Hotels

    Hospitality Market Outlook for SBA Hotel Development

    September 23, 2026
    25 min read

    The hotel market changed character twice in eighteen months, and the recovery favours least the segments small-business developers actually build. This outlook works through segment performance, supply, operating costs, SBA financing and the arithmetic of a 2026 new build.

    Why this cycle looks different from the one everyone is still describing

    Anyone underwriting a hotel today is working against a market that changed character twice in eighteen months, and most of the commentary still in circulation describes the first change rather than the second.

    The first change came in 2025, when US revenue per available room fell roughly 0.3 percent on the year. That sounds trivial. It was not. It was the first full-year RevPAR decline STR has recorded outside a recession. Occupancy gave back about 1.2 percent, rate growth could not cover the gap, and an industry that had spent three years telling itself that pricing power was structural discovered that it was partly a post-pandemic artifact. Forecasters responded accordingly. CoStar and Tourism Economics opened 2026 projecting RevPAR growth of just 0.6 percent. CBRE started the year at 1.2 percent. PwC was near 0.9 percent. The consensus was a flat year at best. Our hotel industry outlook on the RevPAR decline and record pipeline covered that turn as it happened.

    The second change came in the first half of 2026, and it went the other way. First-quarter RevPAR came in at plus 3.8 percent, the strongest quarter since early 2023. The second quarter accelerated to plus 5.7 percent, with average daily rate up 4.4 percent and demand up 1.7 percent against supply growth of only 0.4 percent. By June, CoStar and Tourism Economics had raised the full-year forecast to 2.8 percent. By August, after a record first half, they raised it again to 4.4 percent, with ADR up 3.1 percent and occupancy back to 63.1 percent. CBRE moved from 1.2 percent to 2.5 percent. STR's Amanda Hite summarised the half as an increase of 11.4 million room nights sold versus 2025 and more than 5.4 billion dollars in additional room revenue.

    So the industry is not in decline. It is also not in the broad-based expansion that the headline numbers imply. The recovery is narrow, and the part of the market it favours least is precisely the part that small-business hotel developers build, buy, and operate. That is the tension this outlook is written around.

    For developers using SBA financing, the practical question is not whether the national RevPAR line is going up. It is whether a 90-key upper-midscale select-service hotel in a secondary market can carry today's debt service at today's construction cost. That answer depends on segment performance, on supply in a specific trade area, on operating cost trajectories, and on a financing environment that tightened materially in 2025 and got more expensive again in September 2026. Each of those is worth taking in turn, and each is a question a hotel feasibility study is built to answer.

    The shape of the recovery: a market that split in two

    The single most useful statistic in this cycle is not national RevPAR. It is the spread between chain scales.

    CBRE's midyear 2026 work forecasts luxury RevPAR growth of 5.2 percent for the year, roughly double the national pace. Midscale is forecast at 0.7 percent. Economy is forecast to decline 0.6 percent. The first quarter showed the same pattern in actuals: luxury up 7.0 percent and resort locations up 6.6 percent at the top, midscale up 0.9 percent and economy down 1.8 percent at the bottom. JLL's 2025 data set the trend a year earlier, with luxury RevPAR up 3 percent while midscale fell 2.8 percent and economy fell 4.4 percent.

    This is a consumer story before it is a lodging story. Higher-income households have carried an increasing share of discretionary travel spending through a period in which lower-wage households have absorbed most of the cumulative inflation of the past four years. Hotels serving the first group have kept pricing power. Hotels serving the second group have been trading rate for occupancy and often losing both.

    Why it matters here: the SBA hotel universe does not sit in the luxury tier. By loan count it skews heavily toward economy and midscale flags, the Super 8, Days Inn, Quality Inn, Comfort Inn, Best Western, La Quinta and Motel 6 end of the business. By dollar volume it shifts up into upper-midscale select-service, the Holiday Inn Express, Hampton, Fairfield and Home2 prototypes. Which means the typical small-business hotel owner is positioned somewhere between the segment growing at 0.7 percent and the segment shrinking at 0.6 percent, while reading headlines about a market growing at 4.4 percent. Our chain-scale opportunity and financeability map sets out where each tier currently finances.

    The strategic conclusion is not to avoid these segments. It is to stop underwriting them off national averages. A pro forma built on national RevPAR growth assumptions applied to a midscale asset is optimistic by two to four percentage points a year before the analyst has looked at a single competitive set. Compounded across a ten-year hold, that is the entire equity return.

    There is a second, more encouraging read available, though. The upper-midscale and upscale segments have the strongest structural position in the supply picture, and extended-stay product within those tiers is running against genuinely different demand drivers than transient midscale. That distinction is doing a lot of work in this cycle, and it is where most of the defensible new development is happening.

    Demand: three sources moving in different directions

    Business transient and group are the engine. CBRE reported convention-linked group RevPAR up 5.4 percent year over year by April 2026, and estimated that excluding the World Cup effect, business transient and convention-linked group demand would account for more than half of total 2026 RevPAR growth. Corporate travel returned in a lumpy, sector-specific way rather than a broad one. The clearest evidence sits in the market-level data: San Francisco led all markets in the first quarter of 2026 with 31 percent RevPAR growth, and Memphis led the second quarter with 20 percent, both driven by technology and artificial intelligence infrastructure investment rather than by any general recovery in office-based travel.

    That pattern is important for site selection. Demand is being created by capital projects, not by a rising tide. A market with a data center under construction, a semiconductor fab, a battery plant, an LNG terminal or a large hospital expansion is getting real, contracted, multi-year room-night demand. A market without one is getting the national average, which for midscale is roughly zero.

    Leisure is stable but no longer the growth story. The 2021 to 2023 leisure surge normalised. Resort locations still outperform, up 6.6 percent in the first quarter, but that strength is concentrated in higher-rate product. Drive-to, value-oriented leisure, which is the core of a great deal of interstate and small-market midscale inventory, is the softest part of the market. The same normalisation is visible in our glamping and outdoor hospitality opportunity map.

    International inbound is the open wound. This is the largest single drag on the US lodging market and the most underappreciated risk in gateway market underwriting. The US Travel Association's May 2026 forecast put 2025 inbound international visits at 68.3 million, down 5.5 percent, driven primarily by a collapse in Canadian travel. Oxford Economics estimated the decline at 5.7 percent, with Canadian visits down roughly 25.7 percent and Mexican visits up 8.6 percent, making Mexico the largest single source market for the first time in more than 25 years. Softness carried into 2026, with overseas arrivals down about 4.3 percent year to date through April.

    Inbound visits are forecast to grow 3.4 percent to 70.6 million in 2026, but a return to the 2019 level of 79 million visits is not expected until 2029. Policy is a meaningful part of the delay: a new 250 dollar visa integrity fee, travel restrictions affecting nineteen countries, and visa wait times approaching four months in several major source markets. Every 1 percent decline in international visitor spending represents roughly 1.8 billion dollars in lost US exports.

    For most SBA-financed hotels, direct international exposure is minimal. The relevance is indirect and it is favourable: weak gateway performance is pushing both institutional capital and brand development attention toward domestic secondary and tertiary markets, which is where small-business hotel development lives. The competitive environment in those markets will get more crowded, not less, over the next three years.

    Supply: the best news in the market

    If there is one structural fact that supports new development economics right now, it is the construction pipeline, and specifically how thin it is.

    Lodging Econometrics reported a second-quarter 2026 US pipeline of 5,975 projects and 703,001 rooms, down roughly 4.9 percent in projects and 4.6 percent in rooms year over year. Under construction: 1,081 projects and 133,216 rooms. Scheduled to start within twelve months: 2,147 projects and 245,871 rooms. Early planning: 2,747 projects and 323,914 rooms.

    Forecast openings are modest and remain so through the end of the decade: 661 hotels and 74,820 rooms in 2026, representing about 1.3 percent inventory growth, then 738 hotels in 2027 at 1.4 percent and 832 hotels in 2028 at 1.5 percent. CBRE's framing is blunter, noting fifteen consecutive months of declining hotel construction and projecting inventory growth of just 0.7 percent compounded annually over the next three years, which it describes as a structural floor under rate growth.

    Two details in the pipeline data matter specifically to small-business developers.

    First, the upper-midscale and upscale chain scales dominate what is being built: 2,225 upper-midscale projects with 214,027 rooms and 1,282 upscale projects with 159,252 rooms, together 59 percent of all projects and 53 percent of all rooms. That is the SBA development corridor, and it is where competitive new supply will land.

    Second, conversions hit a record: 1,567 projects and 152,044 rooms, up 15 percent. Conversion activity is the dominant strategic response to a construction cost environment that makes ground-up hard to pencil, and it is a route small operators can actually access. Buying a tired asset and reflagging it, with a properly sized property improvement plan, remains the most reliable way to acquire rooms below replacement cost in 2026. Our PIP reposition case study financed with SBA 7(a) works through one of those files end to end.

    New project announcements rose 18 percent and construction starts rose 14 percent in the second quarter, at 176 projects and 20,056 rooms, so the trough in development activity appears to be behind us. The geographic concentration is unambiguous: Dallas leads with 183 projects and 22,840 rooms, followed by Atlanta at 157 projects and 17,423 rooms, Nashville at 122 and 16,281, Austin at 116 and 13,875, and Phoenix at 115 and 16,136. Those are the markets where a new entrant is most likely to be underwriting into someone else's supply.

    The takeaway for a developer: nationally, supply is your friend for the first time in a decade. Locally, it may not be. The gap between the national 0.7 percent inventory growth figure and what is actually happening within a three-mile radius of a proposed site in suburban Dallas is the entire feasibility question, and it is the question our hotel feasibility study methodology is designed around.

    Operating costs and the margin problem

    Revenue recovery has been partly consumed at the expense line, and this is where a lot of otherwise sound pro formas break.

    Gross operating profit margins have declined for three consecutive years. The drivers are not mysterious. Insurance premiums rose 17.4 percent in 2024, capping a multi-year run of double-digit increases that has hit coastal, Gulf and Southeast assets hardest. Property taxes rose 4.3 percent. In 2024, expenses above gross operating profit rose 4.1 percent and expenses below it rose 3.6 percent, both well ahead of total revenue growth of 2.3 percent. National GOP margin now sits near 33.5 percent and EBITDA near 24.0 percent.

    Labour remains the largest line and the most structurally changed. Operators are paying roughly 22.1 percent more than in 2019 for 7.4 percent fewer hours worked. The good news is that availability has improved substantially: job openings per hotel fell to 14 in May 2026, down 13 percent year over year. The bad news is that the cost per hour is not going back down, and immigration enforcement has tightened the labour pool in several large hospitality markets.

    STR has cautioned that expenses are expected to rise faster than inflation in both 2026 and 2027. Franchise costs compound this: royalty and marketing fees typically run 4 to 8 percent of gross room revenue, and brand-mandated property improvement plans run 5,000 to 25,000 dollars per room on a cycle the franchisor controls rather than the owner.

    For anyone building a ten-year model, the practical adjustment is to stop indexing expenses to CPI. Insurance in particular should be modelled at a higher growth rate than revenue for at least the first three years, and PIP reserves should be funded as a capital plan rather than assumed away in a four percent FF&E reserve.

    Capital markets: better than 2023, worse than three months ago

    US hotel transaction volume rose 17.5 percent year over year to 24 billion dollars in 2025, up 22 percent from the 2023 trough, according to JLL. New York led at 3.7 billion dollars across 29 trades, followed by Phoenix at 1.5 billion across 22 trades and Washington DC at 1.2 billion across 22 trades. Global volume reached 65 billion dollars, up 7 percent. First-quarter 2026 volume rose 14.4 percent year over year to 5.6 billion dollars, and JLL expects large transactions above 250 million dollars to increase significantly through the year. Roughly 64 billion dollars of hotel loans were executed in the US in 2025, with banks and commercial mortgage-backed securities as the primary sources.

    The mechanism behind that recovery was rate relief. The overall cost of hotel debt fell nearly 300 basis points from the start of the Federal Reserve's cutting cycle in September 2024, which restored positive leverage and reopened a bid-ask spread that had been frozen since 2022.

    That mechanism reversed in September 2026. After five cuts between September 2024 and December 2025 took the Prime Rate from a peak of 8.50 percent down to 6.75 percent, the Federal Open Market Committee raised rates 25 basis points at its 15 to 16 September 2026 meeting, to a federal funds range of 3.75 to 4.00 percent, citing still-elevated inflation. Prime moved to 7.00 percent, the first increase since 2023. Markets pushed the ten-year Treasury toward 5.00 percent from roughly 4.53 percent in June. SOFR sat near 3.64 percent.

    This matters more to small hotel borrowers than to institutional ones, because the small-balance market is more floating-rate and more Prime-indexed. A 25 basis point move on a 5 million dollar variable-rate loan is roughly 12,500 dollars a year of debt service, which on a 90-key select-service hotel is about half a point of occupancy at typical rate levels. Not fatal. But it arrived on top of a base that was already high, and the forward path is no longer a one-way bet on cuts.

    Distress is easing but has not cleared. The overall CMBS delinquency rate was 7.55 percent in March and May 2026, improving to 7.35 percent in June. Lodging specifically improved more: the CMBS lodging delinquency rate fell 79 basis points to 5.22 percent in June 2026 after large portfolio cures, and the lodging special servicing rate fell 91 basis points to 9.10 percent in August 2025. The dominant category of new delinquency is non-performing matured balloon loans, which is to say hotels that cannot refinance at maturity. Where a maturity coincides with a deferred PIP, the asset usually trades. That is the origin of most of the genuinely attractive acquisition opportunities available to small-business buyers right now, and the point at which a hotel appraisal and a feasibility analysis are normally commissioned together.

    The financing environment for small hotels

    Small-business lending for hotels changed in 2025, and the change was a tightening.

    Standard Operating Procedure 50 10 8, effective 1 June 2025, reversed the lending expansions introduced in 2023 and restored a broadly pre-2021 underwriting posture. The headline provisions: a minimum 10 percent equity injection on all start-ups and complete changes of ownership, measured against total project cost; citizenship tightened to 100 percent US citizens or lawful permanent residents, up from 51 percent; the small-loan threshold reduced from 500,000 to 350,000 dollars; the minimum credit score raised from 155 to 165; a 50,000 dollar collateral threshold; and the reinstatement of tax transcript verification and hazard insurance requirements. Seller notes may count toward the equity injection only if placed on full standby for the entire loan term, and only up to 50 percent of the required injection. The franchise directory was reinstated. In a partial change of ownership, the selling party must now provide a limited guarantee of the full loan amount for at least two years regardless of retained ownership. The discretionary "do what you do" underwriting philosophy was eliminated. Hotels sit on the SBA special-purpose property list, which is what drives the feasibility requirement in the first place, and our SBA feasibility study practice is built to that standard.

    The context for those changes is portfolio performance. The 7(a) programme recorded negative cash flow in fiscal 2024 for the first time in more than a decade, on the order of 370 to 400 million dollars. The overall default rate reached 3.7 percent, the highest since 2012. Early defaults, meaning those within eighteen months of origination, roughly tripled between 2022 and 2024 to about 1.5 percent. Guaranteed loan purchases rose from 570 million dollars in 2021 to 1.6 billion in 2024. The Community Advantage programme was put under a moratorium on new licences in May 2025 after producing a 7 percent default rate.

    Hotels, notably, were not the cause. The cumulative charge-off rate on small-business hotel lending sits near 1.8 percent against a seasoned all-industry rate closer to 6.4 percent. The structural reason is straightforward: a twenty-five year fully amortising loan on a real-estate-secured, cash-generating asset operated by its owner survives a downturn far better than a short-balloon loan on a business with no hard collateral. Which is why hotels remain a welcome asset class for small-business lenders even as the broader rulebook tightened, and why the accommodation and food services sector took 16.4 percent of all small-business loan dollars approved in fiscal 2025, the largest share of any sector.

    Programme volume overall continued to grow: 78,078 7(a) loans totalling 37.3 billion dollars in fiscal 2025, a record, up from 70,242 loans and 31.1 billion in fiscal 2024 and 57,362 loans and 27.5 billion in fiscal 2023. The 504 programme moved the other way in count, falling 53.2 percent between fiscal 2021 and fiscal 2025, from 8,117 to 3,799 loans, while average loan size grew to roughly 1.02 million dollars. The practical differences between the two are set out in our SBA 7(a) versus 504 guide.

    Pricing, as of late 2026: 7(a) variable rates were running roughly 9.75 to 13.25 percent against a 6.75 percent Prime base before the September increase, and shift upward by 25 basis points with it. The 504 debenture sale on 6 August 2026 priced at 6.19 percent for the ten-year and 6.27 percent for the twenty and twenty-five year debentures, fixed for the life of the loan. Blended 504 all-in cost, accounting for the bank's first mortgage at roughly 7 to 9 percent, lands around 7.0 to 8.0 percent. Lenders are generally underwriting hotels to a minimum debt service coverage ratio of 1.15 to 1.25 times. Where a purchase involves an operating business, the going concern allocation between real property, FF&E and business value governs how the credit file is assembled, and our SBA acquisition report stack planner shows which reports the file will require.

    One structural change worth flagging: effective 4 July 2026, a borrower may hold a 5 million dollar 7(a) loan and a 5 million dollar 504 debenture simultaneously. That lifts the guaranteed component of a single project to 10 million dollars. For a ground-up hotel this is the difference between a deal that works and one that does not, and it is the most consequential positive development in small-business hotel finance in several years. A worked example sits in our select-service hotel financed with SBA 504 case study. Rural projects should also test eligibility for a USDA feasibility study under the OneRD guaranteed loan rules.

    Development economics: the arithmetic of a new build in 2026

    Here is where the outlook becomes concrete.

    HVS's 2025 US Hotel Development Cost Survey, based on 2024 budgets, put the overall median at 219,000 dollars per room. By segment: limited-service and midscale extended-stay in the 167,000 to 169,000 dollar range, select-service around 223,000 dollars, upscale extended-stay around 265,000 dollars, full-service at 409,000 dollars and luxury above 1,057,000 dollars, with a number of flagship projects exceeding 2 million dollars per key. Dual-branded projects ran roughly 231,000 dollars per key. Preliminary figures from the following survey, reflecting 2025 budgets, point higher, with select-service nearer 200,000 dollars and full-service nearer 467,000.

    Materials costs are a live pressure. Steel and aluminium tariffs rose to 25 percent in March 2025 and 50 percent in June 2025, and copper to 50 percent in August 2025. Associated General Contractors data showed the producer price index for materials and services used in nonresidential construction up 2.5 percent year over year by August 2025, with aluminium mill shapes up 22.8 percent and steel mill products up 13.1 percent. AGC's chief economist Ken Simonson observed that the tariff increases appear to have enabled domestic producers to raise their own selling prices. Engineering News-Record reported twenty-city steel prices up 11.9 percent across 2025 and its building cost index up 4.2 percent. Cushman and Wakefield estimated the tariff effect at roughly 6 percent on materials and about 3 percent on total project cost. Forty-three percent of contractors reported a project cancelled, postponed or scaled back in a recent six-month window because of cost.

    Now run the arithmetic that actually determines whether a deal proceeds.

    A 100-key select-service hotel at 223,000 dollars per key is a 22.3 million dollar project. At 85 percent loan to cost, that is roughly 19 million dollars of debt and 3.3 million of equity, though special-purpose hotel underwriting more typically lands at 15 to 20 percent equity, so call it 3.3 to 4.5 million. At a blended 7.5 percent over twenty-five years, annual debt service on 19 million dollars is approximately 1.69 million. At a 1.25 times coverage requirement, the lender needs roughly 2.11 million dollars of net operating income.

    Assume a 30 percent NOI margin, which is realistic to slightly generous for a select-service asset carrying current insurance and labour costs. That implies about 7.04 million dollars of total revenue, or roughly 70,400 dollars per key. At 100 keys and 365 days, that is a required RevPAR of about 193 dollars, and after allowing for other operated departments, a required rooms RevPAR somewhere near 175 to 185 dollars. At 70 percent occupancy, that requires an ADR of roughly 250 to 264 dollars.

    That is not a select-service number in most secondary markets. It is an upscale number in a strong one.

    The same exercise in 2019, with Prime at 5.00 to 5.50 percent and select-service construction nearer 160,000 dollars per key, produced a required ADR roughly 35 to 45 percent lower. In 2021, with Prime at 3.25 percent, lower still. This is the single hardest fact in the current market, and it explains the pipeline contraction more completely than any sentiment survey.

    There are four levers that make new construction work anyway, and successful 2026 projects are pulling at least two of them:

    Build a cheaper box. Midscale extended-stay at 167,000 to 169,000 dollars per key cuts roughly 25 percent off the capital stack against select-service, and extended-stay operating margins run materially higher because of lower housekeeping frequency and thinner staffing models. This is the single most effective lever available.

    Use the 504 structure and the new stacking rule. Fixed debenture pricing near 6.2 percent against variable 7(a) pricing near 10 percent is a large difference in required NOI. On the 19 million dollar example above, moving the blended cost from 8.5 percent to 7.5 percent reduces required NOI by roughly 150,000 dollars a year, which is about 14 dollars of required RevPAR.

    Capture the depreciation. The tax legislation enacted in July 2025 permanently restored 100 percent bonus depreciation for qualifying property acquired after 19 January 2025. For a hotel, where cost segregation typically reclassifies 20 to 30 percent of project cost into five and seven year property, that is an immediate deduction of several million dollars on a 22 million dollar project. Section 179 expensing rose to a 2.5 million dollar limit with a 4 million dollar phase-out. Section 163(j) reverted to an EBITDA-based definition of adjusted taxable income, adding back depreciation and amortisation and substantially improving interest deductibility on leveraged hotel deals. These are not marginal. On an after-tax basis they can move a project's first-five-year internal rate of return by several hundred basis points.

    Buy instead of build. At a national median of 219,000 dollars per key to build, and with distressed and maturity-driven assets trading well below replacement cost, acquisition plus PIP remains the better risk-adjusted route in most markets. A 90-key asset acquired at 90,000 dollars per key with a 20,000 dollar per key PIP is in at 110,000 against a 223,000 dollar replacement cost, and it opens with existing cash flow rather than a two-year construction and ramp risk.

    Brands and prototypes: extended-stay is where the development is

    The brand pipeline reflects the arithmetic above with unusual clarity. Almost every major franchisor's growth effort is now pointed at extended-stay and conversion product, because those are the two formats that still pencil.

    Choice Hotels reached its thirtieth Everhome Suites opening by June 2026, with a redesigned prototype of roughly 120 keys that cut development cost by about 13 percent, and Choice now accounts for nearly half of all new economy and midscale extended-stay construction underway in the United States. Marriott's StudioRes is a 124-room, 54,000 square foot prototype explicitly designed for guests averaging twenty or more nights and is Marriott's most affordable cost-per-key product. Wyndham's ECHO Suites continues to expand rapidly. Hilton is pushing both Spark, a premium-economy conversion brand with more than 43 hotels open, and LivSmart Studios on the new-build side. Hyatt Studios and IHG's Garner round out the field.

    The demand logic underneath these brands is the same project-based demand described earlier. A 120-key extended-stay hotel near a battery plant under construction, a hospital system expansion, a rail or highway project, or a data center campus is not competing for the same discretionary traveller whose spending has flattened. It is serving contracted, multi-week, corporate-paid demand with a defined duration and an identifiable source. That demand can be evidenced in a feasibility study in a way that generic transient demand cannot, which is why lenders have become noticeably more comfortable with extended-stay proposals than with conventional midscale transient ones.

    For a small-business developer choosing a flag, the questions worth asking a franchisor in 2026 are narrower than they used to be: what is the current all-in cost per key for your prototype including brand-required FF&E, what is the actual PIP cycle and cost history on this brand, what is the total effective fee load including reservation, loyalty and marketing contributions rather than the headline royalty, and what area of protection are you prepared to put in writing. The last of those has become more important as franchisors chase unit growth in exactly the secondary markets where small developers operate.

    Where demand is actually being created

    Market selection has become more decisive than segment selection. A midscale hotel in the right trade area will outperform an upscale hotel in the wrong one, comfortably.

    The markets creating genuine incremental room-night demand in this cycle share a characteristic: a large, capital-intensive, multi-year project with a defined workforce. Concretely, that means advanced manufacturing and reshoring investment, data center and AI infrastructure construction, LNG and energy projects, port and logistics expansion, large medical center and university expansions, military installations and the training and contractor traffic they generate, and the sports and event calendar, which in 2026 included the FIFA World Cup and the America 250 programme and in 2028 includes the Los Angeles Olympics.

    Sun Belt and secondary and tertiary markets continue to take share on migration and employment fundamentals. Interstate corridor product, long the backbone of small-hotel ownership, is more mixed: it benefits from freight and construction traffic but is most exposed to the softness in value-oriented drive-to leisure.

    The markets to approach carefully are the five with the heaviest pipelines, Dallas, Atlanta, Nashville, Austin and Phoenix, where a new entrant is underwriting into meaningful competitive supply, and inbound-dependent gateway markets, which will not see a full international recovery until 2029.

    The practical discipline is to underwrite the demand generator rather than the metro. A feasibility analysis that identifies a named project, its workforce size, its construction schedule and its likely lodging capture is worth more to a lender, and to the developer, than a market-level RevPAR forecast. It is also the form of evidence that survives a credit committee in a tightened underwriting environment. What that work costs is set out in our feasibility study pricing guide.

    Risks worth pricing

    Rate direction is no longer one-way. The September 2026 increase to a 3.75 to 4.00 percent funds range, with Prime at 7.00 percent and the ten-year approaching 5.00 percent, ended an eighteen-month easing narrative. Underwriting should stress at least one further 50 basis point move.

    The consumer is bifurcated. The economy and midscale customer base is the most exposed to any softening in the labour market. A recession would hit these segments before it hit luxury, and they are already the weakest performers.

    Insurance and climate. Double-digit premium increases are structural rather than cyclical for coastal, Gulf and Southeast assets, and insurance is now large enough as a share of the expense base to move valuations on its own.

    Labour cost is permanent. The 22.1 percent increase over 2019 in cost per available hour will not reverse. Minimum wage changes and immigration enforcement both push the same direction.

    Short-term rental competition. Airbnb and comparable platforms reached a 13.5 percent demand share by early 2025, up from 11.3 percent in 2020, and grew RevPAR 8.1 percent. The pressure falls disproportionately on leisure and extended-stay demand, which is precisely where the development activity is concentrated.

    Franchise cost creep. Effective fee loads have risen faster than royalty rates suggest, and PIP requirements are set by a party whose interests are not identical to the owner's.

    International inbound. Not a direct risk to most small hotels, but a continuing drag on national aggregates and a reason to discount gateway comparables.

    Outlook and what to do with it

    Base case for 2027: RevPAR growth of roughly 2.1 percent nationally, with occupancy near 63.4 percent and ADR up about 1.6 percent, per CoStar and Tourism Economics, and a broadly matching CBRE forecast of 2.1 percent. That is a market growing slightly ahead of inflation, with supply growth well below demand growth, and with the same chain-scale divergence intact. Expenses continue to rise faster than revenue, so margin pressure persists into 2027 before supply scarcity begins to give operators more pricing room in 2028.

    For a developer or buyer working through a decision now, the sequence that fits this market is roughly as follows.

    Underwrite to the tightened rulebook rather than to 2021 conditions. Plan on a genuine 10 percent minimum equity injection and expect 15 to 20 percent in practice for a special-purpose hotel, particularly a start-up. Seller financing is a partial solution at best, given the full-standby requirement and the 50 percent cap against the required injection. Confirm the intended flag is on the franchise directory before spending money on third-party reports.

    Model at current cost of capital with a stress case above it. Prime at 7.00 percent for variable-rate debt, roughly 6.2 percent fixed on the debenture side, blended all-in near 7.5 to 8.0 percent, coverage at 1.25 times rather than the 1.15 minimum. If the deal only works at 1.15, it does not work.

    Prefer the structures that lower the cost of capital. The 504 route for real estate and the newly permitted combination of a 5 million dollar 7(a) with a 5 million dollar debenture materially expand what a small-business borrower can build. A 7(a)-only new build is arithmetically constrained: at 85 percent loan to cost, a 5 million dollar loan supports roughly a 5.9 million dollar project, which is about 26 select-service keys, far short of any current prototype.

    Favour extended-stay and conversion over conventional midscale transient new build. Lower cost per key, better margins, more evidenceable demand, and a brand pipeline actively competing for your project.

    Select the site on a named demand generator, not on a metro-level forecast. Then commission an independent feasibility analysis early enough to inform the decision rather than merely to satisfy a lender's file. In a market where the required ADR on a new build has moved this far, the study is not a formality. It is the mechanism by which a developer discovers, before committing equity, whether the rate the model requires is a rate the market will actually pay.

    The market is better than 2025 suggested and narrower than the 2026 headlines imply. Supply scarcity is real and durable, which is the strongest argument for owning hotel rooms in this cycle. Cost of construction and cost of capital are the binding constraints, which is the strongest argument for buying them rather than building them, and for building the cheapest viable box when building is the right answer. The developers who do well over the next three years will be the ones who took the national forecast as context rather than as an assumption.

    This outlook was prepared by Robert Mitchell, MAI, SRA, AI-GRS, and reflects data available as of late September 2026. Performance forecasts, interest rates, debenture pricing and programme rules change frequently and should be verified against current sources before being relied upon for a specific transaction. Nothing here constitutes investment, tax, or legal advice.

    Selected sources: STR and CoStar; Tourism Economics; CBRE Hotels Research, including US Real Estate Market Outlook Midyear Review 2026 and Q2 2026 US Hotel Figures; JLL Hotels and Hospitality; Lodging Econometrics Q2 2026 US Hotel Construction Pipeline Trend Report; HVS US Hotel Development Cost Survey; US Travel Association; Oxford Economics; Associated General Contractors of America; Engineering News-Record; Cushman and Wakefield; Trepp; US Small Business Administration SOP 50 10 8 and programme data; Federal Reserve.

    Looking for a lender-grade hotels feasibility study?

    Related feasibility study engagements

    RM

    Robert Mitchell, MAI, SRA, AI-GRS

    Certified commercial real estate appraiser with extensive experience in hotels property valuations across the United States.

    View team credentials →
    Get Started Today

    Need to Know if Your Project Works?

    Tell us about your project and we'll send a clear proposal: scope, timeline, and fee.