store operating expense, 2 cents to equipment amortisation and 1 cent to shrink, leaving about 13 cents, inside NACS's stated 10 to 15-cent net range. Distribution, normally about 8 cents, rose to about 12 cents when gas topped $4.50 in 2026. Card fees rise with the pump price, so a price surge both narrows the margin and raises the cost of collecting it.

    Margin caseGasoline / diesel (cents per gallon)EBITDA on the benchmark profileNOI
    2025 national39.7 / 45.7$244,190$222,190
    Five-year average38.3 / 44.3$233,690$211,690
    Subject, normalised36.0 / 42.0$216,440$194,440
    Downside32.0 / 38.0$186,440$164,440
    2026 stress: downside margins at $4.30 gasoline and $5.80 diesel32.0 / 38.0$162,670$140,670

    The study normalises the subject at 36.0 cents for gasoline and 42.0 cents for diesel: below the five-year national average because a rural branded dealer buying under a supply agreement rarely earns the national figure, and because the trailing year includes 2026 compression. Each cent on 750,000 gallons is $7,500 of gross profit.

    Method. The lender and the appraiser normalise differently, and both are right for their purpose. Appendix 15 lets the lender use the last fiscal year or the average of the last two, on a historical or adjusted basis, and bars reliance on projections; the two-year average is the built-in smoother, and the lender cannot underwrite a margin recovery the history does not show. The appraiser must develop a stabilised income, so it normalises the margin to a multi-year average and shows the station's own cents-per-gallon history beside the national series. A study that capitalises a peak-year margin as stable income has valued a good year, not a station.

    Benchmark Operating Profile and Historical Years

    LineNormalised (valuation)FY2024 (modelled)FY2025 (modelled)
    Gasoline gallons560,000560,000560,000
    Diesel gallons190,000190,000190,000
    Gasoline / diesel margin (cents)36.0 / 42.037.0 / 43.037.5 / 43.5
    Fuel gross profit$281,400$288,900$292,650
    Inside sales$1,400,000$1,400,000$1,400,000
    Inside gross profit (32.5%)$455,000$455,000$455,000
    Lottery commissions, ATM, air, tanning and other income$45,000$45,000$45,000
    Total gross profit$781,400$788,900$792,650
    Store payroll and burden$240,000$240,000$240,000
    Store manager at market (replaces the owner's draw)$62,000$62,000$62,000
    Card fees (2.3% of fuel sales, 2.0% of inside sales)$84,960$84,960$84,960
    Utilities$52,000$52,000$52,000
    Repairs, maintenance and tank compliance testing$34,000$34,000$34,000
    Insurance, including tank pollution liability$31,000$31,000$31,000
    Real estate taxes (modelled)$18,000$18,000$18,000
    Supplies and waste$22,000$22,000$22,000
    Professional fees, licences and environmental compliance$15,000$15,000$15,000
    Advertising and brand image$6,000$6,000$6,000
    Total operating expenses$564,960$564,960$564,960
    Adjusted EBITDA$216,440$223,940$227,690
    Reserve for replacement$22,000
    Net operating income$194,440

    Fuel sales are priced at 2025 averages of $3.15 for gasoline and $3.75 for diesel, $2,476,500 in total, and total revenue is about $3.92 million. The inside margin of 32.5 per cent sits in the 30 to 35 per cent range rural branded listings report, and its foodservice share is what lifts it. Fuel produces 36 per cent of gross profit on about 63 per cent of revenue, close to the national split. The two modelled historical years average $225,816 of adjusted EBITDA, the figure the Appendix 15 test uses; the valuation uses the lower normalised $216,440.

    Highest and Best Use

    As though vacant, the site is zoned commercial and physically suited to highway commercial use, with 3.36 acres and frontage on US 36. A new fuel station would cost far more than an existing one is worth in a village of 544, so new construction of a station is not financially feasible on this evidence; the land is valued at its commercial use, held for highway commercial development as demand permits. As improved, the station's value is many times that of its land, and continued operation as a branded fuel station and convenience store is the highest and best use. The absence of competition within three miles is the market's own statement that new supply does not pay here.

    Cost Approach: The Tangible Assets

    ComponentReplacement cost newDepreciationDepreciated value
    Land, 3.36 acres (modelled about $40,000 per acre)$135,000
    Store building, 2,961 SF at $260 per SF$769,86040% (effective age 18 of 45 years)$461,916
    Fuel canopy$170,00051% (18 of 35 years)$82,571
    Underground storage tanks and piping (modelled: three tanks, about 30,000 gallons, installed about 2000)$330,00087% (26 of 30 years)$44,000
    Site improvements (paving, drainage, lighting, pylon sign)$190,00050%$95,000
    Real property, depreciated cost$818,487
    Fuel dispensers, four, EMV-compliant$120,00050% (6 of 12 years)$60,000
    Store equipment (coolers, foodservice, shelving, point of sale)$220,00050%$110,000
    Tangible assets, depreciated cost$988,487

    The cost inputs are modelled and are replaced at engagement by a published cost service and at least two contractor or distributor quotes per component: canopy per SF, double-wall fibreglass tank per gallon of capacity, dispenser per unit with EMV, and the store shell per SF.

    A market rent cross-check tests the real property figure: a regional operator leasing the improved site for about $80,000 a year, capitalised at 8.75 per cent for a rural Ohio, non-credit tenant, implies $914,286. The real property is reconciled at $850,000, between depreciated cost and the rent indication.

    Sales Comparison: Why the Obvious Evidence Does Not Apply

    No closed sale of an Ohio or neighbouring-state gas station with real estate was verified with price, date and gallons; Darke County's Auditor sales list and Ohio conveyance data are searched at engagement for service-station land-use codes in Darke, Miami, Mercer, Shelby, Preble and Auglaize counties, and each sale is confirmed with a party for gallons, inside sales and allocation. Listing evidence brackets the market but does not set it: an Ohio branded store in Jackson County asks $1,400,000 plus inventory for 2,400 SF and 35,000 to 40,000 gallons a month, with the seller valuing its real estate at $580,000, about 41 per cent of the price; Ohio gas station listings average $856,562 across a range of $60,000 to $2,100,000.

    The most widely quoted evidence is the wrong evidence. Net lease convenience store cap rates averaged 5.63 per cent in Q2 2026, the tightest of the net lease sectors, and Getty Realty's $260.9 million sale-leaseback of 41 Refuel stores closed in September 2026 at about $6.36 million a site, with Getty investing at a 7.1 per cent initial cash yield. Those are rates on corporate-guaranteed leases of new, large stores averaging nearly 5,000 SF on 2.5 acres. Applied to the EBITDA of an owner-operated rural store, a 5.6 per cent rate would value the subject at more than $3.8 million.

    Method. A net lease cap rate prices a lease from a national tenant. It does not price the business that pays the rent, and it does not price a single store run by its owner. On an owner-operated going concern, the right evidence is a market rent for the real property capitalised at a rate for a non-credit tenant, plus an earnings multiple or capitalisation rate drawn from owner-operator sales. Listing-quoted rates on owner-operator deals, from 6.25 to 10.37 per cent in the sample, are computed on sellers' figures and serve only as a bracket.

    Income Approach: The Going Concern

    TestInputsIndicated rate or multiple
    Owner-operator listingsAsking rates on seller-stated income6.25% to 10.37%
    Band of investment for an SBA-financed buyer under 8.180% loan at a blended constant of about 11.9% (43% real estate over 25 years, 57% business over 10 years); 20% equity at 18%About 13.1%
    Net lease convenience storeCredit tenant, new store5.63%, not applicable
    Concluded overall rate10.50%

    Normalised NOI of $194,440 capitalised at 10.50 per cent gives $1,851,800, rounded to $1,850,000. That is 8.5 times EBITDA after a market manager's salary, or about 6.6 times the $278,440 of earnings before the manager's pay, a familiar range for owner-operated stores with real estate.

    The SBA-financed buyer's band of investment, 13.1 per cent, sits well above the concluded rate. That is not an error. It shows that a buyer relying on a 7(a) loan under the new amortisation rules cannot pay as much for a real-estate-light going concern as a cash or conventionally financed buyer, and it is one reason SBA-financed acquisitions of small stations will need more equity than they did before 1 October 2026.

    Allocating the Going Concern

    ComponentValueShareBasis
    Land$135,0007.3%Modelled land value
    Building, canopy, tanks and site improvements$715,00038.6%Real property reconciled between depreciated cost and market rent
    Real property subtotal$850,00045.9%
    Fuel dispensers and store equipment$170,0009.2%Depreciated replacement cost
    Intangible business value$830,00044.9%Residual
    Going concern$1,850,000100.0%Income approach

    The intangible residual of $830,000 is supported by what it represents: a business operating since 1982 with an established local and farm customer base, the only fuel and food stop within about 3.5 miles, a brand supply relationship and an assembled staff. The business valuation, required on every change of ownership according to several 8.1 summaries, must reach a figure consistent with it, and the two reports are reconciled before closing.

    The classification test shows how much the fixture question matters on this site. If the canopy and tanks are treated as equipment rather than real property, the real property falls to about $723,000, the business share rises, and the coverage-supported loan falls by about $40,500. The effect is small here only because the canopy and tanks are heavily depreciated; on a station with new tanks the same choice can move several hundred thousand dollars across the line.

    Method. The two common allocation approaches give different splits on the same asset. One deducts a management charge and a return on and of equipment and leaves the residual to the real estate. The other values the real estate on market rent and leaves the residual to the business. On a fuel property, the classification of tanks, canopy and dispensers then moves value between the two. For an SBA file the appraiser states the method, shows the fixture classification line by line, and reconciles the allocated intangible value against the business valuation's goodwill.

    SBA Programme Compliance Under SOP 50 10 8.1

    TestRequirement as reportedThis fileResult
    CategoryInitial Acquisition: a new majority owner who was not previously an owner or employeeOutside buyerInitial Acquisition
    Historical coverageAt least 1.25x on the last fiscal year or the average of the last two, historical or adjusted EBITDA over combined post-closing debt service; projections may not be relied on$225,816 average / $180,3901.25x, passes
    EquityAt least 10% of total project cost, which cannot be reduced or eliminated28.7%Passes
    Quality of EarningsRequired where the business purchase price, the contract price less the appraised owner-occupied real estate, is $3 million or more$1,000,000 at value; $1,750,000 at the asking priceNot triggered
    Business portion amortisationNo longer than 10 years; blended maturity across real estate and business portions43.5% over 25 years, 56.5% over 10 yearsBlended constant 11.91%
    Business valuationIndependent valuation from a qualified source requested by and prepared for the lender; total debt capped at the business valueRequiredAt engagement
    Going-concern appraisalGas stations remain special-purpose property: a Certified General appraiser with at least four going-concern appraisals of equivalent property in 36 months; allocation to land, building, equipment and intangiblesThis study's allocationAt engagement
    Loan maximum$5,000,000$1,515,000Passes

    Two points reported in the summaries conflict and are read in the 1 October 2026 text before commitment: one vendor summary says special-purpose property is exempt from the QoE and that in-house lender valuations remain available up to $350,000, while others say the in-house tier was removed. SBA lists Version 8.1 with Technical Updates, effective 1 October 2026, and Information Notices 5000-880695 and 5000-882227; the technical update superseded the August 2026 text, which never took effect. The SBA feasibility study page explains where the study sits in the 7(a) file.

    The QoE Line and Why the Allocation Still Matters

    At no price within reach does this station cross the $3 million line. At the asking price the business purchase price is $2.6 million less $850,000 of real estate, $1.75 million; at value it is $1.0 million. A station would need a contract price of about $3.85 million with the same real estate to trigger the report. The QoE question is moot here, but the allocation is not.

    Allocation or termShare over 25 yearsBlended constantLoan supported at 1.25x
    Concluded allocation43.5%11.91%$1,517,200
    Canopy and tanks treated as equipment37.4%12.23%$1,476,700
    Reference: whole loan over 25 years, as under SOP 50 10 8 practice100%8.87%$2,037,200
    Reference: whole loan over 10 years0%14.24%$1,268,300

    The same $225,816 of earnings would have supported $2.04 million under the old 25-year shortcut and supports $1.52 million under the blended rule. That $520,000 difference is the effect of Appendix 15 on a real-estate-light going concern, and it lands on the buyer as equity. The SBA Acquisition Report Stack Planner runs the same test on any change-of-ownership file.

    Project Cost Estimate and Loan Assumptions

    Location: 103 W Main St, Gettysburg, OH 45328 | Site: 3.36 acres | Size in SF (Gross): 2,961

    ItemCostCost in %Cost per SF
    Acquisition
    Land$135,0006.4%$45.59
    Building, Canopy, Tanks and Site Improvements$715,00033.7%$241.47
    Fuel Dispensers$60,0002.8%$20.26
    Store Equipment$110,0005.2%$37.15
    Intangible Business Value$830,00039.1%$280.31
    Total Acquisition$1,850,00087.1%$624.79
    Inventory
    Fuel and Merchandise Inventory at Cost$110,0005.2%$37.15
    Soft Cost
    Business Valuation$8,0000.4%$2.70
    Going-Concern Appraisal$9,0000.4%$3.04
    Phase I ESA and Tank Tightness Testing$12,0000.6%$4.05
    Legal, Title and Closing$35,0001.6%$11.82
    Total Soft Cost$64,0003.0%$21.61
    Financial Cost
    Working Capital$60,0002.8%$20.26
    SBA Guaranty Fee (modelled)$40,1091.9%$13.55
    Total Financial Cost$100,1094.7%$33.81
    Total Subject Project Cost$2,124,109100.0%$717.36

    Source: Listing data, NACS, EIA, UnionMetric

    Loan Assumptions
    LTC Ratio71.3%
    Loan$1,515,000
    Equity$609,109
    Interest Rate7.50% (modelled)
    Amortisation25 years on the real estate share (43.5%); 10 years on the business share (56.5%); blended constant 11.91%
    Annual Debt Service$180,390

    A 90 per cent loan on the same project, $1,922,000, would carry $228,851 of debt service and cover it 0.99 times. The guaranty fee is modelled on a 75 per cent guarantee and confirmed against the current fiscal year notice at commitment.

    Five-Year Pro Forma and Forward Coverage

    YearFuel gross profitInside salesInside gross profitOther incomeTotal gross profitOperating expensesEBITDANOIDSCR
    2027$281,400$1,442,000$468,650$45,900$795,950$583,868$212,082$189,4221.18x
    2028$281,400$1,485,260$482,710$46,818$810,928$599,565$211,362$188,0231.17x
    2029$281,400$1,529,818$497,191$47,754$826,345$615,733$210,612$186,5721.17x
    2030$281,400$1,575,712$512,107$48,709$842,216$632,386$209,829$185,0681.16x
    2031$281,400$1,622,984$527,470$49,684$858,553$649,539$209,014$183,5101.16x

    Gallons are held flat, fuel margins stay at the normalised cents per gallon, fuel is priced at the 2027 outlook of $3.35 for gasoline and $4.00 for diesel, inside sales and expenses grow 3 per cent a year and other income 2 per cent.

    The forward years show what the historical test cannot. Fuel margins are earned in cents per gallon, and cents do not inflate; wages, utilities and insurance do. With flat gallons, EBITDA drifts down even as inside sales grow, and forward coverage settles near 1.16 times. The loan passes the Appendix 15 test on history and then lives below 1.25 times on the forward path. The store's growth, not the pumps, has to close that gap.

    Break-Even Analysis

    Measure (forward, normalised basis)Break-evenBenchmarkMargin
    Gasoline margin for 1.00x coverage (diesel 6 cents higher)31.2 cents36.0 cents4.8 cents
    Gasoline margin for 1.25x coverage37.2 cents36.0 centsBelow base
    Total gallons for 1.00x coverage629,531750,00016.1%
    Inside sales for 1.00x coverage$1,281,800$1,400,0008.4%

    The station can lose 16 per cent of its gallons, or 4.8 cents of margin, before it stops covering its debt. It can lose only 8.4 per cent of its inside sales. The store carries the loan.

    Sensitivity Analysis

    Scenario (forward, normalised basis)EBITDADSCR on $1,515,000Going-concern value at 10.50%
    Benchmark$216,4401.20x$1,851,800
    Gallons minus 10%$193,9961.08x$1,638,100
    Gallons plus 10%$238,8851.32x$2,065,600
    Inside sales minus 10%$173,7400.96x$1,445,100
    Inside sales plus 10%$259,1411.44x$2,258,500
    Margins at the 2025 national level$244,1901.35x$2,116,100
    Margins at the five-year average$233,6901.30x$2,016,100
    Downside margins (32.0 / 38.0)$186,4401.03x$1,566,100
    Other variableChangeEffect
    Capitalisation rate9.50% / 11.50%Value $2,046,700 / $1,690,800
    Interest rate8.50%Blended constant 12.61%; historical DSCR 1.18x; supportable loan $1,432,500
    Interest rate9.50%Blended constant 13.34%; historical DSCR 1.12x; supportable loan $1,354,700

    The Asking Price Test

    MeasureAt $1,850,000At $2,600,000
    Total project cost$2,124,109$2,905,034
    Loan$1,515,000 (coverage-bound)$2,614,530 (90% of cost)
    Real estate share over 25 years43.5%32.0%
    Blended constant11.91%12.53%
    Annual debt service$180,390$327,482
    Historical EBITDA needed for 1.25x$225,488$409,352
    Coverage on the benchmark's $225,8161.25x0.69x
    Volumes needed at normalised margins750,000 gallons; $1.40 million insideAbout 972,000 gallons; about $1.81 million inside

    The asking price is not impossible. It is a claim about the station's earnings that the seller's tax returns can confirm in an afternoon. A lender should ask for three years of returns, monthly gallons by grade, inside sales by category and the fuel supply terms before ordering any third-party report, because the answer decides whether there is a file at all.

    Method. When the seller discloses no operating data, turn the valuation around. Instead of estimating what the station earns and valuing it, solve for what it must earn to support the price, then show what volumes that implies. The question for the seller becomes concrete, the lender's diligence starts with the one document that matters, and nobody spends money on an appraisal of a price the business cannot carry.

    Where the Feasibility Conclusion and the Value Conclusion Meet

    The valuation says a station of this kind, on a benchmark profile, is worth $1.85 million, and that less than half of that is real property. The feasibility analysis says the same earnings carry $1.515 million of debt at 1.25 times under the blended amortisation, and settle near 1.16 times on the forward path as costs outrun flat fuel margins. The allocation is where they meet: the 54 per cent of the value that is equipment and business must amortise over ten years, and that is what turns a $1.85 million value into a $1.5 million loan and 29 per cent equity. The determination is that the acquisition is supportable at $1.85 million on the benchmark profile, and that the $2.6 million asking price requires verified historical adjusted EBITDA of about $409,000.

    Risk Factors

    The income is unknown. Every operating figure is a benchmark until the seller's returns, invoices and point-of-sale reports replace it.

    The listing status is uncertain. One brokerage page returned an error in October 2026, which can mean a withdrawn, expired or contracted listing.

    The tanks are old. A tank system installed about 2000 is near the end of its warranty life, and replacement is a capital call the buyer should price now.

    Fuel margins are volatile. A 2026 price surge narrowed margins while raising card fees, and a downside margin takes forward coverage to 1.03 times.

    The trade area is thin. A village of 544 cannot replace lost farm or through-traffic volume.

    Costs inflate and margins do not. Flat cents-per-gallon margins against 3 per cent cost growth erode coverage every year.

    The rules are summarised, not read. Every Appendix 15 provision used here comes from secondary summaries, and two of them conflict.

    Conditions and Limitations

    This is a model study prepared to illustrate feasibility and valuation method on a publicly listed property. It is not an appraisal, it was not prepared under an engagement, it was not prepared for any intended user other than the readers of this site, and no one should rely on it for any decision about the property. UnionMetric did not inspect the property, review its books, or communicate with its owner, broker, supplier or any buyer.

    The operating profile, the historical years, the margins, the expenses, the tank configuration, the component costs and depreciation, the land value, the market rent, the capitalisation rate, the allocation and the interest rate are UnionMetric assumptions built from market evidence, not the station's own data. The study relies on the extraordinary assumptions that the listing's parcels, acreage, building size and zoning are accurate and that the SOP 50 10 8.1 provisions apply as summarised in the cited sources. If any proves false, the conclusions may change. Figures are rounded, and totals may differ slightly from the sum of their parts.

    What the Lender Received

    In an engagement on this file, the lender would receive:

    • A diligence request built around the asking price test: three years of returns, monthly gallons by grade, inside sales by category and the fuel supply agreement
    • The tank registry record, dispenser inventory and an environmental scope matched to tank age
    • A dated single-day price survey of every station in the ring and the Versailles cluster, an ODOT traffic count and ring demographics
    • A margin history for the station beside the NACS series, with the lender's two-year historical basis and the appraiser's normalised basis shown side by side
    • A going-concern appraisal by a qualified Certified General appraiser with the allocation to land, building, equipment and intangibles and the fixture classification stated line by line
    • The Appendix 15 coverage test under the blended amortisation, the QoE measure, and forward coverage under four margin cases
    • A data verification register separating primary-verified, secondary and modelled figures

    To discuss a fuel station, a convenience store or any change-of-ownership file, request a feasibility study.

    Sources

    1. 103 W Main St, Gettysburg, OH 45328, Retail for Sale, LoopNet, October 2026
    2. 103 W Main Street, Gettysburg, OH 45328, MLS listing, 2026
    3. Gas Stations for Sale, listing index, Crexi, October 2026
    4. Advanced Search, Darke County Auditor and Treasurer, accessed October 2026
    5. Marathon, 103 W Main St, Gettysburg, OH, GasBuddy, accessed October 2026
    6. Best Gas Prices and Local Gas Stations in Darke County, OH, GasBuddy, accessed October 2026
    7. Gettysburg, OH Gas Prices and Nearby Gas Stations, NewsBreak, accessed October 2026
    8. Gas Stations in Gettysburg, OH and Versailles, OH, YellowPages, accessed October 2026
    9. Lavy's Corner Mart and Tanning Station business profile, Better Business Bureau of Dayton and Miami Valley, accessed October 2026
    10. Gettysburg, OH Profile Data, ACS 2024 five-year, Census Reporter, accessed October 2026
    11. Gettysburg, Ohio, 2020 Census population, accessed October 2026
    12. Key Facts About Fueling, NACS, 29 June 2026
    13. Who Makes Money Selling Gas?, NACS Convenience Corner, 2025
    14. 5 Key Metrics Defining the Convenience Industry's Health, NACS Magazine, June 2026
    15. 3 Big Numbers: How did c-stores fare in 2025?, Convenience Store Dive, 2026
    16. Retail Prices for Regular Gasoline, weekly series, U.S. Energy Information Administration, through 28 September 2026
    17. Gasoline and Diesel Fuel Update, U.S. Energy Information Administration, September 2026
    18. What goes into diesel prices?, Today in Energy, U.S. Energy Information Administration, September 2026
    19. Short-Term Energy Outlook, current release and April 2026 release, U.S. Energy Information Administration, 2026
    20. Murphy USA Inc., earnings releases for Q1 and Q2 2026 (Exhibit 99.1), U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
    21. Getty Realty Corp., Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1, September 2026, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
    22. Getty Realty sale-leaseback of 41 Refuel stores, CSP Daily, September 2026
    23. Gas Prices Are Soaring, But Gas Station Investors Aren't Flinching, Bisnow, October 2026
    24. Gas Station Real Estate Draws Buyers Despite Soaring Fuel Prices, CRE Daily, 2 October 2026
    25. South East Ohio Branded Gas Station C Store For Sale Or Lease, BizQuest, 2026
    26. Ohio Gas Stations for Sale, Realmo, accessed October 2026
    27. Gas station listings in Florida, Texas and New Jersey with stated cap rates, Crexi and LoopNet, accessed October 2026
    28. Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, SOP 50 10, Version 8.1 with Technical Updates, U.S. Small Business Administration, effective 1 October 2026
    29. Information Notice 5000-880695, Issuance of SOP 50 10 8.1, U.S. Small Business Administration, 14 August 2026
    30. Information Notice 5000-882227, Issuance of Technical Updates to SOP 50 10 8.1, U.S. Small Business Administration, 25 September 2026
    31. SOP 50 10 8.1 Overview: Appendix 15, Changes of Ownership Transactions, training listing, U.S. Small Business Administration, 2026
    32. SOP Update: SBA Publishes SOP 50 10 8.1 with Technical Policy Updates, National Association of Government Guaranteed Lenders, 25 September 2026
    33. The SBA Now Requires a Quality of Earnings on Larger Acquisition Loans, CliftonLarsonAllen, 2026
    34. SBA SOP 50 10 8.1 Introduces New Quality of Earnings Requirement on Acquisitions, CBIZ, 2026
    35. New SBA Quality of Earnings Rules: SOP 50 10 8.1 Guide, Brady Ware, 2026
    36. SOP 50 10 8.1: What SBA Lenders Should Be Thinking About Before Oct. 1, Doeren, 2026
    37. Three Major SBA Announcements, Womble Bond Dickinson, September 2026
    38. SOP 50 10 8.1 is Coming: A Friendly Guide for SBA Lenders, Starfield & Smith, September 2026
    39. This Just In: SBA Releases SOP 50 10 8.1, Effective October 1, 2026, Coleman Report, August 2026
    40. SOP 50 10 8.1 summary table, StatementsReady, 2026
    41. Information Notice 5000-1340, Issuance of SOP 50 10 5(H), U.S. Small Business Administration
    42. Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, The Appraisal Foundation, current edition
    43. The Appraisal of Real Estate, Appraisal Institute
    Get Started Today

    Need to Know if Your Project Works?

    Tell us about your project and we'll send a clear proposal: scope, timeline, and fee.