USDA B&I New Hotel Case Study: 80-Room Upper-Midscale Hotel at Gaffney Outlet Marketplace, South Carolina, Not Feasible at 2026 Development Cost
A model feasibility study and valuation of a proposed 80-room upper-midscale hotel on a listed interstate pad in Gaffney, South Carolina, financed with a USDA Business and Industry guaranteed loan. The case is built on the valuation problem that decides most rural new-build hotel files: what the hotel will be worth against what it will cost to build, in a market where a new competitor has just opened next door and much of the new demand is construction work that will end. A federal guarantee changes who bears the loss. It does not change the arithmetic.
By Robert Mitchell, MAI, SRA, AI-GRS, UnionMetric Feasibility | 6 October 2026
Study at a Glance
| Item | Finding |
|---|---|
| Subject site | ±2.698-acre semi-improved pad fronting I-85 at Gaffney Outlet Marketplace, Factory Shops Boulevard, Exit 90, Gaffney, Cherokee County, South Carolina 29341 |
| Listing | Marketed as "ideal for a hotel, full service restaurant, retail, or entertainment users"; price on request |
| Proposed project | 80-room upper-midscale hotel, four storeys, interior corridor, about 48,000 SF, a brand not yet represented in Gaffney |
| Total project cost | $17,109,295 ($213,866 per room), including modelled land of $1,050,000 |
| Financing | USDA B&I guaranteed loan, FY2026 terms: 80% guarantee ($5 million to $25 million), 3.0% upfront fee, 0.55% annual fee; 25% equity for a new business with construction |
| Stabilised performance (Year 3) | 64.0% occupancy, $126.00 ADR, $80.64 RevPAR |
| Prospective value upon completion | $6,730,000 ($84,100 per room) |
| Prospective value upon stabilisation | $7,200,000 ($90,000 per room), 42% of project cost |
| B&I loan at 75% of cost | $12,831,971; stabilised coverage 0.61x |
| Debt the hotel supports at 1.25x | $6,242,556, leaving $10.87 million (63.5%) to equity |
| Discounted collateral | $4,669,674, 36% of the loan |
| ADR at which value equals cost | $251.64 at 64% occupancy, about twice the market |
| Determination | Not feasible at 2026 development cost |
Determination
A new 80-room upper-midscale hotel on the Gaffney Outlet Marketplace pad is not feasible at 2026 development cost. The project would cost $17.1 million, or about $214,000 a room. Stabilised at 64 per cent occupancy and a $126 average rate, which is at the level of the market's established upper-midscale hotel and above its newest one, the hotel would earn net operating income of $630,203 and be worth $7.2 million, or 42 per cent of what it cost. On opening day it would be worth $6.73 million.
The financing cannot bridge that gap. A B&I loan at 75 per cent of cost, $12.8 million, carries debt service of $1.19 million against stabilised EBITDA of $726,313, a coverage of 0.61 times. Stretching the amortisation to the 40 years the programme allows raises coverage only to 0.68 times. At 1.25 times, the hotel supports $6.24 million of debt, so the owner would have to fund $10.87 million, or 63.5 per cent of the project. After the going-concern deduction Part 5001 requires and ordinary collateral discounts, the lender would hold collateral worth 36 per cent of its loan.
The demand is real, and part of it is new. First Solar's $330 million plant, a $2.1 billion data centre and a cluster of smaller industrial projects will put engineers, contractors and trainers in Gaffney rooms through 2027 and 2028. But much of that demand is construction and commissioning that ends, the market lost a 478-employee university in 2025, and the newest competing hotel, an 81-room Holiday Inn Express opened in 2021 next to the pad, has itself been offered for sale. The demand supports the hotels that exist. It does not support building another at today's cost.
Scope, Basis and Data Verification
This is a model study. UnionMetric was not engaged on this property, has no relationship with the seller, the shopping centre owner, the listing broker or any developer, and did not inspect the site. The subject is a real pad publicly listed for sale as of the effective date, 6 October 2026, and marketed for a hotel. It was chosen because it puts the central question of rural hotel development in its clearest form: a well-located interstate site, a real industrial demand story, a federal guarantee programme designed for rural projects, and a development cost that the market's rates cannot carry. The value indications illustrate method on public data and labelled assumptions. They are not an appraisal, they are not an opinion of market value for any intended user, and they must not be relied on in any transaction involving the property.
| Status | Items |
|---|---|
| Primary-verified | The listing text and acreage; Census QuickFacts for Cherokee County; the Cherokee Medical Center bed count; the First Solar, Cielo and Huwell announcements; the FY2026 B&I fee and guarantee table (91 FR 11272); 7 CFR 5001.105(d) equity tiers; the B&I programme page; the South Carolina statewide 2024 lodging data; IHG's own page for the Holiday Inn Express Gaffney |
| Secondary | All traffic counts (2011 and 2015); hotel room counts and opening years; online travel agency rates; national 2025 hotel results; development cost survey figures; franchise fee summaries; Limestone University employment, closure and debt; the Fenner, UFP Packaging and Sticker Mule announcements |
| Not obtained | The pad's parcel ID, asking price, zoning, utility will-serve letters and taxes; competitor taxes and acreage; brand-website rates for fixed stay dates; county-level 2025 and 2026 hotel performance; Gaffney household income and labour force data; the current Holiday Inn Express FDD; a published B&I lender rate; a dated USDA eligibility map screenshot |
| Modelled | Land price, building size and budget, the operating projection and ramp, expenses, taxes, capitalisation and discount rates, the going-concern deduction, collateral discounts and the interest rate |
The Valuation Problem This Case Is Built On
A new hotel has to pass a test an existing one never faces: it must be worth what it costs. Three things stand between the cost and the value in a tertiary market.
The first is rate. Construction cost is set nationally, by materials, labour and brand standards, while room rates are set locally. A hotel that costs the same to build in Gaffney as in a metropolitan suburb earns a fraction of the rate.
The second is supply. Gaffney's newest hotel opened in 2021, next door to the subject pad. A new entrant does not fill an unmet gap; it divides existing demand and must take share or create new demand to reach its projection.
The third is the nature of the new demand. Industrial construction and plant commissioning fill rooms on weeknights for 18 to 36 months, then fall to a much smaller base of vendor and corporate travel. A projection that treats the construction peak as permanent will overstate stabilised occupancy.
For a B&I lender there is a fourth. Part 5001 requires the lender to deduct any going-concern value from the reconciled market value before discounting collateral, and to obtain an as-is and a prospective value for a construction project. On a new hotel, the as-is value of the site with a building that does not yet exist is little more than land, and the prospective value is the forecast the whole loan rests on.
Method. The cost-versus-value test is the feasibility test for any development. Value upon stabilisation must exceed total project cost by enough to pay a developer for the risk of building it. When it falls short, the gap is external obsolescence: the market's way of saying the project should not be built. No financing structure changes the gap; it only decides who absorbs it.
Project Business Plan
The Project is the development and operation of an 80-room upper-midscale hotel on a ±2.698-acre semi-improved pad fronting I-85 at Gaffney Outlet Marketplace, a 360,000 SF, 75-store outlet centre at Exit 90 in Gaffney, Cherokee County, South Carolina. The hotel is a four-storey, interior-corridor building of about 48,000 SF with surface parking at about one space per room plus staff, a fitness room, an outdoor pool, a breakfast area and a small meeting room, operating under an upper-midscale brand not yet represented in Gaffney (a Fairfield- or Tru-type prototype), since the Hampton Inn and Holiday Inn Express flags already operate next to the centre. It operates around the clock with front desk, housekeeping, breakfast and maintenance staff of about 24 full-time equivalents (modelled) under a third-party management agreement. The borrower is a newly formed single-purpose entity that owns the land and the hotel, which makes it a new business under Part 5001. The hotel is positioned as the newest branded product in the market, priced at the level of the Hampton Inn rather than below it, and targets weekday industrial and corporate travel from the new Cherokee County plants, interstate transient demand on I-85 between Charlotte and Greenville-Spartanburg, and weekend leisure from the outlet centre and the region's attractions.
Marketing & Sales Strategy
The pre-opening sales effort targets the industrial pipeline directly: First Solar and its contractors, the data centre builders, the plant equipment vendors and the economic development office that hosts site visits. Project-rate agreements for construction and commissioning crews fill weeknights in the first two years, priced to protect the rate base the hotel needs when those crews leave. The brand's loyalty programme and website carry interstate transient demand. Weekend sales target outlet-centre shoppers, youth sports tournaments in the Upstate and visitors to the Kings Mountain and Cowpens battlefields. The built-in acquisition channel is the brand's loyalty system, the reason for building under a flag that no other Gaffney hotel carries.
Amenities
- 80 guest rooms on four storeys with interior corridors
- Complimentary breakfast area
- Fitness room
- Outdoor pool
- Small meeting room
- Surface parking at about one space per room plus staff
- I-85 frontage at Exit 90, within the Gaffney Outlet Marketplace
Subject Site: Listing, Access, Traffic and Open Items
The listing describes one semi-improved pad of ±2.698 acres fronting I-85, within a 360,000 SF premium outlet centre with 75 stores, with pricing on request. An older undated flyer shows a ±2.34-acre pad in the same position, so the pad has probably been reconfigured and the broker's current survey governs. At 2.698 acres, about 117,500 SF, the pad fits a four or five-storey, 75 to 90-room prototype with surface parking.
The centre sits at Exit 90, the northern end of SC 105 (Hyatt Street). Interstate traffic past the exit was counted at 60,500 vehicles a day in 2015 and 54,200 in 2011; SC 105 at 12,300 and US 29 at 12,400 in 2015. SCDOT reported in August 2025 that the I-85 widening through Spartanburg and Cherokee counties had reached its final layout, with three lanes open in each direction. Current counts are pulled from SCDOT at engagement.
The parcel ID, owner, assessed value and taxes, the zoning and permitted hotel use, and utility will-serve letters were not obtained; the county's parcel search blocked automated access. The model carries land at $1,050,000, about $8.93 per SF, a modelled figure for an interstate outparcel inside an operating centre, replaced by the broker's price.
USDA Rural Area Eligibility
For B&I, 7 CFR 5001.3 defines a rural area as anywhere other than a city or town of more than 50,000 people and the urbanised area contiguous and adjacent to it. Gaffney had 12,764 residents at the 2020 Census, and Cherokee County 58,275 in July 2025, up 3.6 per cent from its 2020 base. Spartanburg, about 20 miles away, has about 38,000 residents, and no city over 50,000 has an urbanised area that reaches Gaffney. On the regulatory definition the site is rural. Rural Development has lent in Gaffney before, including $34.5 million to Limestone University in October 2018 for a library, debt refinancing and a residence hall. In an engagement, the determination is documented with a dated screenshot of the eligibility map query for the parcel.
Market Area and Demand
Demand in Gaffney is moving from education to manufacturing.
| Project | Investment | Jobs | Timing | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Solar, 121 Logistics Drive | $330 million | 600+ | Operations in the second half of 2026 | Announced by the Governor and SC Commerce, 14 November 2025 |
| Cielo Digital Infrastructure data centre, Ford Road | About $2.1 billion | 30 | Not stated | Announced 24 June 2025 |
| Fenner Precision Polymers, 1 Commerce Drive | About $30 million | 51 | Mid-2026 | Reported December 2025 |
| Huwell US, 14 Commerce Drive | $11.6 million | 25 | Not stated | Announced 3 February 2026 |
| UFP Packaging | $5.31 million | 136 | By 2027 | Reported August 2026 |
| Sticker Mule | $18 million | 50 | Not stated | Reported |
| Cherokee Commerce Center 85 (speculative industrial) | $415 million | About 3.6 million SF | Underway | Reported |
These projects add more than 890 direct jobs. Hotel demand from manufacturing comes mainly during construction, equipment installation, commissioning and training, and from vendor and corporate visits once plants run. A 600-job module plant ramping in late 2026 is the most important weekday demand driver for 2027 and 2028. Data centre construction can fill rooms for 18 to 36 months and needs very few after opening.
Against that, Limestone University closed after its final commencement on 3 May 2025. It employed 478 people and generated the athletics, parent and graduation weekends that filled Gaffney rooms; a downtown restaurant owner reported losing about 40 per cent of business after the closure, and court records reported in April 2026 show the university owing Rural Development roughly ten times its $3.4 million bank debt. Cherokee County unemployment was 7.1 per cent in January 2026, well above the state rate, which signals available labour for the new plants and a softer local leisure base. Cherokee Medical Center, a 125-bed hospital, and the outlet centre itself are the steady demand anchors.
National conditions offer no tailwind. U.S. occupancy fell 1.2 per cent in 2025 to 62.3 per cent, with ADR up 0.9 per cent to $160.54 and RevPAR down 0.3 per cent to $100.02, the first full-year declines in occupancy and RevPAR since 2020. Economy hotels fell 8 per cent in late November 2025 while luxury rose. South Carolina's statewide hotels ran 62.8 per cent occupancy, $137.56 ADR and $86.33 RevPAR for January to August 2024, a figure lifted by the coast. No public 2025 or 2026 data exists for Cherokee County; a custom STR set of the Gaffney hotels and the Spartanburg-North I-85 hotels, and Cherokee County accommodations tax collections, replace the proxies at engagement.
Method. Construction demand is a temporary lift, not a permanent base. The study projects occupancy reaching 64 per cent by Year 3, which assumes the plants' permanent travel replaces the construction crews. A credit committee should see a separate test with the construction demand removed; in this case the conclusion does not change, because the project fails even with it.
Competitive Supply: Competitor Census
The Gaffney core set lies within about three miles of Exit 90. Competitor taxes and acreage were not obtained and are collected from the Cherokee County Assessor at engagement; brand-website rates are captured for a fixed Wednesday and Saturday with screenshots.
Competitor Number 1
Holiday Inn Express Gaffney
This 81-room upper-midscale hotel (interior corridor, five guest floors, outdoor pool) was opened in 2021. It is located at 1031 Hyatt Street, Gaffney, SC 29341, next to the outlet centre.
Competitor Number 2
Hampton Inn Gaffney
This 87-room upper-midscale hotel (interior corridor, four floors) was opened in 1999 and renovated in 2017 or 2019. It is located at 115 Nancy Creek Road, Gaffney, SC 29341, next to the outlet centre.
Competitor Number 3
Quality Inn Gaffney I-85
This 83-room midscale hotel is located at 143 Corona Drive, Gaffney, SC.
Competitor Number 4
Baymont by Wyndham Gaffney
This 59-room midscale hotel is located at 101 Stuart Street, Gaffney, SC.
Competitor Number 5
Econo Lodge Gaffney
This 68-room economy hotel is located at 136 Peachoid Road, Gaffney, SC.
Competitor Number 6
Sleep Inn, Red Roof Inn and Super 8
These midscale and economy hotels are located at 834 Windslow Avenue, 132 New Painter Drive and 100 Ellis Ferry Avenue in Gaffney. Their room counts were not verified.
A secondary set 9 to 25 miles away includes the Hampton Inn Spartanburg-North I-85, the Holiday Inn Express and Suites Spartanburg-North, the AmericInn by Wyndham Boiling Springs and the Hampton Inn and Suites Shelby, North Carolina.
| Hotel | Rate evidence | Source type |
|---|---|---|
| Hampton Inn Gaffney | From $124 for the next 30 days; $119 to $132 on booking sites; $119 to $185 on one review site | Brand locations page; booking sites |
| Holiday Inn Express Gaffney | $81 to $88 a night | Booking site, May 2026 |
The newest hotel in the market was selling at $81 to $88 on a booking site while the 1999 Hampton showed $119 and up. Whatever the reason, it is not the rate behaviour of a market short of rooms. A brokerage offering marketed the 2021-built Holiday Inn Express for sale; whether a sale closed is not known. An offering of a near-new competitor next to the subject pad is the clearest signal available about new supply economics in this submarket. No hotel was found under construction or proposed in Gaffney, which is confirmed with city planning and county permits at engagement.
Fair Share and Penetration
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Upper-midscale rooms in the core set today | 168 (Holiday Inn Express 81, Hampton Inn 87) |
| With the subject | 248 |
| Subject's fair share of upper-midscale rooms | 32.3% |
| Existing upper-midscale demand at an assumed 62% occupancy | About 38,000 room nights a year |
| Room nights the subject needs at 64% occupancy | About 18,700 a year |
| Room nights the set needs for all 248 rooms to run 64% | About 57,900 a year |
| New or induced demand required | About 19,900 room nights a year, about 55 rooms a night |
The subject needs the upper-midscale set to find about 55 more occupied rooms every night, permanently, or it must take them from the two hotels already there. The industrial pipeline can supply that during construction. Whether it can after 2028 is the central demand risk, and the study's projection assumes it can.
Occupancy and Rate Projection
| Year | Occupancy | ADR | RevPAR | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (first 12 months, from mid-2028) | 56.0% | $118.00 | $66.08 | New hotel ramp, construction crews on project rates |
| 2 | 62.0% | $122.00 | $75.64 | Brand loyalty contribution builds |
| 3 (stabilised) | 64.0% | $126.00 | $80.64 | About 103 occupancy index, ADR at the Hampton level |
| 4 | 64.0% | $129.15 | $82.66 | ADR plus 2.5% |
| 5 | 64.0% | $132.38 | $84.72 | ADR plus 2.5% |
The projection is not conservative on rate. It prices a new upper-midscale hotel at the level of the established Hampton and well above the Holiday Inn Express's observed booking-site rates, and it assumes stabilised occupancy just above the state average. Every one of those assumptions favours the project, and the project still fails.
Stabilised Operating Statement, Year 3
| Line | Amount | % of revenue | Per room |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rooms revenue | $2,354,688 | 98.0% | $29,434 |
| Other operated revenue | $48,055 | 2.0% | $601 |
| Total revenue | $2,402,743 | 100.0% | $30,034 |
| Rooms expense (24.0% of rooms revenue) | $565,125 | 23.5% | $7,064 |
| Other operated expense | $24,027 | 1.0% | $300 |
| Departmental profit | $1,813,590 | 75.5% | $22,670 |
| Administrative and general | $192,219 | 8.0% | $2,403 |
| Sales and marketing, including loyalty and channel costs | $144,165 | 6.0% | $1,802 |
| Franchise royalty (6% of rooms revenue) | $141,281 | 5.9% | $1,766 |
| Franchise programme fee (4% of rooms revenue) | $94,188 | 3.9% | $1,177 |
| Franchise technology fee ($17 per room per month) | $16,320 | 0.7% | $204 |
| Repairs and maintenance | $96,110 | 4.0% | $1,201 |
| Utilities | $108,123 | 4.5% | $1,352 |
| Gross operating profit | $1,021,184 | 42.5% | $12,765 |
| Base management fee (3.0%) | $72,082 | 3.0% | $901 |
| Property taxes (modelled) | $132,612 | 5.5% | $1,658 |
| Insurance | $90,176 | 3.8% | $1,127 |
| EBITDA | $726,313 | 30.2% | $9,079 |
| Reserve for replacement (4.0%) | $96,110 | 4.0% | $1,201 |
| Net operating income | $630,203 | 26.2% | $7,878 |
Franchise costs follow the published summary of a comparable upper-midscale brand's 2025 Franchise Disclosure Document: a 6 per cent royalty and a 4 per cent programme fee, with loyalty charges (4.9 per cent of the guest folio in that summary) carried in sales and marketing. South Carolina assesses commercial property at 6 per cent of fair market value; taxes are modelled on an assessed value near the income value at a combined millage confirmed with the county at engagement, and any negotiated fee in lieu of taxes would be an upside not assumed here. Repairs start low in a new building, which flatters the early years rather than the later ones.
Highest and Best Use
As though vacant, the pad is zoned for the centre's commercial uses, subject to confirmation with the City of Gaffney or Cherokee County, and it is physically suited to a hotel, with 2.698 acres of I-85 frontage. The listing names four uses: hotel, full-service restaurant, retail and entertainment. The hotel fails the financial feasibility test by more than half its cost. The centre's other pads already carry restaurant use (one adjoins an Outback Steakhouse), and restaurant or retail pad development priced to the centre's traffic and interstate exposure is the more probable use, confirmed by a land residual test at engagement. The highest and best use of the pad as though vacant is restaurant or retail pad development, not a hotel.
Method. A listing's description of a site as "ideal for a hotel" describes its physical fit, not its financial feasibility. The as-vacant analysis tests every legally permissible and physically possible use against the market, and the hotel here is the use with the largest gap between cost and value. The highest and best use conclusion is where a feasibility study first tells the lender what the market thinks of the project.
Development Budget and Cost Approach
| Component | Amount | Per room |
|---|---|---|
| Land (modelled) | $1,050,000 | $13,125 |
| Building construction, four storeys, interior corridor | $11,120,000 | $139,000 |
| Furniture, fixtures and equipment | $1,840,000 | $23,000 |
| Soft costs: design, permits, franchise application, technology, pre-opening and legal | $1,840,000 | $23,000 |
| Construction interest | $650,000 | $8,125 |
| B&I guarantee fee and fee for the loan note guarantee before completion | $359,295 | $4,491 |
| Working capital and pre-opening reserve | $250,000 | $3,125 |
| Total project cost | $17,109,295 | $213,866 |
The development cost excluding land, financing and working capital is $185,000 a room, inside the $175,000 to $205,000 range that Upstate construction costs support for an 80-room upper-midscale prototype and below the select-service median of about $200,000 a room in a national development cost survey published in July 2026. A comparable brand's 2025 FDD puts the initial investment for an 89-room hotel at $15.2 million to $22.2 million excluding real property, or $171,000 to $249,000 a room. Furniture, fixtures and equipment at $23,000 a room sits in the $18,500 to $28,500 range for select-service product.
| Cost approach test | Amount |
|---|---|
| Total project cost, including land, financing and working capital | $17,109,295 |
| Prospective value upon stabilisation | $7,202,324 |
| Market-extracted entrepreneurial incentive | Negative |
| External obsolescence at stabilisation | $9,906,971, or 58% of cost |
The improvements are new, so physical and functional depreciation are nil. The external obsolescence is measured, not assumed: it is the gap between what the hotel costs and what its income is worth. It is the clearest number in this study.
Income Approach: Value Upon Stabilisation
| Test | Inputs | Indicated rate |
|---|---|---|
| Band of investment | 65% loan at 7.50% over 25 years (constant 8.87%); 35% equity at a 10.0% dividend rate | 9.26% |
| New product adjustment | Newest branded hotel in the market, no deferred maintenance, full brand support | Downward |
| Concluded overall rate | 8.75% |
Year 3 NOI of $630,203 capitalised at 8.75 per cent gives $7,202,300, rounded to $7,200,000, or about $90,000 a room. A lower rate of 8.0 per cent would give $7.88 million, and 9.5 per cent $6.63 million; neither comes within half of the cost.
Value Upon Completion
| Step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Year 1 NOI ($486,033), discounted one year at 11.25% | $436,883 |
| Year 2 NOI ($582,792), discounted two years | $470,883 |
| Value upon stabilisation, discounted two years | $5,819,326 |
| Prospective value upon completion | $6,727,092, rounded to $6,730,000 |
| Deduction for the occupancy ramp | $475,232 |
Both values are prospective opinions, effective on the completion date and the stabilisation date, and both rest on the extraordinary assumptions that the hotel is built to budget and opens on schedule and that the demand projection is met.
Going-Concern Deduction and Discounted Collateral
| Step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Prospective value upon completion, going concern | $6,727,092 |
| Less going-concern value (start-up intangibles: assembled workforce, franchise licence, systems), deducted before discounting under 5001.203 | ($200,000) |
| Less furniture, fixtures and equipment, valued separately | ($1,840,000) |
| Real property value upon completion | $4,687,092 |
| Real property discounted at 80% | $3,749,674 |
| FF&E discounted at 50% | $920,000 |
| Discounted collateral value | $4,669,674 |
| Discounted collateral as a share of a $12,831,971 loan | 36.4% |
The going-concern deduction is small on opening day because a new hotel has no established business to deduct; it grows as the hotel builds its accounts and reputation. Part 5001 sets no fixed discount factors, but it requires the lender to justify its discounts by type, quality, location, marketability and alternative uses. A special-purpose building in a market where a two-year-old competitor is for sale would justify a heavier discount than 80 per cent, not a lighter one.
Method. A B&I file reads collateral three times. The appraisal gives the market value. The going-concern deduction removes the part of that value that belongs to the business. The discount converts what is left into what the lender could expect to recover. On a new hotel the first number is a forecast, the second is small, and the third is where an optimistic projection meets a lender's credit policy.
B&I Programme Compliance Under 7 CFR Part 5001
| Requirement | Rule | This file |
|---|---|---|
| Rural area | 5001.3: outside cities over 50,000 and their contiguous urbanised areas | Gaffney 12,764 (2020); rural on the definition |
| Guarantee and fees | FY2026 notice, 91 FR 11272: 80% guarantee from $5 million to $25 million; 3.0% fee on the guaranteed amount; 0.55% annual retention fee on the guaranteed share of the outstanding balance; 0.50% for a loan note guarantee issued before construction completion | $307,967 upfront; $51,328 before completion; about $56,500 a year |
| Equity | 5001.105(d): a new business with a construction project needs 25% balance sheet equity or 25% of total eligible project cost | $4,277,324 at 25% |
| Feasibility study | Required for a new business, the B&I trigger set by the 2024 rule (89 FR 79698) | This study |
| Coverage | No numeric floor in the rule for a project like this one; the only codified floor, 1.1x, applies to majority-purpose refinancing; the lender's policy minimum governs | 1.25x modelled; the file achieves 0.61x |
| Appraisal | 5001.203: USPAP Standards 1 and 2, FIRREA, state Certified General, no more than one year old, reviewed under Standards 3 and 4 before closing; as-is and prospective values for construction; going-concern value deducted before discounting | As above |
| Collateral | 5001.202(b)(4): discounts justified by type, quality, location, marketability and alternative uses; intangible assets not primary collateral | 36% coverage |
| Construction | 5001.205: firm fixed-price contract with an independent general contractor favoured; equity injected before guaranteed loan funds | Required |
| Term | Real estate up to 40 years (programme page) | 25 years modelled; 40 years tested |
The FY2026 rates apply to loans obligated in fiscal year 2026. Fiscal year 2027 began on 1 October 2026 and no FY2027 notice had been published on the effective date, so a loan obligated now takes its terms from the FY2027 notice when it appears. The FY2026 notice also lists a reduced-fee B&I row (1.0 per cent upfront, 0.50 per cent annual, 80 per cent guarantee), available only where its eligibility criteria are met and not assumed here. The 7 CFR Part 5001 handbook sets out every provision used in this section, and the USDA feasibility study consultant page explains who may prepare the study the Agency relies on.
Project Cost Estimate and Loan Assumptions
Location: Factory Shops Boulevard, Gaffney, SC 29341 (Exit 90, I-85) | Rooms: 80 | Size in SF (Gross): 48,000
| Item | Cost | Cost in % | Cost per SF |
|---|---|---|---|
| Land Cost | |||
| Land (±2.698 acres, modelled) | $1,050,000 | 6.1% | $21.88 |
| Hard Cost | |||
| Building Construction, Four Storeys, Interior Corridor | $11,120,000 | 65.0% | $231.67 |
| Total Hard Cost | $11,120,000 | 65.0% | $231.67 |
| Improvements | |||
| Furniture, Fixtures and Equipment | $1,840,000 | 10.8% | $38.33 |
| Total Equipment | $1,840,000 | 10.8% | $38.33 |
| Soft Cost | |||
| Design, Permits, Franchise Application, Technology, Pre-Opening and Legal | $1,840,000 | 10.8% | $38.33 |
| Total Soft Cost | $1,840,000 | 10.8% | $38.33 |
| Financial Cost | |||
| Construction Interest | $650,000 | 3.8% | $13.54 |
| Working Capital and Pre-Opening Reserve | $250,000 | 1.5% | $5.21 |
| B&I Guarantee Fee (3.0% of the guaranteed amount) | $307,967 | 1.8% | $6.42 |
| Fee for Loan Note Guarantee Before Completion (0.50%) | $51,328 | 0.3% | $1.07 |
| Total Financial Cost | $1,259,295 | 7.4% | $26.24 |
| Total Subject Project Cost | $17,109,295 | 100.0% | $356.44 |
Source: 2026 published development cost ranges, franchise disclosure summaries, 91 FR 11272, UnionMetric
| Loan Assumptions | |
|---|---|
| LTC Ratio | 75.0% |
| Loan | $12,831,971 (80% guaranteed, $10,265,577) |
| Equity | $4,277,324 |
| Interest Rate | 7.50% (modelled) |
| Amortisation | 25 years |
| Annual Debt Service (principal and interest plus the annual fee) | $1,194,386 |
Five-Year Pro Forma and Debt Service Coverage
| Year | Occupancy | ADR | RevPAR | Total revenue | GOP | EBITDA | NOI | Debt service | DSCR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 56.0% | $118.00 | $66.08 | $1,968,914 | $833,857 | $564,790 | $486,033 | $1,194,386 | 0.47x |
| 2 | 62.0% | $122.00 | $75.64 | $2,253,763 | $956,855 | $672,942 | $582,792 | $1,194,386 | 0.56x |
| 3 | 64.0% | $126.00 | $80.64 | $2,402,743 | $1,021,184 | $726,313 | $630,203 | $1,194,386 | 0.61x |
| 4 | 64.0% | $129.15 | $82.66 | $2,462,811 | $1,047,122 | $743,765 | $645,253 | $1,194,386 | 0.62x |
| 5 | 64.0% | $132.38 | $84.72 | $2,524,382 | $1,073,708 | $761,620 | $660,644 | $1,194,386 | 0.64x |
The hotel never covers its debt in the projection period. The shortfall in Year 1 alone is $629,596.
Break-Even and Required Performance
| Measure | Result |
|---|---|
| Occupancy for 1.00x coverage at a $126 ADR | Above 90%; not reachable |
| ADR for value to equal cost at 64% occupancy | $251.64 |
| RevPAR for value to equal cost | $161.05, twice the projection |
| Debt supported at 1.25x on stabilised EBITDA | $6,242,556 |
| Equity required at that debt | $10,866,739, or 63.5% of cost |
| All-in cost per room at which value equals cost | About $90,000 |
There is no plausible occupancy or rate at which the project works. It would need roughly double the market's rate, or an all-in cost of about $90,000 a room, less than two-thirds of today's construction cost alone.
Sensitivity Analysis
| Scenario (Year 3) | EBITDA | NOI | Value at 8.75% | DSCR |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base: 64% at $126 | $726,313 | $630,203 | $7,202,300 | 0.61x |
| Occupancy 60% | $665,974 | $575,871 | $6,581,400 | 0.56x |
| Occupancy 68% | $786,652 | $684,535 | $7,823,300 | 0.66x |
| ADR $120 | $680,341 | $588,808 | $6,729,200 | 0.57x |
| ADR $135 | $795,272 | $692,297 | $7,912,000 | 0.67x |
| Upside: 70% at $140 | $934,147 | $817,347 | $9,341,100 | 0.78x |
| Other variable | Change | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Capitalisation rate | 8.00% / 9.50% | Value $7,877,500 / $6,633,700 |
| Amortisation | 30 years / 40 years | Debt service $1,133,141 / $1,069,780; DSCR 0.64x / 0.68x |
Even the upside case, 70 per cent occupancy at $140, which would make the subject the best-performing hotel in the market by a distance, produces a value of 55 per cent of cost and coverage of 0.78 times.
Loan Sizing: What Each Test Allows
| Test | Maximum loan |
|---|---|
| 75% of project cost (25% equity for a new business with construction) | $12,831,971 |
| 1.25x coverage on stabilised EBITDA, 25 years, including the annual fee | $6,242,556 |
| Discounted collateral upon completion | $4,669,674 |
The equity rule would allow $12.8 million. The hotel's cash flow supports half of that, and the collateral less than two-fifths. In most B&I files the coverage test binds and the collateral test follows. Here both fail by such a margin that the structure question never arises.
What Would Work
The demand evidence supports the hotels that exist, not a new one. A buyer who wants the Gaffney industrial demand can reach it by acquiring existing supply at its market value, and B&I can finance an acquisition of an existing business; the two-year-old hotel next door has already been offered for sale. On the subject pad, the restaurant, retail and entertainment uses the listing also names are the ones the market supports. A new hotel here becomes feasible only if development cost falls toward the value of existing product or the market's rates roughly double, and neither is in prospect.
Where the Feasibility Conclusion and the Value Conclusion Meet
The feasibility analysis says the hotel would cover its debt 0.61 times at stabilisation. The valuation says it would be worth 42 per cent of its cost. They are the same finding seen from two sides: the market's rates produce income that supports about $90,000 a room of value and about $78,000 a room of debt, against a cost of $214,000 a room. The determination is that the hotel is not feasible at 2026 development cost, with or without a federal guarantee.
Risk Factors
The cost-value gap is decisive. No assumption in the reasonable range closes it.
The new demand is partly temporary. Construction and commissioning crews leave, and the projection assumes their rooms are replaced by permanent plant travel.
New supply is recent. An 81-room competitor opened next door in 2021, and its rates and its offering for sale signal a market that is not short of rooms.
The university is gone. Limestone's closure removed weekend and event demand, and its unresolved debt to Rural Development is a reminder that federal programmes also absorb losses in this town.
Local data is missing. No county-level hotel performance exists in public sources, and every rate is from a booking site.
Construction risk sits on the borrower. Cost overruns widen a gap that is already 58 per cent of cost.
The fee terms will change. A loan obligated after 1 October 2026 takes its fees from the FY2027 notice.
Conditions and Limitations
This is a model study prepared to illustrate feasibility and valuation method on a publicly listed site. It is not an appraisal, it was not prepared under an engagement, it was not prepared for any intended user other than the readers of this site, and no one should rely on it for any decision about the property. UnionMetric did not inspect the site or communicate with its owner, the centre's operator, the broker, any brand or the city.
The study relies on the extraordinary assumptions that the pad is about 2.698 acres, is zoned for hotel use and has utilities at the site, and that the B&I provisions apply as published in the FY2026 notice and the current eCFR text. The prospective values rest on the extraordinary assumptions that the hotel is built to the stated budget and schedule and that the demand projection is met. Land price, building size and budget, the operating projection, expenses, taxes, capitalisation and discount rates, the going-concern deduction, collateral discounts and the interest rate are UnionMetric assumptions. Figures are rounded, and totals may differ slightly from the sum of their parts.
What the Lender Received
In an engagement on this file, the lender would receive:
- A dated USDA eligibility map determination, zoning confirmation and utility will-serve letters
- A demand analysis that separates construction and commissioning demand from the permanent base, with a test that removes the construction demand
- A custom STR set for the Gaffney and Spartanburg-North I-85 hotels, accommodations tax data and dated brand-website rate captures
- A fair share and penetration analysis showing the room nights the subject must take or create
- An appraisal by a state Certified General appraiser reporting the as-is value, the prospective values upon completion and upon stabilisation, and the going-concern deduction
- The cost-versus-value test, the highest and best use of the pad as though vacant, and the required-performance analysis
- Loan sizing against the equity rule, coverage and discounted collateral
- A data verification register separating primary-verified, secondary and modelled figures
To discuss a hotel development, a rural project under B&I or any new-business file, request a feasibility study.
Sources
- Factory Shops Blvd, Gaffney, SC 29341, ±2.698 Acre Outparcel, Gaffney Outlet Marketplace, listing 23879422, LoopNet, accessed 6 October 2026
- Gaffney Outlet Marketplace, marketing flyer, undated
- About Gaffney Outlet Marketplace, Simon Property Group, accessed 2026
- South Carolina Highway 105, accessed 2026
- Roadway Network chapter, Appalachian Council of Governments, citing SCDOT 2015 counts
- Route station AADT sheets, SCDOT, archived by the South Carolina State Library, 2011
- SCDOT announces major traffic shift on I-85 in Spartanburg and Cherokee counties, SCDOT, August 2025
- 202 Hyatt St, Gaffney, SC 29341, public record page, LoopNet, tax year 2025
- QuickFacts: Cherokee County, South Carolina, U.S. Census Bureau, V2025
- Gaffney, SC profile data, Census Reporter, accessed 2026
- College town without a college: A year after Limestone's closure, $38M debt stalls efforts to move on, Post and Courier, April 2026
- Limestone University to close at end of spring 2025 academic semester, WLTX, 30 April 2025
- Limestone University closure coverage, Fox Carolina, 30 April 2025
- Limestone University faces possible closure, WSPA, 2025
- Limestone University closure, Inside Higher Ed, 1 May 2025
- Cherokee Medical Center, Spartanburg Regional Healthcare System, accessed 2026
- Spartanburg Regional Healthcare System facilities, accessed 2026
- First Solar, Inc. grows South Carolina footprint with new Cherokee County facility, Office of the Governor of South Carolina, 14 November 2025
- Cielo Digital Infrastructure selects Cherokee County for first South Carolina development project, Office of the Governor of South Carolina, 24 June 2025
- New $30M Fenner Precision Polymers facility brings more jobs to Cherokee County, Fox Carolina, 16 December 2025
- Huwell US Inc. selects Cherokee County for first US operation, Office of the Governor of South Carolina, 3 February 2026
- UFP Packaging Opens Gaffney, SC Plant, Adds 136 Jobs, Hoodline, August 2026
- Company to invest $18M with new Gaffney facility, SCBiz, 2026
- Holiday Inn Express Gaffney, property record, Travel Weekly, 2026
- Gaffney, SC hotels, Hotel and Travel Index search, Travel Weekly, 2026
- Holiday Inn Express Gaffney, IHG, accessed 2026
- Hampton Inn Gaffney, property record, Travel Weekly, 2026
- Hampton Inn Gaffney reviews and prices, Tripadvisor, 2026
- Hotels in Gaffney, SC, Hilton, 2026
- Hampton Inn Gaffney, 115 Nancy Creek Rd, HotelPlanner, 2026
- Hotels near Gaffney Outlet Marketplace, Travelocity, May 2026
- Top hotels in Gaffney, SC, booking site listings, 2026
- The best hotels in Gaffney, SC, Tripadvisor, 2026
- Red Roof Inn Gaffney, Red Roof, 2026
- Super 8 by Wyndham Gaffney, Wyndham, 2026
- Gaffney South Carolina hotels and motels directory, 2026
- 1031 Hyatt Street, Gaffney, SC 29341, hotel offering page, undated
- CoStar full-year 2025 U.S. hotel performance, press release, CoStar, 20 January 2026
- STR Weekly Insights: 16 to 29 November 2025, Hospitality Net, December 2025
- Lodging Outlook, South Carolina Department of Parks, Recreation and Tourism (STR data), August 2024, South Carolina State Library
- Hampton by Hilton franchise costs and fees, 2025 FDD summary, FDD Exchange, 2025
- U.S. Hotel Development Cost Survey, published 13 July 2026
- Hotel construction cost calculator, DataDrivenAEC, 2026
- OneRD Annual Notice of Guarantee Fee Rates, Periodic Retention Fee Rates, Loan Guarantee Percentage and Fee for Issuance of the Loan Note Guarantee Prior to Construction Completion for Fiscal Year 2026, 91 FR 11272, Federal Register, 9 March 2026
- 7 CFR 5001.105, Eligible B&I projects and requirements, eCFR, current as of 2 October 2026
- 7 CFR Part 5001, Subpart B, Eligibility Provisions, eCFR, 2026
- 7 CFR Part 5001, Subpart C, Origination Provisions (5001.202, 5001.203 and 5001.205), eCFR, 2026
- 7 CFR 5001.3, Definitions, eCFR, 2026
- Business and Industry Guaranteed Loan programme page, USDA Rural Development, 2026
- OneRD Guaranteed Loan Program final rule, 89 FR 79698, Federal Register, 30 September 2024
- Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice and Advisory Opinions, including Advisory Opinion 34, The Appraisal Foundation
- Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines, federal banking agencies, December 2010
Related services and regulatory reading
- 2026 Feasibility Methodology Atlas
- Hotel feasibility study
- Hotel engagement hub
- USDA B&I engagements
- Hospitality market outlook
- USDA feasibility study consultant
- USDA feasibility study
- 7 CFR Part 5001 Handbook
- USDA Rural Development programmes
- Feasibility Study Methodology for SBA and USDA Loans: The Valuation and Market Analysis Methods a Consultant Should Apply
- Feasibility Study Methodology: A Comprehensive Framework for CRE Development and Acquisition Analysis
- DSCR in Feasibility Studies: The Complete Guide for Lenders, Developers, and Investors
- Sensitivity Analysis in Feasibility Studies: The Complete Guide for Lenders, Developers, and Investors
- Rationalizing the Development Budget: How a Feasibility Study Tests Project Cost Across Seven Asset Classes
- Rationalizing Operating Expenses Across Seven Asset Classes: Normalization, Benchmarks and Valuation for Lender-Grade Feasibility Studies (2026)
- Operating Expense Ratios and Cap Rates by Asset Class: The 2026 Benchmark Reference for Feasibility Studies and Valuation
- Hotel Feasibility Studies: When SBA Requires One, and Why the Pipeline Decides the Answer
- Going-Concern Allocation: The Two Numbers Holding It Up Are Both Market Studies
- Prospective Value: The Gap Between Two of Your Three Numbers Is a Feasibility Study
- How USDA Deducts Going-Concern Value From Collateral: Hotels, Gas Stations and Car Washes
- U.S. Hotel Industry 2026: First RevPAR Decline Since 2020 Meets Record Pipeline
- Hotel Feasibility Study by Chain Scale: The 2026 U.S. Opportunity and Financeability Map