Feasibility Study Consultant

    UnionMetric Appraisal & Feasibility


    Almost nobody commissions a feasibility study because they want one. They commission it because a lender asked, and the lender asked because the transaction sits in one of two categories: a start-up, or a change of ownership on property the programme treats as special purpose. On acquisition files, our SBA acquisition report stack planner shows which third-party reports the file carries and what they cost.

    So the useful question when you are choosing a consultant is not what a feasibility study is. It is what the lender is actually worried about, and whether the consultant you hire understands it well enough to answer.

    We can be specific about that, because we maintain our own analysis of the SBA loan file. What follows is computed from the agency's FOIA release as of 31 March 2026, covering 783,551 funded 7(a) loans approved between FY2010 and FY2026. It shows what the start-up penalty actually is, and where it applies.

    The short answer is that the penalty is smaller than the folklore, wildly uneven across industries, and in several categories it does not exist at all.


    What being a start-up actually costs

    Every 7(a) loan carries a business-age field. Grouping the seasoned FY2010 to FY2019 cohort by it gives the following.

    Borrower typeLoansCharged offLost per dollarMedian loan
    Start-up, loan funds will open the business72,4157.60%3.68%$178,000
    New, under two years old45,9917.39%3.41%$72,900
    Existing business307,0245.93%2.71%$125,000
    Change of ownership9,5714.22%2.09%$500,000

    Two things in that table deserve attention.

    A start-up charges off at 1.28 times the rate of an existing business, and loses 1.36 times as much per dollar. That is a real difference and it is a long way from the assumption that start-up lending is a different order of risk. Roughly one in thirteen start-up loans charges off against roughly one in seventeen for an existing business.

    Change of ownership is the safest category in the file, at 4.22 per cent, well below loans to businesses that already exist. It is also by some distance the largest loan, at a $500,000 median against $125,000.

    That second finding is the counterintuitive one, and it is worth sitting with. Buying an existing business, at the biggest average cheque in the programme, performs better than lending to a business already running. The plausible reading is selection: an acquisition has an operating history someone underwrote, a price someone negotiated, and, on special-purpose property, frequently a third-party feasibility study behind it. The scrutiny is the point.

    The start-up penalty is not the same in every industry

    This is the finding that matters most if you are choosing a consultant, because it tells you how hard your lender is going to look.

    Seasoned FY2010 to FY2019 cohort. "Penalty" is the start-up charge-off rate divided by the existing-business rate in the same industry.

    IndustryStart-upsStart-up charge-offExistingExisting charge-offPenalty
    Funeral homes1954.1%1,1941.7%2.45x
    Limited-service restaurants4,72810.3%4,7906.4%1.61x
    Gas stations with convenience store7253.9%3,5852.5%1.57x
    Full-service restaurants4,8319.5%9,3866.3%1.50x
    Fitness and recreational sports centres3,21510.1%2,3928.5%1.19x
    Car washes4634.8%1,2124.4%1.09x
    Hotels and motels9912.3%4,7192.2%1.07x
    Breweries7995.3%8505.3%0.99x
    Golf courses and country clubs323.1%2453.3%0.96x
    Veterinary services7881.5%2,4771.7%0.92x
    Child day care services1,5633.0%2,8343.6%0.84x
    Assisted living for the elderly2401.2%5622.0%0.64x
    Bowling centres872.3%3784.8%0.48x

    Read the bottom of that table first.

    In five of the thirteen industries, start-ups charge off at a lower rate than existing businesses. Bowling start-ups fail at less than half the rate of established bowling centres. Assisted living start-ups at under two thirds. That is not what anyone expects, and it has a straightforward explanation: in capital-intensive, purpose-built asset classes, a start-up is a new facility with new equipment and no deferred capital, competing against incumbents carrying twenty-year-old plant. The new entrant is not the weak operator in that market. It is frequently the strong one.

    Now read the top. Funeral homes carry the largest start-up penalty in the file at 2.45 times, which fits an industry where the business is a relationship inherited over decades and a new entrant has none of it. Restaurants and gas stations sit at 1.5 to 1.6 times.

    And note hotels at 1.07 times. Hotel start-ups perform essentially as well as hotel acquisitions, in a category where lenders reliably demand a feasibility study. That is a useful thing to be able to show a credit committee.

    The practical instruction for a sponsor: the industry you are in determines how much of the study has to carry the argument. In a 1.6x industry the study is doing heavy lifting against a real statistical prior. In a 0.6x industry the data is on your side and the study's job is to say so with evidence rather than to overcome scepticism.

    Start-up lending is shrinking as a share of the programme

    Fiscal yearStart-up share of funded 7(a) loans
    FY201013.9%
    FY201316.3%
    FY201616.7%
    FY201920.5%
    FY202217.4%
    FY202415.5%
    FY202614.8%

    Start-up lending climbed steadily through the last decade, peaked at 20.5 per cent of funded loans in FY2019, and has fallen back to under 15 per cent. FY2026 is a partial year in this release.

    For a sponsor the consequence is competitive rather than statistical. A shrinking share means lenders are more selective about start-up credit than they were five years ago, and the documentation supporting a start-up projection is doing more work than it was.


    What this means for choosing a consultant

    Ask whether they have the industry, not just the programme. The tables above show that the risk profile of a start-up is an industry property, not a general one. A consultant who can tell you where your asset class sits, and why, is reading the same evidence your lender's credit committee will.

    Independence is the requirement, not the preference. SBA requires the study be prepared by a qualified third party with no financial interest in the transaction closing. That excludes your broker, the franchisor's development team, and anyone affiliated with the seller. A study produced by an interested party is not a third-party study whatever the cover page says.

    Ask what the study will conclude if the answer is no. A consultant whose studies always support the transaction is not producing a document a lender can rely on, and experienced credit officers know which names those are.

    Settle the scope before it is ordered. Most of what causes a study to be returned is decided at engagement rather than in the analysis: which programme, whether a going-concern allocation is required, whether the property is special purpose, and what the participating lender's own credit policy demands beyond the agency minimum.

    Check what they will do with the absorption assumption. On a start-up, the ramp is the whole projection. A study that reaches stabilised performance in year one, or that borrows an absorption period from a faster asset class, will not survive review.

    What we do

    We prepare third-party feasibility studies for SBA 7(a) and 504, USDA Business and Industry, and conventional lenders, across the special-purpose asset classes where the requirement most often attaches: hotels, car washes, gas stations and truck stops, self-storage, golf, marinas, bowling and family entertainment, RV parks, manufactured housing, assisted living and restaurants.

    Each study is built to be read by a credit committee rather than by the sponsor who commissioned it: trade area drawn the way that asset class actually draws, demand quantified from the ground up in the unit the business consumes, competitive supply censused including what is permitted but not yet open, revenue built from operational units rather than from a target, cost structure at real levels with a component-built reserve, and coverage tested under the definition the programme applies.

    We also publish our analysis of the loan file, of which this page is part, because a consultant who cannot show you evidence about your industry is asking you to take their judgement on faith.


    Methodology and sources

    Computed from the SBA 7(a) FOIA loan data release as of 31 March 2026, covering approvals from FY2010 to FY2026. The data is a United States government work in the public domain.

    Population. 919,732 records, of which 783,551 are funded. Cancelled and undisbursed approvals are excluded from every figure.

    Cohorts. The business-age field is reported by the lender at approval. "Start-up" is the file's own category for a loan whose funds will open the business. "Change of ownership" is its own category and is not a subset of the others. Loans where the field was left unanswered, roughly 44,000 in the seasoned cohort, are excluded from the cohort comparison and shown separately in our full extract.

    Seasoning. Performance figures are restricted to approval years FY2010 to FY2019, because recent cohorts have not had time to season and a charge-off rate computed on unseasoned loans understates loss. FY2020 and FY2021 are excluded from performance figures entirely, since pandemic-era relief distorted both approval volume and outcomes.

    Minimum cell size. No industry appears in the penalty table with fewer than thirty start-up loans and thirty existing-business loans. Self-storage and RV parks are omitted from that table despite meeting the count threshold, because their existing-business charge-off rate is zero or near zero over the period and a ratio against it is not meaningful.

    Industry classification. NAICS as recorded on the loan. The 2022 revision moved gasoline stations from 447110 and 447190 to 457110 and 457120; the crosswalk is applied across every fiscal year, because both code sets appear in overlapping years.

    Vintage. Dollar figures are nominal, in the dollars of the approval year.

    You are welcome to cite these figures with attribution to UnionMetric Appraisal & Feasibility. If you want a cut we have not published, whether by state, by fiscal year, by cohort or by a NAICS code not shown, ask and we will run it.


    Tell us what you are financing

    Send us the property type, the location, whether this is a start-up, an acquisition or an expansion, and which programme your lender is using. We will tell you whether a third-party study is likely to be required, what it will need to contain, and what it will cost, before you commit to anything.


    Prepared by UnionMetric Appraisal & Feasibility. Figures on this page are computed from the SBA 7(a) FOIA loan data release as of 31 March 2026 and describe historical loan approvals and outcomes; they are not a forecast and not a representation about any individual transaction. Business age is as reported by the lender at approval and is not independently verified in the source file. Programme requirements including preparer qualifications and independence standards are set by SBA and are periodically revised; confirm current requirements with the participating lender before relying on any detail. Nothing on this page is legal, tax or valuation advice.

    Get Started Today

    Need to Know if Your Project Works?

    Tell us about your project and we'll send a clear proposal: scope, timeline, and fee.