Industry Guides

    Population Growth Rate in Feasibility Assumptions: How to Model It Correctly

    March 24, 2026
    50 min read

    Population growth is the foundational demand driver for every CRE asset class. As populations grow, demand increases for housing, retail space, hotel rooms, office space, and industrial logistics. HVS research found an R-squared of 0.952 when plotting hotel demand against U.S. population growth, meaning population alone explains over 95% of the variance in national hotel demand.

    The Current National Growth Picture: 0.5% and Volatile

    This analysis complements the broader demographic influence on feasibility framework and psychographic segmentation tools.

    The U.S. population reached 340.1 million as of July 2024, growing at 0.98% (approximately 3.3 million people), the highest annual growth rate since 2001. By July 2025, population reached 341.8 million, but the growth rate had halved to 0.5% (1.8 million), the slowest since 2021's pandemic-era 0.2%. The volatility stems from the changing composition of growth. Since 2021, net international migration has surpassed natural increase as the primary growth driver. In 2023 to 2024, net international migration accounted for 2.8 million people (84% of total growth), while natural increase (births minus deaths) contributed only approximately 519,000.

    The long-term trajectory shows steady deceleration: from 1.4% to 1.8% annual growth in the 1950s to 1960s, to 1.0% to 1.4% in the 1990s, to 0.5% to 0.7% in the 2010s. The 20th-century average was approximately 1.3% per year. No feasibility study should assume a return to that level. In 2024, 17 states experienced natural decrease (more deaths than births). The dramatic reversal from 2.7 million to 1.3 million net international migrants between 2024 and 2025 underscores how volatile migration-driven growth can be.

    Fastest and Slowest Growing States and Metros

    The fastest-growing states in 2024 to 2025 were South Carolina (1.5%), Idaho (approximately 1.3%), Texas, Delaware, and Utah (all above 1%). The Sunbelt continues to dominate growth, with the South region gaining 2,685,000 net domestic migrants between July 2020 and July 2024. Florida alone gained 810,000, North Carolina 384,000, South Carolina 300,000, and Tennessee 237,000. Moody's Analytics projects Sun Belt population will grow by another 11 million (+7.0%) over the next decade versus only 475,000 (+0.3%) for non-Sun Belt states.

    At the metro level, the fastest-growing large metros in 2023 to 2024 included Georgetown, Texas (6.4% growth), New Braunfels, Texas (5.6%), and multiple Florida, Idaho, and Carolinas metros. Growth in metro areas outpaced the nation as a whole. States losing population included Vermont, West Virginia, and Mississippi. Forty-two states grew faster in 2024 than their average over the previous 15 years, indicating a broad national rebound beyond just Sunbelt markets.

    The Five Forecasting Sources and When to Use Each

    Census Bureau Population Estimates and Projections use the cohort-component method (modeling fertility, mortality, and migration assumptions). The Vintage 2024 estimates were released December 2024; Vintage 2025 in early 2026. Census provides national, state, county, MSA, and city-level data. The limitation is that immigration assumptions can be dramatically wrong, as demonstrated by the 2021 to 2024 underestimates. State demographer offices produce independent projections using local data sources (building permits, school enrollment, utility connections) that the Census Bureau does not incorporate.

    ESRI Updated Demographics provides current-year estimates and 5-year forecasts for 2,000+ demographic and socioeconomic variables, updated annually with a current vintage of 2025/2030. ESRI projects approximately 3.18 million new households nationally over the next five years, a 2.4% increase overall (0.49% per year). Moody's Analytics provides macro-level economic and demographic forecasts. Woods and Poole Economics provides county-level projections annually from 1970 through 2060 for all U.S. counties, covering 900+ variables, priced at $1,495 for the complete download. Woods and Poole won the 2023 NABE Outlook Award for most accurate macroeconomic forecaster.

    Best practice for feasibility studies: use Census Bureau data for baseline population, ESRI for 5-year trade-area projections, Woods and Poole for long-term (10 to 20 year) county-level projections, and state demographer data for local context. Lenders want conservative assumptions with a survival-first approach and minimum DSCR of 1.15x to 1.25x.

    CAGR Methodology: The Right Way to Project Population

    Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) is the standard method for population projection in feasibility studies. The formula is: CAGR = (Ending Value / Beginning Value) raised to the power of (1/n) minus 1, where n equals the number of years. For example, if a county had 150,000 people in 2014 and 175,000 in 2024, the CAGR is (175,000/150,000) raised to (1/10) minus 1, equaling 1.55% per year. Projecting forward: Future Population = Current Population multiplied by (1 + CAGR) raised to the power of n. Using the example: 5-year projection = 175,000 multiplied by (1.0155) raised to 5 = 188,919.

    For feasibility studies, CAGR/geometric growth is the standard and most widely accepted by lenders. Appropriate time horizons vary: 5-year projections are most reliable and match typical SBA loan terms. 10-year projections are standard for CRE investment analysis. 20-year projections carry high uncertainty and are appropriate only for infrastructure planning. The longer the horizon, the more sources should be triangulated and the more conservative assumptions should be. Critical CAGR limitations: the method assumes constant growth, it is sensitive to start and end dates (starting from a COVID-era low inflates apparent growth), and it cannot account for structural breaks.

    Converting Population Growth into Demand Units

    Population to households: divide population by average household size (national average approximately 2.5 persons per household, though this varies significantly by market). Ten thousand new residents divided by 2.5 equals 4,000 new households. Households to multifamily demand: multiply new households by renter propensity (nationally approximately 31% to 36%) and then by a capture rate (typically 5% to 15% for a specific project). National retail space per capita stands at 54.3 square feet, a multi-decade low, declining from 56.5 SF in 2009 and continuing to fall at roughly 0.3% per year due to e-commerce.

    Hotel demand per capita has risen from 2.84 room-nights per person in 1987 to 3.84 room-nights recently. Hotel demand CAGR since 1987 has been approximately 1.9% annually versus population growth of roughly 1.0%, meaning demand consistently grows faster than population due to increasing per-capita travel. CoStar data shows a 10% population increase correlates with approximately 6% hotel room supply increase across 384 metro areas. Population to fuel demand is driven by population multiplied by vehicles per household, average miles driven, and fuel efficiency.

    What Lenders Accept Versus Reject in Growth Assumptions

    Reasonable revenue growth for stabilized multifamily markets is typically 2% to 3% annually. Stabilized occupancy should be projected at 93% to 95%. For hotels, long-term average U.S. demand growth of approximately 1.9% annually provides a benchmark. Lenders will reject revenue growth above 3% to 4% per year without extraordinary market justification, occupancy assumptions above market averages without compelling evidence, population growth projections that significantly exceed historical CAGR without explaining structural changes, missing downside or sensitivity analysis, and projections based on a single high-growth year rather than multi-year averages.

    The Danger of Linear Extrapolation and Why Constrained Models Matter

    Simple linear extrapolation assumes population will grow by the same absolute number indefinitely, a fundamentally flawed approach that ignores carrying capacity, infrastructure constraints, and economic cycles. A University of Illinois Chicago study published in Nature Cities (2024) found that nearly half of U.S. cities are depopulating. Logistic/constrained growth models assume population grows rapidly initially, then slows as it approaches carrying capacity (an S-curve). These are more appropriate when infrastructure, water, or land constraints exist.

    Infrastructure constraints that cap growth include water rights (Colorado River Basin states face severe scarcity), sewer and wastewater capacity (EPA estimates $655 billion needed over 20 years), road capacity, power grid capacity (data centers and population growth are straining electrical infrastructure), and school capacity. North Carolina highlighted this tension at a March 2026 forum, noting that population growth is overwhelming water infrastructure with an estimated need of $20 billion for drinking water and $21 billion for wastewater investment. Gas station fuel volume projections are directly tied to population density and traffic growth within the trade area. Self-storage demand correlates strongly with population growth, household mobility, and housing turnover rates.

    Case Studies of Projects Destroyed by Optimistic Growth Projections

    Las Vegas multifamily overbuilding (2003 to 2010) stands as a cautionary landmark. During 2003 to 2007, developers aggressively acquired land, extrapolating rapid population growth. An average of 3,200 multifamily units were delivered annually from 2007 to 2009. When the job market dropped nearly 15% from 2008 to 2010, vacancy rates soared from 4.6% to 11.8%, and $2.2 billion in distressed multifamily properties accumulated. Phoenix has repeated the pattern. In 2024, Phoenix again became an epicenter of multifamily construction with vacancy rates climbing as supply additions exceeded absorption capacity despite strong population growth. Growth alone does not guarantee absorption if supply is excessive.

    Net Migration Versus Natural Increase: Why the Distinction Matters

    For CRE analysts, net migration is far more important than natural increase because migration creates localized demand surges or collapses. A market can have zero natural increase but enormous growth from domestic in-migration (Idaho, South Carolina, and North Carolina demonstrate this pattern). Migration is also far more volatile, subject to economic conditions, policy changes, housing affordability, and remote work trends. In 2023 to 2024, 16 states depended on immigration for 100% of their population growth. The dramatic reversal from 2.7 million to 1.3 million net international migrants between 2024 and 2025 means large coastal metros that recently returned to growth via immigration may revert to decline.

    How SBA and USDA Reviewers Evaluate Growth Assumptions

    SBA and USDA reviewers expect feasibility studies that use verifiable, third-party data from recognized sources, benchmark financial projections against industry standards, apply conservative growth assumptions (survival first, growth second), include risk assessment and sensitivity analysis, and present DSCR coverage under stress scenarios. Poor-quality or overly optimistic studies are a primary reason for loan denial. Reviewers specifically flag projections that diverge significantly from established sources like Census Bureau estimates, ESRI forecasts, or Woods and Poole projections without clear justification. The strongest feasibility studies triangulate multiple sources and present a range of scenarios rather than a single-point estimate.

    For lenders and investors evaluating projects in this sector, UnionMetric provides independent USDA feasibility study services that meet SBA and USDA requirements.

    Sources

    1. U.S. Census Bureau, Population Estimates Vintage 2024 and 2025
    2. U.S. Census Bureau, Older Adults Outnumber Children in 11 States, June 2025
    3. Loan Analytics, Per-Capita Demand and the U.S. Hotel Cycle
    4. ESRI, Updated Demographics Documentation, 2025/2030 Vintage
    5. Woods and Poole Economics, County-Level Projections Methodology
    6. Clarion Partners, U.S. Sun Belt Boom: Real Estate Investment Management, 2024
    7. GlobeSt, Retail Space Per Capita Hits a Multi-Decade Low, September 2023
    8. CoStar, Population Gains Tend to Drive Hotel Room Growth
    9. Governing, 42 States Grew Faster in 2024 Than Over the Previous 15 Years

    Looking for a lender-grade industry guides feasibility study?

    RM

    Robert Mitchell, MAI, SRA, AI-GRS

    Certified commercial real estate appraiser with extensive experience in industry guides property valuations across the United States.

    View team credentials →
    Get Started Today

    Need to Know if Your Project Works?

    Tell us about your project and we'll send a clear proposal: scope, timeline, and fee.