SBA 504 Feasibility Study: Select-Service Hotel Acquisition, Tier-2 Ohio Market
UnionMetric prepared this SBA 504 feasibility study for a regional SBA 504 lender reviewing a financing request. The mandate scope and analytical conclusions are summarized below.
In 2024 a regional SBA 504 lender asked whether projected RevPAR for a select-service hotel acquisition in Franklin County, Ohio, could be supported by primary market area demand and competitive positioning. The record states that competitive set data supports the assumed RevPAR, that demand generators within ten miles give a year-round occupancy floor, that the set has not added rooms above its prior-cycle peak, and that brand standards fit the budgeted cap-ex. This page explains how those tests reconcile to the lender's value.
The Mandate
A regional hospitality sponsor engaged UnionMetric to prepare a third-party feasibility study supporting a SBA 504 financing request for a project located in Franklin County, Ohio. Total project capitalization fell within the $25 million to $50 million band. The capital provider, a regional SBA 504 lender, required documentation consistent with current SBA 504 program review standards. The analytical question put to the team: whether projected RevPAR could be supported by PMA demand and competitive positioning.
Engagement Scope
- Primary market area defined as a 45-minute trade-area boundary
- Comparable supply set of 17 properties
- Demand model framework: penetration and capture-rate
- Financial projection horizon: five-year
- Site inspection completed; operator interviews where applicable
- Documentation aligned to SBA 504 review standards
Methodology Applied
Primary Market Area
The PMA was defined as a 45-minute trade-area boundary from the subject site, calibrated to the demand catchment behavior typical of hotel assets in Ohio. The boundary captured the population, employment, and competitive supply base relevant to the subject's operating thesis.
Supply and Demand Reconciliation
The comparable supply set comprised 17 properties operating within the PMA or in directly substitutable submarkets. Demand was modeled using a penetration and capture-rate approach over a five-year horizon. The reconciliation tested whether incremental supply, including the subject, could be absorbed within the projection window without compromising stabilized occupancy assumptions.
Capture Rate Calibration
The subject's capture rate was calibrated against the absorption capacity of the PMA. The analysis concluded that PMA absorption capacity exceeded subject build-out by a factor of 2.7x across the projection window, with a stabilized capture rate of 1.2 percent.
Analytical Conclusions
- Smith Travel data for the competitive set supports the assumed RevPAR at the subject's positioning.
- Demand generators within a 10-mile radius produce a year-round occupancy floor consistent with the assumption.
- The competitive set has not added rooms above the prior-cycle peak.
- Brand standards for the chosen flag are consistent with the cap-ex budgeted in the project.
Deliverable
The delivered report ran 164 pages with 28 exhibits across nine analytical sections, plus appendices documenting comparable supply data, demographic inputs, and financial projection assumptions. The document was prepared to the documentation standards of a regional SBA 504 lender reviewing under SBA 504 program requirements.
The premise of value the 504 lender needed
The record describes a hotel acquisition, so the lender's first question is what the property is worth today, not what it could be worth after a plan is executed. For a 504 loan to buy an existing building that needs no construction, SOP 50 10 8.1 has the appraiser estimate market value on an as-is basis and explain any other basis used. The study therefore starts from the as-is premise and treats any renovation as a separate prospective step. The record does not say whether the cap-ex budget crossed the substantial renovation line, which is one-third of the purchase price or fair market value at application; the study tests that ratio first, because crossing it moves the appraisal to a value at completion of construction.
Change of ownership matters here as well. The standard method for a 504 transaction that includes a change of ownership is to size the loan against the lesser of the as-is appraised value and the purchase price of eligible fixed assets, and the property must appraise for 100 percent of the estimated value. An acquisition priced above its as-is value therefore leaves a gap that someone must fund in cash.
A hotel is also a business. The method labelled here as standard for a 504 hotel is a going concern premise: the appraiser allocates separate values to land, building, equipment and the business, including intangibles, and the feasibility study's RevPAR and margin work supports only the real property share of that split. Lenders read the study to see that the flag, the management and the franchise fee are not capitalized into the real estate value that secures the debenture.
Approaches and reconciliation for a select-service hotel
Method, not record: for an operating select-service hotel the income approach carries the most weight, because buyers price these assets on net operating income after a reserve for replacement. The sales comparison approach is a cross-check on price per key, and its reliability depends on how many arm's-length hotel trades the lender can document. The cost approach is a ceiling test: a buyer will not pay materially more than the cost to replace the rooms and common areas, and it matters most when the building is newer.
The RevPAR assumption is the hinge of the income approach. The record states that competitive set data supports the assumed RevPAR at the subject's positioning, which means the study's revenue line starts from observed performance of comparable hotels rather than from a pro forma. The remaining work is translating that revenue into a value: apply a stabilized expense ratio, deduct the reserve, capitalize or discount the result, and then subtract the non-real-property components of the going concern. A lender that sees RevPAR, expense ratio and cap rate reconciled to a per-key figure within the sales comparison range has a credit file it can defend to the CDC and to SBA.
Reconciliation is not an average. The conclusion states which approach governed and why, and the difference between the income value and the sales value is explained in the text. Where the two diverge, the study reports the range to the lender and flags the lower figure, because loan sizing is tested against the appraised value.
Market, site, financial and management tests
The record's four findings map to the five feasibility components that 7 CFR 5001.3 and SOP 50 10 8.1 describe, and each one feeds the value conclusion differently.
- Market: competitive set RevPAR support is the revenue input to the income approach; the finding that the set has not added rooms above its prior-cycle peak limits the supply risk in the stabilized year.
- Site and technical: demand generators within ten miles supporting a year-round occupancy floor tests the seasonal low point, which sets the downside case for debt service; the brand standard and cap-ex finding tests the physical plan against the franchisor's requirements.
- Financial: the stabilized net operating income, less the reserve, is divided by annual debt service on the combined first mortgage and debenture to give the coverage ratio. For all 504 loans the required floor is 1.15:1, calculated on a historical basis, so for an acquisition the study reconciles the seller's trailing results to the projection the buyer will actually run.
- Management: the franchise and operator track record are tested because a flagged hotel that changes hands can reset its performance if the operator changes.
Loan to value is computed on the concluded as-is value, not the purchase price. If the 504 appraisal comes in below 90 percent of the estimated value, the debenture must be reduced or the gap covered with added collateral or borrower investment, unless the loan committee accepts strong and consistent cash flow. A study that shows RevPAR-based coverage well above the floor gives the lender evidence for that discretion.
SBA 504 rules that governed the file
13 CFR 120.160(b) lets SBA require a feasibility study; it does not require one for every loan. SOP 50 10 8.1 names five conditions that may cause SBA to request a study for a 504 loan, and a hotel can fall within one of them: the highly specialized project property. SBA's own list of limited or special purpose property includes hotels, motels and other lodging facilities.
That classification drives the capital stack. A 504 borrower with a limited or special purpose property must contribute at least 15 percent, and the debenture is capped at 35 percent of the project; a new business buying a hotel contributes at least 20 percent under 13 CFR 120.910(a)(3), and the third party loans must total at least 50 percent of project cost under 13 CFR 120.920(a). The CDC debenture generally covers up to 40 percent of project costs under 13 CFR 120.801(c)(2), so the special purpose reductions are the binding constraint here.
The appraisal itself must comply with USPAP, be dated within twelve months of the application, and, for a project property worth more than $1,000,000, be performed by a State-certified appraiser. A 504 loan where the value is above $500,000 requires an appraisal rather than an evaluation. The appraiser for special purpose property must be experienced in the particular industry. The study is written to the credential standard the lender will rely on, and it is not a substitute for the appraisal.
Ohio factors: price disclosure and the tax regime
Ohio requires a Real Property Conveyance Fee Statement of Value, DTE Form 100, listing total consideration and filed with the county auditor. That gives the sales comparison approach a state document to draw on, although the verified record does not say how freely the auditor releases it, so the study confirms access before counting a hotel sale as a comparable.
Ohio's taxable value is 35 percent of appraised value for all real property. County auditors reappraise every parcel once every six years, with a market update in the third year of that cycle, and value is struck as of the January 1 tax lien date. An acquisition in Franklin County therefore raises a question the study must answer: if the purchase price is above the auditor's last value, the next update can lift the assessment, and the income approach should load a tax expense computed on the expected assessment, not the seller's bill.
Ohio's inside millage is 10 mills without voter approval, and other levies generally need voter approval, so the effective rate on the hotel depends on local levies the study reads from the parcel's tax district. Owners challenge a value by filing with the county Board of Revision by March 31 of the following tax year, and a Board decision is appealed to the Board of Tax Appeals with notice due within thirty days of mailing. The SBA Ohio District Office serves the entire state, and its Columbus office serves Franklin County.
Questions about this engagement
Why does the study use an as-is premise for this Franklin County hotel?
The record describes an acquisition. For an existing building that needs no construction, SOP 50 10 8.1 has the appraiser estimate as-is market value, so the study is built to reconcile with that figure.
Does a select-service hotel count as a special purpose property for 504?
SBA's list of limited or special purpose property includes hotels, motels and other lodging facilities. That classification raises the minimum borrower contribution to 15 percent and caps the debenture at 35 percent.
What did the record find about RevPAR?
It states that competitive set data supports the assumed RevPAR at the subject's positioning. The study's role is to carry that finding into a value and a coverage ratio, not to restate performance figures.
Which debt service coverage ratio applies?
For all 504 loans the floor is 1.15:1, calculated on a historical basis. The study reconciles trailing results to the buyer's projection so that the ratio the lender computes matches the one the CDC reviews.
How does Ohio's six-year reappraisal cycle change the analysis?
A purchase can sit well above the auditor's last value. The income approach loads taxes at the expected assessment, since the next update to the 35 percent taxable value can raise the bill.
What happens if the appraisal is low?
If it comes in below 90 percent of the estimated value, the debenture is reduced or the gap is covered by added collateral or investment, unless strong cash flow is accepted.
Related pages
Sources
- U.S. Small Business Administration, SBA Standard Operating Procedure 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, accessed 17 November 2026.
- eCFR, Title 13 CFR 120.160, 120.801, 120.910, 120.920, accessed 17 November 2026.
Related Engagements
Ground-Up Franchised Select-Service Hotel, Sun Belt Secondary Metro
SBA 504 feasibility study supporting a hotel project in Sun Belt Secondary Metro.
110-Key Extended-Stay Hotel, Loudoun County, Virginia
SBA 504 feasibility study supporting a hotel project in Loudoun County.
Ground-Up Taproom-Focused Craft Microbrewery, Growing Suburb
SBA 504 feasibility study supporting a brewery & distillery project in Growing Suburb.