SBA 504 Express Car Wash Case Study: 12994 Tamiami Trail S, North Port, Florida, Feasible Only If the Approved Tunnel Next Door Is Not Built

    A model feasibility study and valuation of a new 130-foot express tunnel car wash on a listed 2.1-acre site on US 41, financed with an SBA 504 loan. The case is built on the valuation problem every start-up special-purpose project raises: the gap between the value on the day it opens and the value once its membership base is built, and where that value actually sits. For an express car wash in a saturating market, most of it sits in the membership business, not in the real estate the 504 programme finances.

    By Robert Mitchell, MAI, SRA, AI-GRS, UnionMetric Feasibility | 6 October 2026

    Study at a Glance

    ItemFinding
    Subject12994 Tamiami Trail S (US 41), North Port, Sarasota County, Florida 34287
    Parcel0997-05-0003 (listing); Activity Center 1 (AC-1) zoning
    SiteAbout 2.1 acres; about 425 feet of US 41 frontage; 39,500 AADT (2023, broker-reported)
    Listed price$1,500,000 for the land, marketed with an express car wash site plan "approved by right"
    Project130-foot express tunnel, 4,500 SF building, three pay lanes, 19 free vacuum stalls
    Total 504 project cost$6,425,500 ($37,888 per tunnel foot excluding land)
    FinancingSBA 504, start-up special-purpose property: 50% bank, 30% CDC debenture, 20% borrower
    Prospective value upon completion$5,560,000 (going concern)
    Prospective value upon stabilisation (Year 3)$6,340,000 (going concern), 98.7% of project cost
    Real property value (land, building, site improvements)$3,185,000 at completion and stabilisation
    Stabilised coverage1.42x in Year 3; 0.37x in Year 1, covered by a $300,000 ramp reserve
    Membership needed for 1.00x2,062 members at $32 a month, against 2,600 modelled
    DeterminationFeasible with 20% 504 equity and a ramp reserve if the approved tunnel next door is not built; not feasible if it is

    Determination

    The project is feasible as proposed, on one condition that no amount of equity can replace. A third Tommy's Express tunnel was approved by the North Port City Commission in January 2024 "next to the Fellowship Church", and Fellowship Church sits on the parcel adjoining the subject. If that approval covers the subject parcel, which would explain the broker's "approved by right" plans, the buyer controls the site and the competitive set is the one analysed here. If it covers the adjoining tract, a franchised tunnel with an entrenched membership programme opens next door, and the project fails: stabilised coverage falls to 0.39 times and the going-concern value to about $1.47 million, less than a quarter of what the project costs. The permit record must settle the question before a lender commits.

    On the first reading, the project works. A $6,425,500 project financed 50/30/20 (a $3,212,750 bank first lien, a $1,927,650 CDC debenture and $1,285,100 of borrower equity) carries $435,430 of annual debt service. The wash reaches 2,600 members at a blended $32 a month and 30,000 retail washes a year in Year 3, producing EBITDA of $616,698 and coverage of 1.42 times. Year 1 covers its debt service only 0.37 times while the membership base builds, so the borrower funds a $300,000 ramp reserve, with pre-opening marketing and working capital, outside the 504 project, bringing total borrower cash to $1,735,100, or 25.2 per cent.

    The valuation explains why the structure needs every part of that equity. The going concern is worth $5.56 million on opening day and $6.34 million once stabilised, about what it cost. But only $3.19 million of that is real property. The rest is equipment and the membership business, and at completion the 504 debt equals 92 per cent of the going-concern value and almost all of the real property and equipment combined.

    Scope, Basis and Data Verification

    This is a model study. UnionMetric was not engaged on this property, did not inspect it, and has no relationship with the seller, the listing broker, any operator or any prospective buyer. The subject is a real parcel publicly listed for sale as of the effective date, 6 October 2026, and marketed for an express car wash. It was chosen because its record contains what this case is meant to teach: a special-purpose start-up, a market where membership pricing is already competitive, published evidence of national saturation, and an approved competing project whose location must be resolved. The value indications illustrate method on public data and labelled assumptions. They are not an appraisal, they are not an opinion of market value for any intended user, and they must not be relied on in any transaction involving the property.

    The study follows the sequence a lender-grade engagement follows on a 504 special-purpose start-up: site and entitlement, planned competition, market and membership pricing, a volume and membership ramp model, highest and best use, the cost approach with entrepreneurial incentive and external obsolescence, the income approach upon stabilisation, the value upon completion, the allocation between real property, equipment and business value, and loan sizing against project cost, appraised value and coverage. The Feasibility Study Methodology Navigator maps the same sequence for other asset classes.

    StatusItems
    Primary-verifiedMister Car Wash SEC filings and releases (FY2023 to Q1 2026); membership and single-wash prices on the Tommy's Express and Coastal Express websites (6 October 2026); City of North Port utility rates, meter fees and wastewater plant capacity; the 2024 Unified Land Development Code adoption; North Port Census QuickFacts; 504 debenture pricing for 10 September 2026
    SecondaryThe subject's parcel ID, price, acreage, zoning, AADT and site plan (listing portals); the January 2024 Tommy's Express approval (Sun Newspapers); capacity fees (2021 and 2022 documents); all net lease cap rates (asking); construction cost ranges; churn and volume benchmarks; 504 equity and occupancy percentages; the Mister Car Wash take-private and the Zips restructuring
    Not obtainedThe Sarasota County Property Appraiser and Tax Collector records; an FDOT count; one, three and five-mile ring demographics and vehicles; competitor tunnel lengths, opening years and taxes; county-recorded closed sales; a contractor bid
    ModelledTunnel length and budget, membership ramp, rates, retail volume, churn, expenses, capitalisation and discount rates, market rent, equipment depreciation, the bank interest rate

    The Valuation Problem This Case Is Built On

    A start-up special-purpose property has two values that a lender must keep apart. The prospective value upon completion is the value on the day the tunnel opens, with the building finished and almost no members. The prospective value upon stabilisation is the value once membership has been built, typically after 24 to 36 months. On an express car wash the gap between them is large, because most of the income is recurring membership revenue that does not exist on opening day.

    The second problem is where the value sits. An express car wash has three kinds of asset: land, building and site improvements; the tunnel equipment, vacuums and pay stations; and the membership business, the base of subscribers and the operation that keeps them. The 504 programme finances the first two. The third is business value. In a market where membership prices are being matched and new tunnels keep opening, the real estate can be worth much less than it cost even when the operating business is worth roughly what the whole project cost.

    The third problem is competition that does not exist yet. USPAP Standards Rule 1-4 requires income projections to weigh reasonably anticipated events, including competition from developments planned or under construction. An approved tunnel on the next parcel is exactly that event.

    Method. A lender sizing a construction loan looks at the value upon completion, because that is the collateral it holds when the last draw funds. The value upon stabilisation matters for the take-out and for proving the project is worth building, but it is a forecast. A study that reports only the stabilised value, or labels it as the as-complete value, overstates the collateral by the full cost of building the membership base.

    Project Business Plan

    The Project is the development and operation of an express exterior tunnel car wash on about 2.1 acres at 12994 Tamiami Trail S (US 41) in North Port, Sarasota County, with about 425 feet of frontage on a corridor the broker reports at 39,500 vehicles a day in 2023, up from 31,500 in 2020. The broker's site plan, reviewed here only as marketed, shows a tunnel of at least 125 feet laid out parallel to US 41, three pay-station lanes, 19 free vacuum stalls, five additional parking spaces and room for on-site stormwater retention; the model uses a 130-foot tunnel in a 4,500 SF building with water reclamation. The wash operates seven days a week from early morning to evening with a site manager, an assistant manager and about eight full-time-equivalent attendants, and sells four unlimited membership tiers and four single-wash packages through plate recognition and app-based billing. The borrower is a newly formed operating company that owns the land and improvements and occupies 100 per cent of the building, as the 504 programme requires of a single-tenant special-purpose project. The wash is positioned at the middle of the local membership grid, with a blended member rate of about $32 a month against $19.99 to $49.99 tiers already offered on the corridor, and targets households in the fast-growing southern end of North Port and through traffic on US 41.

    Marketing & Sales Strategy

    The launch is built on membership pre-sales. Founding-member pricing is sold for 60 days before opening from a sales trailer on site and through geo-targeted digital advertising to households within about five miles, with the first month free or discounted for members who enrol before opening. Opening weeks run free-wash days to put cars through the tunnel and convert retail customers into members at the pay station, where attendants are paid on member sign-ups. Channels are the wash's own app and website, plate-recognition lanes that make membership frictionless, and local social media. Business-to-business outreach targets fleet memberships for real estate agencies, home-service contractors, dealerships and the city's own vehicle fleet. The built-in acquisition channel is the pay station itself: every retail wash is a membership pitch.

    Amenities

    • 130-foot express exterior tunnel with conveyor, friction and touchless components, and high-velocity dryers
    • Four unlimited membership tiers and four single-wash packages
    • Three automated pay-station lanes with plate recognition
    • 19 free vacuum stalls under shade canopies
    • Water reclamation system
    • Five additional parking spaces and on-site stormwater retention
    • About 425 feet of US 41 frontage with a layout parallel to the highway

    Subject Site: Parcel, Zoning, Access, Flood, Utilities and Tax

    The site is listed on LoopNet and BizQuest at $1,500,000 for about 2.1 acres (listed as "over 2 acres" on one portal), parcel 0997-05-0003, zoned Activity Center 1, with no improvements. The parcel and owner of record are confirmed on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser site at engagement.

    The broker describes the car wash as "approved by right with city of North Port." That claim needs two checks. First, North Port adopted a rewritten Unified Land Development Code on 6 August 2024, so the AC-1 use table must be read under the new code, not the one in force when any earlier approval was granted. Second, the January 2024 Tommy's Express approval, reported as one the Commission "could not be denied due to a permitted code," was described as "on U.S. 41 next to the Fellowship Church." The next section deals with that.

    The adjoining parcel at 13000 Tamiami Trail (10.06 acres) is mapped in flood zone AE, panel 12115C0370G, and the subject is likely on the same plat. An AE designation means the building must be elevated or floodproofed to the base flood elevation, adds fill and stormwater cost, and requires flood insurance on the 504 collateral. The budget below carries the elevation work in site costs.

    Water and sewer come from the City of North Port Utilities Department, whose Pan American Boulevard wastewater plant has 7.0 million gallons a day of capacity. Monthly rates were set by Resolution 2025-R-66, effective 1 November 2025, after a rate study recommending 10 per cent increases in each of three years. Meter installation fees run from $320 for a one-inch meter without a tap to actual cost for three inches and above. Capacity fees were reported at $1,872 per ERC for water and $2,213 for sewer in 2021, and the 2022 coverage of Ordinance 2022-24 cited a $4,000 capacity fee plus line extension charges where no mains exist. How many ERCs the city assigns to a car wash, and the current fee per ERC, are confirmed at engagement; the budget carries $85,000 for capacity fees and meters.

    Method. Utility cost matters more for a car wash than for almost any other commercial use. A reclaim system cuts water purchases, but sewer charges, capacity fees and a city committed to three years of 10 per cent increases go straight into the operating statement. The study carries utilities at 6.2 per cent of stabilised revenue and tests the line, rather than borrowing a chain-wide ratio that hides utilities inside other costs.

    Real estate taxes for vacant land were not obtained. Taxes on the completed wash are modelled at $72,000 a year, about 1.6 per cent of an assessed value near the cost of the improvements, and confirmed with the Property Appraiser at engagement.

    The Approved Tunnel Next Door

    On 21 February 2024 Sun Newspapers reported that the North Port City Commission had approved the city's third Tommy's Express "on U.S. 41 next to the Fellowship Church." Fellowship Church Inc. is listed at 13000 Tamiami Trail, the parcel next to the subject. Two readings are possible, and they lead to opposite conclusions.

    ReadingWhat it meansConsequence for the project
    The approval covers the subject parcelThe broker's "approved by right" plans are the Tommy's plans, and the franchisee did not proceedThe buyer inherits a franchisor-designed plan whose transferability must be confirmed; no competing tunnel opens next door; the base case applies
    The approval covers the adjoining tractA franchised tunnel with an established membership programme can open next doorThe subject's capture collapses; Scenario B applies and the project is not feasible

    The case is a direct application of USPAP Standards Rule 1-4: an income projection that ignores an approved competitor on the next parcel is not credible. North Port's development permit records, the site plan approval number and the parcel ID on the approved plans settle the question. Until they do, the study cannot clear the site, and a lender should not issue a commitment.

    Method. A planned competitor is not handled by a generic vacancy allowance. It is modelled as its own scenario, with its own capture, pricing response and value, because its effect is not proportional. Here it does not trim the projection; it removes the project's ability to cover debt.

    Market Area and Demand

    North Port is the largest city in Sarasota County by area and one of the fastest-growing in Florida. Census QuickFacts puts its population at 92,875 (July 2024), with 31,569 households averaging 2.55 persons, a median household income of $81,940 and per capita income of $40,917 (2023 dollars), and 81.2 per cent owner occupancy. A newer five-year release reported by aggregators shows median household income of $84,049 and about 34,400 households. Owner-occupied, car-dependent suburban households with incomes above the state median are the core market for unlimited wash memberships.

    Ring demographics and vehicles per household are built at engagement by aggregating block-group ACS tables, including table B25044 for vehicles available, for one, three and five miles around the site. The study uses the city as a proxy: 2,600 members would equal 8.2 per cent of North Port's households, sold into a market where two operators already sell memberships from three tunnels.

    Traffic is the second test. At 39,500 vehicles a day, the Year 3 volume of 108,000 cars a year, about 296 a day, is a capture of 0.75 per cent of passing traffic. An FDOT count from Florida Traffic Online replaces the broker figure at engagement.

    Competitive Supply: Competitor Census

    Prices were read from each operator's own website on 6 October 2026. Tunnel lengths, opening years, taxes and acreage were not obtained and are collected from the Sarasota and Charlotte County records at engagement.

    Competitor Number 1

    Tommy's Express, Front Place

    This franchised express tunnel is located at 1141 Front Pl, North Port, FL 34287. Its unlimited plans are $24.99, $31.99, $37.99 and $43.99 a month, and its single washes $13, $18, $22 and $27.

    Competitor Number 2

    Tommy's Express, Sun Market Place

    This franchised express tunnel is located at 1155 Sun Market Pl, North Port, near Price Boulevard. It carries the same pricing as the Front Place location.

    Competitor Number 3

    Coastal Express Car Wash, Aidan Lane

    This express exterior tunnel with free vacuums, part of an eight-site regional operator, is located at 4420 Aidan Ln, North Port, FL 34287. Its unlimited plans are $19.99, $29.99, $39.99 and $49.99 a month, and its single washes $10, $15, $20 and $25.

    Competitor Number 4

    North Port Car Wash

    This independent touchless in-bay wash with a tunnel component and free vacuums, built in 2018 with 1,930 SF, is located at 14164 Tamiami Trl, North Port, FL 34287. Aggregators cite single washes of about $8 to $15. Its real estate is listed for sale at $1,049,995.

    Competitor Number 5

    Tommy's Express, approved

    The third Tommy's Express in North Port was approved in January 2024 on US 41 next to the Fellowship Church. Its build status is unknown.

    Coastal Express also operates at 3291 Tamiami Trail and 2105 S Tamiami Trail in Port Charlotte, probably at or beyond five miles; Road Runners Express operates at 111 S Tamiami Trail in Port Charlotte; Bubble Down has announced a Port Charlotte location for 2026; and DJ's Car Wash at 14956 Tamiami Trail is marked permanently closed.

    TierCoastal ExpressTommy's ExpressModel for the subject
    Entry unlimited$19.99$24.99Sold, but not the anchor
    Second tier$29.99$31.99Core of the mix
    Third tier$39.99$37.99Core of the mix
    Top unlimited$49.99$43.99Minority of members
    Blended member rateNot disclosedNot disclosed$32 a month at stabilisation; $29 in Year 1 with founding-member pricing
    Single washes$10 to $25$13 to $27$16 average ticket in Year 1, $17 thereafter

    Two operators already set the local floor at $19.99 and $24.99 and the ceiling at $43.99 and $49.99. A new entrant cannot price above that grid and should not model the top tier as the mix. The blended $32 sits slightly below the middle and assumes any promotion by an incumbent is matched.

    The Saturation Evidence

    The national evidence through the first quarter of 2026 describes an industry past its peak growth.

    SignalEvidence
    Comparable-store salesMister Car Wash: up 2.9% in FY2025, slowing from 6.0% in Q1 to 1.6% in Q4, then up 3.9% in Q1 2026; the company described a "challenging retail environment" in Q2 2025
    Membership shareMister Car Wash: 79% of wash sales in Q4 2025 and 76% in Q1 2026; about 2.5 million members at 31 March 2026
    DistressZips Car Wash filed for Chapter 11 in February 2025 with about $654 million of funded debt, emerged in April 2025 under lender ownership with about 230 sites; its first-day declaration said more than 900 new washes had opened each year for five years
    Repricing of platformsDriven Brands sold its U.S. car wash business for $385 million in April 2025 after an $851 million goodwill impairment; Mister Car Wash was taken private at a $3.1 billion enterprise value, completed May 2026
    ChurnIndustry averages across 2025 of about 4.1% voluntary and 3.6% involuntary churn a month, about 7.7% combined; reported annual churn rose to 31% from 29%
    Local pushbackCape Coral paused new car wash applications from April 2024 to January 2025 with 16 washes open and 12 more in the pipeline, then required one-mile separation between new washes

    None of this says a well-located wash cannot succeed. It says the margin for error is gone. Membership growth now comes from taking members from someone else, churn is high enough that a wash must sign about 182 new members a month just to hold 2,600 at 7 per cent, and the capital markets have repriced the sector.

    Volume, Membership and Revenue Model

    YearAverage membersBlended rateMember revenueRetail washesAverage ticketRetail revenueOther revenueTotal revenueCars a yearCars a day
    11,150$29.00$400,20036,000$16.00$576,000$19,922$996,12270,500193
    22,150$31.00$799,80031,500$17.00$535,500$27,251$1,362,55196,000263
    32,600$32.00$998,40030,000$17.00$510,000$30,784$1,539,184108,000296
    42,600$32.80$1,023,36030,000$17.43$522,750$31,553$1,577,663108,000296
    52,600$33.62$1,048,94430,000$17.86$535,819$32,342$1,617,105108,000296

    Members wash about 2.5 times a month, about 30 times a year, in line with published member frequency. Membership is 66 per cent of wash revenue at stabilisation, below the 76 to 79 per cent Mister Car Wash reports across a mature chain, because a single new site sells more retail washes while it builds its base. Other revenue (add-ons, vending, gift cards and fleet accounts) is 2 per cent. Rates rise 2.5 per cent a year from Year 4.

    Method. Membership is a stock, not a flow. The base at any date equals the members signed less the members lost, so the projection must state both the acquisition rate and the churn rate it assumes. At 7 per cent monthly churn, 182 sign-ups a month hold 2,600 members; at 8 per cent the same sign-ups hold only 2,275. A projection that states a member count without the churn behind it cannot be tested.

    At about $1.54 million of stabilised revenue, the subject sits below the $1.9 to $2.0 million that Mister Car Wash's FY2025 revenue implies per location. That is the right relationship: a mature national chain with pricing power and an established base is the ceiling for a single new site, not its base case.

    Stabilised Operating Statement, Year 3

    LineAmount% of revenue
    Total revenue$1,539,184100.0%
    Labour (site manager, assistant, about eight FTE attendants)$345,00022.4%
    Chemicals and supplies$107,7437.0%
    Utilities (water, sewer, electric)$95,0006.2%
    Repairs, maintenance and equipment service$70,0004.5%
    Marketing, app and membership software$45,0002.9%
    Card processing and recurring billing$46,1763.0%
    Insurance (wind and flood)$55,0003.6%
    Real estate taxes (modelled)$72,0004.7%
    Management (market fee)$61,5674.0%
    General, administrative, professional and security$25,0001.6%
    Total operating expenses$922,48659.9%
    EBITDA$616,69840.1%
    Reserve for replacement$46,1763.0%
    Net operating income$570,52237.1%

    Labour and chemicals together are 29.4 per cent of revenue, against 29 per cent for Mister Car Wash in FY2025. A single site cannot spread fixed labour as widely as a chain, but it also carries no regional overhead, and the two effects roughly offset. Mister Car Wash's other store operating expenses, 42 per cent of revenue, include rent, which an owner-occupied 504 project does not pay; the subject's debt service takes its place below EBITDA. A market management fee is charged even though the borrower will run the wash, because a lender underwrites arm's-length costs. The reserve of 3 per cent reflects an equipment-heavy asset with a tunnel that needs brushes, motors and controllers replaced on a short cycle.

    Highest and Best Use

    As though vacant, the site is zoned AC-1 and, on the broker's account, a car wash is permitted by right, subject to confirmation under the 2024 code. The site is physically suited to a range of highway commercial uses: 2.1 acres, about 425 feet of US 41 frontage and room for stacking and retention. Financial feasibility separates the candidates. An express car wash is financially feasible only if the approved tunnel next door is not built; quick-service restaurant, fuel, retail and self-storage pads are the alternatives the corridor already supports, and the alternate parcel analysed for this case at 6040 Talon Bay Drive is entitled for self-storage. The highest and best use as though vacant is highway commercial development, with an express car wash maximally productive only under the first reading of the approval record.

    As proposed, the use passes the feasibility test only marginally: the value upon stabilisation is 98.7 per cent of cost. That is enough for an owner-operator who earns the operating return, and not enough for a merchant developer who needs a profit on cost.

    Cost Approach: Entrepreneurial Incentive and External Obsolescence

    ComponentAmount
    Land, 2.1 acres at the listed price ($16.40 per SF)$1,500,000
    Real property improvements (site work, building, reclaim, signage, and their share of contingency, fees, design and interim interest)$2,946,250
    Real property, cost new$4,446,250
    Equipment (tunnel, vacuums, pay stations and their share of contingency)$1,979,250
    Total project cost new$6,425,500
    Prospective value upon stabilisation, going concern$6,340,000
    Market-extracted entrepreneurial incentiveNil
    Real property value by income (below)$3,185,000
    External obsolescence in the real property$1,261,250, or 28% of its cost

    The land is carried at its listed price, which the study treats as market value for the model; land sales on the corridor are collected at engagement. The improvements are new, so physical and functional depreciation are nil.

    Entrepreneurial incentive is the reward a developer expects for taking on a project. It cannot be borrowed from a rule of thumb; it has to be extracted from the market by comparing what completed projects are worth with what they cost. Here the stabilised going-concern value is 98.7 per cent of cost, so the extracted incentive is nil. In a market still absorbing new tunnels, a developer cannot expect to sell a stabilised wash for more than it cost to build.

    The real property tells a sharper story. Land and improvements cost $4.45 million; capitalising the rent a market tenant would pay for them gives $3.19 million. The $1.26 million difference is external obsolescence: a car wash building has one use, its rent is limited by what a wash on that corner can earn, and in a saturating market that earning power does not support the cost of building it.

    Method. In a growing market a new special-purpose building is usually worth about its cost, and the cost approach confirms the income approach. In a saturating one the cost approach is where the problem shows. The external obsolescence here is measured, not extracted: it is the difference between cost and an independent income value of the real property alone. A study that reports cost as value because the building is new has skipped the only test that tells the lender what the real estate is worth without the business.

    Income Approach: Value Upon Stabilisation

    The capitalisation rate is built from three tests.

    TestInputsIndicated rate
    Net lease market, askingListed car wash net lease inventory: 6.48% (Q2 2025), 6.37% (July 2025), 6.33% (August 2025), 6.27% (November 2025), 6.21% (April 2026)6.2% to 6.5%
    Going-concern premiumOwner-operated, unbranded, single-site start-up rather than a credit tenant on a 17 to 19-year lease; business risk; equipment wearPlus about 250 basis points
    Band of investment, conventional terms65% loan at 7.25% over 25 years (constant 8.67%); 35% equity at 12%9.84%

    Net lease asking rates are the floor: they price a lease from a national operator, not the business itself, and closed sale-leasebacks usually clear somewhat above asking. The going-concern rate sits above the net lease range and below the conventional band of investment, which overstates the rate an SBA-financed buyer can accept. The concluded overall rate is 9.00 per cent.

    Year 3 NOI of $570,522 capitalised at 9.00 per cent gives $6,339,100, rounded to $6,340,000, or 98.7 per cent of the $6,425,500 project cost.

    Value Upon Completion: Pricing the Membership Ramp

    The value upon completion is the stabilised value less the cost of getting there, priced as a buyer would price it on opening day.

    StepAmount
    Year 1 NOI, discounted one year at 11.5%$116,396
    Year 2 NOI, discounted two years$347,417
    Value upon stabilisation ($6,340,000), discounted two years$5,098,947
    Prospective value upon completion, going concern$5,562,760, rounded to $5,560,000
    Deduction for the membership ramp$776,378

    The discount rate of 11.5 per cent is 250 basis points above the overall rate, for the risk that the ramp runs slower than modelled.

    Method. USPAP treats both values as prospective opinions with their own effective dates, supported by extraordinary assumptions about completion and market conditions. The Appraisal Institute's guidance is that an appraiser should not accept the developer's completion or stabilisation date at face value but should test whether the market can deliver it. The ramp deduction is that test expressed in dollars: $776,000 is the price of a membership base that does not exist on opening day.

    Where the Value Sits: Real Property, Equipment and the Membership Business

    ComponentUpon completionUpon stabilisationBasis
    Real property (land, building, site improvements)$3,185,000$3,185,000Market rent of $230,900 (15% of stabilised revenue) capitalised at 7.25%
    Equipment (tunnel, vacuums, pay stations)$1,979,250$1,567,000Cost new; depreciated 2.5 years of a 12-year life by Year 3
    Membership base and operating business$398,510$1,588,000Residual
    Going concern$5,562,760$6,340,000Income approach

    The real property is valued on what an operator would pay to rent it. Mister Car Wash paid $31.8 million of rent in Q1 2026 on 493 leased washes, about $258,000 per lease a year, or about 13 per cent of its revenue per site; listed net lease car washes carried average NOI of $318,000 to $324,000. A rent of 15 per cent of the subject's stabilised revenue, $230,900, is consistent with that evidence for a single site with lower revenue, and leaves the operator EBITDA of 2.7 times the rent. Capitalised at 7.25 per cent, between the net lease asking range and the going-concern rate because the tenant is not a national credit, the real property is worth $3,185,000. Market rent does not depend on how many members the current operator has signed, so the real property value is the same at completion and at stabilisation. The ramp belongs to the business, not the building.

    The membership base and operating business grow from $398,510 at completion, mostly the pre-sold founding members and the launched systems, to $1,588,000 at stabilisation. About $450,000 of that is the cost to recreate the base and its systems (2,600 members at about $150 each in launch discounts and marketing, plus $60,000 of systems and launch costs); the remaining $1,138,000 is going-concern value earned by the location and the operation.

    Method. On an express car wash, subscription revenue makes the business component unusually large and unusually perishable. Members belong to the operator's billing system, not to the land; if the wash closes, they cancel. A lender that treats the stabilised going-concern value as real estate collateral is lending against subscriptions. The allocation is what shows the 504 lender how much of its collateral would survive a failure of the business.

    SBA 504 Programme Compliance

    RequirementAs reportedThis file
    StructureFirst-lien lender 50%, CDC/SBA 40%, borrower 10% as standardAdjusted below for special purpose and start-up
    Special-purpose propertyBorrower contribution of 15%Car wash is special-purpose
    New businessAdditional contribution for a start-upNew operating company
    Special-purpose start-up20% borrower contribution: 50% / 30% / 20%; reportedly unchanged under SOP 50 10 8.1$1,285,100 of $6,425,500
    OccupancyNew construction at least 60% occupied at the outset, 80% within 10 years100% owner-occupied
    Debenture rate10 September 2026 sale: 25-year debenture 5.41% (Treasury 4.91% plus 0.50%); about 6.54% effective with ongoing fees; next pricing 8 October 20266.54% modelled
    Ongoing fees inside the effective rateSBA about 0.364%, CDC 0.625%, central servicing agent 0.100%Included
    Upfront guaranty fee50 basis points for non-manufacturing projects; FY2027 schedule for approvals from 1 October 2026Financed with the debenture
    AppraisalIndependent appraisal by a state-certified general appraiser for a real estate project of this sizeAs-complete and as-stabilised values, with allocation
    ProjectionsSOP 50 10 8.1 reportedly bars projections as a substitute for history on changes of ownership, with an exception for owner-occupied special-purpose property; a start-up has no history and is underwritten on projections and the feasibility studyThis study

    Every 504 provision above comes from CDC rate pages, lender commentaries and published summaries rather than the SOP text, and is read against the 1 October 2026 version before commitment. The SBA feasibility study page explains how the study fits the 504 and 7(a) credit files.

    Project Cost Estimate and Loan Assumptions

    Location: 12994 Tamiami Trail S, North Port, FL 34287 | Tunnel: 130 feet | Size in SF (Gross): 4,500 | Site: 2.1 acres

    ItemCostCost in %Cost per SF
    Land Cost
    Land (2.1 acres)$1,500,00023.3%$333.33
    Hard Cost
    Site Work, Stormwater Retention, Flood Elevation and Utilities$1,050,00016.3%$233.33
    Tunnel Building (4,500 SF at $230 per SF)$1,035,00016.1%$230.00
    Water Reclamation System$150,0002.3%$33.33
    Signage$90,0001.4%$20.00
    Total Hard Cost$2,325,00036.2%$516.67
    Improvements
    Tunnel Wash Equipment (130 feet)$1,350,00021.0%$300.00
    Vacuum System and Canopies (19 stalls)$325,0005.1%$72.22
    Pay Stations, Gates, POS, Plate Recognition and Membership Software$210,0003.3%$46.67
    Total Equipment$1,885,00029.3%$418.89
    Soft Cost
    Architecture, Engineering, Permits and Surveys$240,0003.7%$53.33
    Utility Capacity Fees and Meters (modelled)$85,0001.3%$18.89
    Contingency (5% of hard cost and equipment)$210,5003.3%$46.78
    Total Soft Cost$535,5008.3%$119.00
    Financial Cost
    Construction-Period Interest and Interim Lender Fees$180,0002.8%$40.00
    Total Financial Cost$180,0002.8%$40.00
    Total Subject Project Cost$6,425,500100.0%$1,427.89

    Source: Listing data, 2026 published construction cost ranges, City of North Port fee schedules, UnionMetric

    Loan Assumptions
    LTC Ratio (504 debt)80.0%
    Bank First Lien$3,212,750 (50%); 7.25% (modelled); 25-year amortisation; debt service $278,664
    CDC Debenture$1,927,650 (30%); 6.54% effective; 25 years; debt service $156,766
    Equity$1,285,100 (20%)
    Annual Debt Service$435,430
    Borrower funds outside the 504 project$450,000: pre-opening membership launch and training $120,000; ramp reserve $300,000; working capital and initial chemicals $30,000
    Total borrower cash$1,735,100, or 25.2% of $6,875,500

    The working budget of $4.93 million excluding land sits inside the published 2026 ranges of $2.6 million to $5.7 million and $3 million to $7 million for an express tunnel project, and inside the $4.5 million to $6.0 million a 130 to 150-foot tunnel on a Florida pad implies. It is replaced by a contractor and equipment-vendor bid at engagement.

    Five-Year Pro Forma and Debt Service Coverage

    YearTotal revenueOperating expensesEBITDAReserveNOIDebt serviceDSCR
    1$996,122$836,457$159,665$29,884$129,782$435,4300.37x
    2$1,362,551$889,757$472,794$40,877$431,917$435,4301.09x
    3$1,539,184$922,486$616,698$46,176$570,522$435,4301.42x
    4$1,577,663$948,333$629,330$47,330$582,001$435,4301.45x
    5$1,617,105$974,928$642,176$48,513$593,663$435,4301.47x

    Year 1 marketing is $90,000 for the launch, falling to $45,000 by Year 3; repairs start low under equipment warranty and rise to $70,000. Year 1 EBITDA falls $275,765 short of debt service, which the $300,000 ramp reserve covers. Year 2 covers 1.09 times. The reserve is the single most important structural term in the file.

    Break-Even Analysis

    MeasureBreak-evenYear 3 baseMargin
    Members at $32 for 1.00x coverage2,0622,600538 members, 20.7%
    Members at $32 for 1.25x coverage2,3852,600215 members, 8.3%
    Blended rate at 2,600 members for 1.00x$25.38$32.0020.7%
    Blended rate for 1.25x$29.36$32.008.3%

    A wash that holds 2,062 members at $32, or 2,600 members at $25.38, still covers its debt. Either a membership shortfall of about a fifth or a price war that pushes the blended rate toward the $24.99 entry tier is survivable. Both together are not.

    Sensitivity and Scenario Analysis

    Scenario (Year 3)RevenueEBITDADSCRValue at 9.00%
    Base$1,539,184$616,6981.42x$6,339,100
    Members minus 10% (2,340)$1,437,306$529,0831.22x$5,399,600
    Members plus 10% (2,860)$1,641,061$704,3131.62x$7,278,700
    Blended rate minus $3$1,443,673$534,5591.23x$5,458,300
    Blended rate plus $3$1,634,694$698,8371.60x$7,220,000
    Retail washes minus 20%$1,435,102$527,1881.21x$5,379,300
    Churn at 8% a month (2,275 members)$1,411,837$507,1801.16x$5,164,700
    Scenario C, price war: $27 blended, $15 retail ticket$1,318,776$427,1470.98x$4,306,500
    Scenario B, approved tunnel opens next door: 1,700 members at $29, 24,000 retail at $16$995,510$169,1390.39x$1,466,000 at 9.50%
    Other variableChangeEffect
    Capitalisation rate8.50% / 9.50%Stabilised value $6,712,000 / $6,005,500
    Bank ratePlus 100 basis pointsDebt service $460,737; Year 3 DSCR 1.34x

    The base case survives any single reasonable stress. It does not survive a price war, and it collapses if the approved tunnel opens next door. That is the shape of the risk in a saturating market: the downside is not a gentle slope but a cliff set by a competitor's decision.

    Loan Sizing: Project Cost, Appraised Value and Coverage

    TestMeasureResult
    Project cost504 debt at 80% of $6,425,500$5,140,400
    First lien against value upon completion$3,212,750 / $5,562,76057.8%
    Combined 504 debt against value upon completion$5,140,400 / $5,562,76092.4%
    Combined 504 debt against value upon stabilisation$5,140,400 / $6,339,10081.1%
    Combined 504 debt against real property and equipment at completion$5,140,400 / $5,164,25099.5%
    Stabilised coverage$616,698 / $435,4301.42x

    The 504 programme sizes the loan on project cost, not on appraised value, which is why a start-up special-purpose project can be financed at all. The appraisal still has to support the structure, and here it does so narrowly. The first lien is comfortable at 58 per cent of the value upon completion. The combined debt is 92 per cent of the going-concern value on opening day and almost all of the tangible collateral. The borrower's 20 per cent, the ramp reserve and the operator's personal guarantees are what stand between the lenders and a loss if the membership ramp stalls.

    Where the Feasibility Conclusion and the Value Conclusion Meet

    The feasibility analysis says the wash covers its debt 1.42 times once 2,600 members are signed, and that it needs a $300,000 reserve to get there. The valuation says the completed wash will be worth about what it cost, but that only half of that value is real estate, and that the gap between the opening-day value and the stabilised value is the $776,000 cost of building the membership base. The two meet in a single condition. Both conclusions assume that no franchised tunnel opens on the next parcel. If one does, the membership base the valuation depends on cannot be built, and the coverage the feasibility analysis depends on cannot be earned. The determination is that the project is feasible with 20 per cent 504 equity and a ramp reserve if the approved tunnel next door is not built, and not feasible if it is.

    Risk Factors

    The approved tunnel is the first risk and the decisive one. Until the permit record places it, the site cannot be cleared.

    Membership pricing is set by competitors. Two operators already sell $19.99 and $24.99 entry plans; a price war takes stabilised coverage below 1.00 times.

    Churn is high. At 7 to 8 per cent a month, the wash must sign roughly 2,000 members a year just to stand still.

    The ramp is uncertain. The 24 to 36-month build cited by practitioners is an industry convention, not a guarantee, and Year 1 depends entirely on the reserve.

    Flood and wind add cost. An AE flood zone and a Gulf Coast location raise elevation, insurance and resilience costs, and a storm can close the wash for weeks.

    Utilities are rising. North Port's rate plan anticipates three years of 10 per cent increases.

    The capital markets have repriced the sector. Distress at Zips and impairments at Driven Brands show that car wash values can fall faster than their cash flows.

    The rules are summarised, not read. Every 504 and SOP 50 10 8.1 provision used here comes from secondary sources and is read against the 1 October 2026 text before commitment.

    Conditions and Limitations

    This is a model study prepared to illustrate feasibility and valuation method on a publicly listed property. It is not an appraisal, it was not prepared under an engagement, it was not prepared for any intended user other than the readers of this site, and no one should rely on it for any decision about the property. UnionMetric did not inspect the property or communicate with its owner, broker, any operator or the city.

    The study relies on the following extraordinary assumptions: that the listing's acreage, zoning, frontage and site plan are accurate; that a car wash is permitted on the site under the 2024 code; that the approved third Tommy's Express is either on the subject parcel or not built (Scenario B tests the alternative); that the land is worth its listed price; and that the 504 provisions apply as summarised. If any proves false, the conclusions may change. The prospective values rest on the extraordinary assumptions that the wash is completed to the stated budget and schedule and that the membership ramp follows the stated model. Rates, membership, retail volume, churn, expenses, capitalisation and discount rates, market rent, equipment depreciation and the bank interest rate are UnionMetric assumptions. Figures are rounded, and totals may differ slightly from the sum of their parts.

    What the Lender Received

    In an engagement on this file, the lender would receive:

    • A permit and entitlement memorandum placing the January 2024 approval by parcel, confirming car wash use under the 2024 code and recording any transferable approvals
    • A competitor census with dated membership and single-wash prices from each operator's website, tunnel lengths, opening years and county tax data
    • One, three and five-mile ring demographics with households, income and vehicles, and an FDOT traffic count
    • A membership model stating acquisition, churn and pricing assumptions, tested against the competitive grid
    • An appraisal by a state-certified general appraiser reporting the prospective values upon completion and upon stabilisation, with the allocation between real property, equipment and business value
    • The cost approach with market-extracted entrepreneurial incentive and measured external obsolescence
    • Loan sizing against project cost, appraised value and coverage, including the ramp reserve, with scenario tests for a price war and an adjacent competitor
    • A data verification register separating primary-verified, secondary and modelled figures

    To discuss a car wash, an SBA 504 special-purpose project or any start-up file, request a feasibility study.

    Sources

    1. 12994 Tamiami Trl S, North Port, FL 34287, land listing, LoopNet, viewed 6 October 2026
    2. Express Car Wash Development Property, Approved by Right, listing, BizQuest, viewed 6 October 2026
    3. North Port, FL Land for Sale, search results, LoopNet, viewed 6 October 2026
    4. Search properties within Sarasota County, FloridaParcels.com, 2026
    5. What's the deal with all of the car washes?, Sun Newspapers, 21 February 2024
    6. 13000 Tamiami Trl, North Port, FL 34287, APN 0997-05-0001, public record page, 2026
    7. City Commission adopts updated ULDC, City of North Port, August 2024
    8. About Us, Utilities Department, City of North Port, accessed October 2026
    9. Resolution No. 2025-R-66, City of North Port, 23 September 2025
    10. Utility account and meter installation fee schedule, City of North Port, 2026
    11. After Ian, North Port residents face exorbitant utility fees, WUSF, November 2022
    12. Ordinance No. 2022-24, City of North Port, 2022
    13. Impact Fee Study Update, Board of County Commissioners workshop, Charlotte County, 19 January 2021
    14. Site Selection, Department of Economic Development, City of North Port, 2026
    15. 6040 Talon Bay Dr, North Port, FL 34287, land listing, LoopNet, 2026
    16. QuickFacts: North Port city, Florida, U.S. Census Bureau, accessed October 2026
    17. North Port, Florida demographics, ACS 2020 to 2024 release, aggregator pages, 2026
    18. Tommy's Express at 1141 Front Pl., North Port, FL 34287, Tommy's Express, accessed 6 October 2026
    19. Tommy's Express at 1155 Sun Market Pl., North Port, Tommy's Express, modified 23 April 2026
    20. North Port Wash Packages, Coastal Express Car Wash, accessed 6 October 2026
    21. Locations, Coastal Express Car Wash, accessed 6 October 2026
    22. 14164 Tamiami Trl, North Port, FL 34287, listing, CommercialCafe, updated 22 September 2025
    23. DJ's Car Wash North Port, Facebook page, 2026
    24. Port Charlotte Car Wash (Coming 2026), Bubble Down, 2026
    25. Mister Car Wash Announces Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2025 Results, Mister Car Wash, 2026
    26. Mister Car Wash, Inc., Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
    27. Mister Car Wash Announces First, Second and Third Quarter 2025 Results, Mister Car Wash, 2025
    28. Mister Car Wash, Inc., Form 8-K, Q1 2026 results, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, 29 April 2026
    29. Mister Car Wash, Inc., Form 8-K filings for 2024 and 2025, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
    30. Mister Car Wash to Be Taken Private by Leonard Green & Partners, February 2026
    31. Mister Car Wash completes $3.1B LGP take-private, PitchBook, May 2026
    32. Mister Car Wash agrees to $7 LGP buyout at 29% premium, Professional Carwashing & Detailing, 2026
    33. Mister Car Wash to go private as growth moderates in 2025, trade press, 2026
    34. Mister Car Wash Q3 2024 earnings call transcript, 2024
    35. Q1 2025 Car Wash Industry Report and Trends, International Carwash Association Pulse data as reported by Auto Laundry News, 2025
    36. Car Wash Industry Statistics 2026, Cinch, 2026
    37. Tunnel Car Wash Trends 2023 to 2025, Cinch, 2025
    38. Unlocking membership growth, Professional Carwashing & Detailing, 2025
    39. Zips Car Wash Chapter 11 first-day declaration summary, ElevenFlo, 2025
    40. Driven Brands sale of U.S. car wash business to Whistle Express, CollisionWeek, 16 April 2025
    41. Cape Coral car wash application pause, WINK News, 17 April 2024
    42. Cape Coral car wash separation code amendment, Modern Storage Media, 2025
    43. Q2 2025 Net Lease Cap Rates: Market Trends and Strategy, B+E, 2025
    44. Net Lease Car Wash, July 2025 report, B+E, 2025
    45. August 2025 Net Lease Car Wash Properties Report, B+E, 2025
    46. November 2025 Net Lease Car Wash Properties Report, B+E, 2025
    47. Commercial Real Estate Cap Rates 2025: What Q4 Data Reveals About the Net Lease Market, B+E, 2026
    48. April 2026 Net Lease Car Wash Properties Report, B+E, 2026
    49. Financing the Cost to Build a Car Wash: 2026 Guide, 2026
    50. Car Wash Construction Costs in 2026: What It Really Takes to Build a Wash, equipment manufacturer publication, 2026
    51. Car Wash Construction Cost 2026: Tunnel, Express and Self-Serve, 2026
    52. Current Debenture Pricing, CDC rate page, September 2026
    53. September 2026 SBA 504 Interest Rates, SomerCor, September 2026
    54. SBA 504 Rate Pricing, Growth Corp, 2026
    55. SBA 504 Rate Information, Capital Partners CDC, 2026
    56. SBA 504 Rates, CDC rate page, 2026
    57. Two Major SBA Announcements: Issuance of SOP 50 10 8.1 and a New Expansion of the ITL Program, National Association of Government Guaranteed Lenders, August 2026
    58. SOP Update: SBA Publishes SOP 50 10 8.1 with Technical Policy Updates, National Association of Government Guaranteed Lenders, September 2026
    59. 13 CFR 120.131, Leasing part of new construction or existing building to another business, eCFR
    60. Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice and Advisory Opinions, including Standards Rule 1-4 and Advisory Opinions 17 and 34, The Appraisal Foundation
    61. The Appraisal of Real Estate, Appraisal Institute
    Get Started Today

    Need to Know if Your Project Works?

    Tell us about your project and we'll send a clear proposal: scope, timeline, and fee.