Gas Stations

    How to Find and Secure a Fuel Supplier: A Guide for Gas Station Developers

    March 23, 2026
    45 min read

    Fuel supply is the operational foundation of every gas station, yet it is one of the least understood aspects of new development for first-time investors. The choice between branded and unbranded fuel, the structure of wholesale pricing, and the terms of supply agreements directly affect per-gallon margins.

    Fuel supply is the operational foundation of every gas station, yet it is one of the least understood aspects of new development for first-time investors. The broader industry outlook is reshaping how fuel supply agreements are structured. The choice between branded and unbranded fuel, the structure of wholesale pricing, and the terms of supply agreements directly affect per-gallon margins, which flow directly into the operating expense pro forma, marketing support, lender confidence, and long-term asset value. Gross fuel margins have remained above 35 cents per gallon since July 2019, with leading operators like Casey's reporting 40 to 41 cents per gallon excluding credit card fees. This guide explains how wholesale fuel pricing works, how to evaluate branded versus unbranded options, and what lenders require regarding fuel supply in feasibility studies.

    Branded, Unbranded, and Hypermarket Fuel Supply Models

    The three primary fuel supply models are branded, unbranded, and hypermarket. Branded fuel is sold under major company names with proprietary additive packages exceeding EPA minimums, marketing support, and loyalty programs. Approximately 10% of consumers choose their gas station based on brand. Branded contracts typically run 10 to 20 years with 3-year renewals. Pricing follows a fuel index benchmark plus a margin for additives, branding, and operational support.

    Unbranded fuel comes from the same refineries but with only EPA-minimum additives and no long-term contracts. The wholesale price advantage is $0.05 to $0.15 per gallon. Retailers gain full freedom over branding, pricing, and image, but face no guaranteed supply during shortages and must self-manage marketing. Hypermarket models (Costco, Kroger, Casey's, Kwik Trip) involve direct supply agreements with refiners at significantly lower wholesale prices, leveraging volumes of 500 to 1,000 or more store networks.

    Major Fuel Brand Dealer Programs

    Most brands do not deal directly with individual station owners. The process goes through branded petroleum marketers (jobbers/distributors). Shell operates 40,000 or more stations globally with TOP TIER-certified fuel featuring 2 times or more EPA-required additives and the Shell Fuel Rewards loyalty program. Sunoco serves 5,200 or more branded retailers across the U.S., distributing 8 or more billion gallons per year to 7,300 or more retailers in 33 or more states. Sunoco reports stations with new brand imaging average 12% or more volume growth and premium fuel customers are up 15%.

    Phillips 66/Conoco/76 offers a notable brand licensing model giving retailers freedom to purchase fuel on the open market while meeting branded fuel performance standards. ExxonMobil distributes through networks like CrossAmerica Partners with its Synergy branded fuel and Exxon Mobil Rewards+ loyalty program. BP/Amoco is aggressively expanding its bp pulse EV charging network. CITGO conducts quality audits and has forced 20 or more New Jersey retailers to remove branding for co-mingling unbranded fuel.

    How Wholesale Fuel Pricing Works

    The U.S. has approximately 400 rack locations comprising 1,100 or more terminals, with about 220 racks on pipeline systems. The pricing chain flows from NYMEX futures (paper contracts) to the spot market (physical barrels at 7 major refining hubs, minimum 5,000 to 50,000 barrels) to the wholesale rack (truckload quantities at terminals) to the retail pump price. Standard rack transactions cover approximately 8,000 gallons (truck and trailer load). Rack prices change daily at 6:00 PM ET based on spot market movements.

    Pricing methods available to buyers include index-based pricing (destination-based using OPIS Rack or DTN FastRacks), cost-plus pricing (supplier's cost plus agreed margin), fixed-price contracts (locked price for a set period), price cap contracts (ceiling on per-gallon price), price collar contracts (cap plus floor), and trigger contracts (activating at certain market prices). Dealer Tankwagon pricing is used when refiners deliver directly via their own network, tied to rack price plus delivery, with the price set exclusively by the oil company.

    OPIS and Platts Pricing Benchmarks

    OPIS (Oil Price Information Service), a Dow Jones company, is the most widely accepted pricing index for wholesale rack prices. Pioneering rack price discovery over 40 years ago, OPIS benchmarks underpin transactions for billions of gallons of U.S. gasoline and diesel. OPIS provides multiple benchmark timing windows (5:30 AM, 10:00 AM closing, 6:00 PM closing) and reports include branded/unbranded supplier detail. The Spot Replacement Index factors delivery costs to specific racks, estimating the cost of product delivered from bulk market including tariffs, fees, shrinkage, and transportation. S&P Global Commodity Insights (formerly Platts) provides competing benchmarks used in international and wholesale transactions.

    The Jobber/Distributor Model

    A jobber (petroleum marketer) is an independent business purchasing refined products wholesale from refiners and reselling to end users. Historically, 44.3% of all U.S. gasoline was sold through jobbers. Jobbers often own bulk plants, delivery trucks, and retail stations. Super jobbers are large resellers with supply, trading, and marketing arms, essentially oil companies without refineries. The jobber model offers bundled services: fuel supply, delivery, billing, brand relationship management, credit terms, and local market expertise.

    Direct supply from refiners eliminates the middleman markup but requires significant volume (typically large chains with 500 or more stores) and own transportation capability. Freight savings for self-hauling within 1 to 15 miles of a terminal run approximately $0.015 to $0.02 per gallon. The industry is consolidating, with jobbers acquiring stations and other jobberships, creating more super-jobbers. Key multi-brand distributors include CrossAmerica Partners (distributing Exxon, Mobil, BP, Shell, Valero, Citgo, Marathon, Phillips 66) and Sunoco LP (12 or more brands in 33 or more states).

    Supply Agreement Terms and Volume Commitments

    Branded fuel contracts typically run 10 years, with some extending to 15 to 20 years, and renewal terms of 3 years. Security deposits normally equal one full tank of fuel (refundable). Volume commitments require minimum monthly gallon purchases, negotiated based on site potential, traffic counts, and historical sales. Failure to meet minimums may trigger penalties or loss of per-gallon incentive rebates. A sample SEC filing for a Valero-CST Supply Agreement shows an effective term from 2013 through April 30, 2028 (15 years) at rack price plus $0.045 to $0.050 per gallon adder, with prompt payment discounts, quality compliance warranties, and provisions allowing the seller to require prepayment if the buyer exceeds credit limits.

    Unbranded arrangements involve no formal long-term contracts. Individual purchase orders with pricing based on current fuel indexes allow buyers to switch suppliers at will but provide no guaranteed pricing or supply security. Common wholesale fuel payment terms include 2/10 Net 30 (2% discount if paid within 10 days), 1/10 Net 10, and Net 7, Net 10, Net 14 cycles. Electronic funds transfer is increasingly standard.

    Brand Image Standards and Marketing Support

    Branded stations must comply with strict image standards covering canopy design, fascia colors, signage, lighting, pump decals, and sometimes employee uniforms. Commercial canopy costs range from $25 to $45 per square foot for basic to $30 to $60 per square foot for custom/branded installations. Some brands provide image rebates and incentives over the contract term, while others require significant dealer investment. Phillips 66's licensing model uniquely allows purchasing fuel on the open market while using the brand image.

    Major loyalty programs include Shell Fuel Rewards, BP/Amoco BPme Rewards, ExxonMobil Rewards+, and Sunoco Go Rewards. Brands provide national and regional advertising, point-of-purchase materials, consumer mobile apps with station locators, co-branded credit card programs, gift card programs, and online B2B portals for promotions and training. Sunoco reports 12% or more average volume growth for stations adopting the new brand image.

    Fuel Quality, TOP TIER Standard, and Additive Packages

    All U.S. gasoline must meet EPA minimum detergent additive standards established in 1995 to 1996. TOP TIER gasoline, created in 2004 by BMW, GM, Honda, and Toyota (now 10 or more automaker sponsors), requires approximately 3 times the EPA minimum detergent levels and prohibits metallic additives like MMT. Over 61 licensed retail brands carry TOP TIER certification for gasoline. An AAA study found cars using TOP TIER fuel averaged 19 times fewer intake valve deposits than those using non-TOP TIER fuel, with a price premium of only about $0.03 per gallon.

    Testing costs for additive makers run approximately $45,000 per additive package for TOP TIER designation. TOP TIER brands include Shell, Chevron, Costco/Kirkland, Marathon, Sunoco, Phillips 66/Conoco/76, and Valero. Additive packages are added at the loading terminal, not at individual stations, with random quality auditing of licensed retailers.

    EV Charging Integration and Future-Proofing

    S&P Global Mobility projects approximately 120,000 public/semi-public chargers installed in North America in 2025, down from over 160,000 estimated previously. The federal $5 billion NEVI program installed only 126 charging ports by late 2024 and may expire in 2026. However, major fuel retailers are investing aggressively: BP is expanding its bp pulse network with NACS connectors, and Pilot Flying J expanded to 130 locations in 25 states by March 2025 with plans for 2,000 ultra-fast chargers at 500 locations by 2026. One c-store retailer with EV chargers reported 80% conversion to store visits with purchases approximately 2 times the value of regular fuel customers. DC Fast Charger installation costs range from $150,000 to $750,000 for 2 to 4 ports. New station developers should plan electrical capacity for future EV infrastructure even if not installing immediately.

    What Lenders Require for Fuel Supply in Feasibility Studies

    SBA lenders require a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment for any loan secured by gas station real estate, with no exceptions. All Recognized Environmental Conditions must be resolved before funding. Required documentation includes all current and previous vendor or franchise agreements for the past 3 years if branded, monthly fuel and service revenue reports, jobber agreements, and brand management agreements.

    SBA 7(a) loans offer a maximum $5 million with up to 25 years for real estate and 75% to 85% SBA guarantee. SBA 504 loans allow up to $5.5 million, structured as 50% conventional lender / 35% SBA (CDC) / 15% borrower down payment for special-use properties. The top SBA gas station lender is Celtic Bank, approving 130 gas station loans from 2018 to 2023 at an average of $1.9 million. Lenders require a debt service coverage ratio of 1.25x to 1.75x, loan-to-value up to 90% for acquisitions and loan-to-cost of approximately 80% for new construction, and comprehensive business plans with 36-month financial projections. A confirmed fuel supply agreement, whether branded or unbranded, is a prerequisite for loan closing.

    For lenders and investors evaluating projects in this sector, UnionMetric provides independent gas station feasibility study services that meet SBA and USDA requirements.

    Sources

    1. OPIS (Oil Price Information Service), Rack Price Methodology and Terminal Coverage, 2024-2025
    2. H&S Energy Group/HNS Energy, Branded Versus Unbranded Fuel Contracts
    3. Sunoco LP, Branded Dealer Program and Retail Performance Data, 2024-2025
    4. AAA, TOP TIER Gasoline Study Results
    5. CrossAmerica Partners, Multi-Brand Distribution Network
    6. SEC Filing, Valero-CST Fuel Supply Agreement Terms
    7. S&P Global Mobility, North American EV Charger Installation Forecast, November 2025
    8. NACS, Pilot Flying J EV Charging Network Expansion, March 2025
    9. ProjectionHub, Top SBA Gas Station Lenders and Loan Data 2018-2023

    Looking for a lender-grade gas stations feasibility study?

    MR

    Michael Rodriguez, MAI, CCIM

    Certified commercial real estate appraiser with extensive experience in gas stations property valuations across the United States.

    View team credentials →
    Get Started Today

    Need to Know if Your Project Works?

    Tell us about your project and we'll send a clear proposal: scope, timeline, and fee.